|
Press reviews of Chris Cornell's
acoustic album, Songbook: [read my own review here]

From B.Ives of No
Expiration:
I saw Chris Cornell on his
solo tour last year, and was blown away, so I was glad when I heard he
was putting out a live Songbook album. Like Eddie Vedder, Chris Cornell
is making a good case for having parallel careers with a band, and as
a solo acoustic troubadour.
The album starts and ends with brand new songs that
he hadn't released before this. [Not quite true - As Hope And Promise
Fade was the secret track on Scream - webmaster] The first two tracks
"As Hope And Promise Fade" and "Scar On The Sky" show
that he still has lots of great songs in him. It's hard to imagine Soundgarden
(or even Audioslave) doing "As Hope And Promise Fade." I would
imagine this is the direction his solo career will go in. He sings really
honestly about some of his issues. The line "You're never more than
two drinks away from crying" kills me. "Scar On The Sky"
sounds like it could be a classic Soundgarden slow tune. I just wonder:
can he still write rockers?
The LP ends with "The Keeper," a studio
track (not from the live performances) that he recorded for the film Machine
Gun Preacher. It's an amazing song (I haven't seen the film) that somehow
lost to Madonna's "Masterpiece" (cough) from a film she directed
W.E. I like Madonna, but Chris's song is way better (and so is Mary J.
Blige's "The Living Proof" from The Help).
Back to Songbook: most of the album is solo versions
of Chris' songs from Soundgarden, Audioslave, Temple Of The Dog and his
solo records. He does great versions of these classics. Soundgarden's
"Black Hole Sun" and "Fell On Black Days" sound even
more black, and the Audioslave tunes are just as soulful, stripped of
their (amazing, face-melting) arrangements. I love "Doesn't Remind
Me" and "Like A Stone." Of course, the Temple songs are
incredible. And the album points out that Chris has had some great solo
songs - and (sorry) that maybe his much-mocked Scream album would have
been better with a producer other than Timbaland. I love lots of records
that Timba has worked on, but I just don't think that that combo worked.
Maybe someone like Flood or Danger Mouse could do a great, modern-sounding
Chris solo record.
My only "complaint?" Well, I would have
loved to hear the Bruce Springsteen covers that Chris performed when I
saw him: "Atlantic City" and "State Trooper." And
the "bonus tracks" on the album are "different" versions
of "As Hope And Promise Fade" and "Call Me A Dog,"
that aren't much different from the non-bonus track versions of those
same songs, on this same album. But I'm not a negative guy, so I'll just
hope for a Songbook Vol. 2. But let's get that new Soundgarden record
first!
From Tom Hersey of Rave
Magazine:
Recorded across the American leg of his recent run
of solo shows, Songbook is a collection of grunge rock survivor Chris
Cornell belting out some very iconic rock songs and compiling them with
liner notes curiously provided by actor Josh Brolin.
With minimal instrumentation to confuse matters, Songbook
captures Cornells powerful voice as the Soundgarden main man wails
and croons his way through a set of songs that have defined not only his
career, but songs like John Lennons Imagine and Led Zepplins
Thank You, which helped shape an entire generation of rock music. Even
during these cover numbers, the songs are indelibly stamped by Cornell
and his distinctive booming voice, sounding something like a yodel hybridised
with a croon, and on the CD the singers voice captivates as it does
live. The collection is light on Cornells work with Soundgarden,
even though cuts like the subdued, diminutive rendition of Black Hole
Sun, where his acoustic guitar drops out and Cornell works through the
verses almost a cappella, stand out as the albums most enjoyable
moments.
Songbook focuses more on Cornells latter-day
output, as his solo material is more suited to the stripped down format
of the shows (the difference between the live material and new solo effort
The Keeper, the one studio song recorded specifically for the album, is
negligible), but the material that Cornell originally recorded with bands
like Soundgarden and Temple Of The Dog, and to a lesser extent Audioslave,
demonstrate Cornell when he was at the height of his creative prowess.
From Ben Hughes of Uber
Rock:
When I first heard that Chris
Cornell would be doing a solo acoustic tour in intimate venues earlier
in the year the first thing I though was "wouldn't a live acoustic
Chris Cornell album be a great thing" and lo and behold, here it
is in my stereo as a type. Acoustically his material has always shined,
since first hearing the beautiful 'Seasons' from the 'Singles' soundtrack
I have always yearned for more acoustic material from the man. So to finally
have in my hands a full acoustic live album from one of the greatest vocalists
in rock music it's like Christmas has come early.
An album primarily released for the fans who witnessed
the Songbook Tour, this stripped down, live acoustic album from the Soundgarden
and ex-Audioslave vocalist is a testament to how good a man and his songs
can be, taking the songs back to their original form just Chris and his
acoustic and a bunch of great songs. It's something the fans have wanted,
and he has delivered.
All parts of his career are covered here; Soundgarden, Temple of the Dog,
Audioslave and the solo material, plus a couple of covers for good measure.
The songs were recorded during April this year on various dates across
America and Canada.
'As Hope And Promises Fade' opens the album, a song
I was unfamiliar with and it took me a bit of Google action to discover
its origins, I can tell you. Turns out it was a hidden track on the 'Scream'
album titled 'Two Drink Minimum', a basic blues song and very different
from the Timbaland produced album. Here re-titled with the opening line
of the song it's a melancholy opening that sets the tone for the album,
showcasing the depth and power of Cornell's voice from the off, it's great
stuff. Next up 'Scar On The Sky', the lone song from 'Carry On', works
well acoustic, but it's track three I really have been looking forward
to hearing; 'Call Me A Dog' is one of my favourite songs of all time,
here acoustic and laid bare it fits the mood of the original song and
still has the power to stir emotions and bring a tear to the eye...sublime
indeed.
More highlights? There are many, of course the maybe
obvious Soundgarden tracks are present and correct, 'Black Hole Sun' and
'Fell On Black Days' are excellent as they should be. Audioslave are represented
with personally their strongest and most Cornell-like songs 'Like A Stone'
and the fantastic 'I Am The Highway' which always has me singing along,
it's another 'goosebumps' moment. The lesser known 'Wide Awake' and especially
'Doesn't Remind Me' benefit from the acoustic treatment and sounds far
superior to the original.
The solo material stands up well against the classics,
'Can't Change Me' from the underrated 'Euphoria Morning', an album he
still hasn't bettered, is good here; it's a good mix of old and new, something
to please everyone.
He adds a couple of covers here, a fairly standard
take on Zep's 'Thank You' works well, and, introduced as "a good
Easter song", Lennon's 'Imagine' is one of those classic songs that
should not really be fucked with, but if anyone can get away with it,
it's going to be Chris Cornell, but does he pull it off.....? Well actually
he does it justice, but it ain't the original.
Vocally there are no mistakes, the odd bum guitar
note just adds to the live feel, and keeps it 'as it was' so to speak.
His voice never falters on this album: Jesus, when he hits those high
notes you feel it from your head to your toes. The power and delivery
are inspiring and puts many singers to shame.
Unlike the recent, and frankly disappointing, Soundgarden
live album 'Songbook' doesn't suffer from skipping from show to show,
the songs do fade in and out but it is not something you really notice.
Although the mood is generally melancholy throughout it is far from dull,
it has the same feel that the Temple Of The Dog album has and that can
only be a good thing.
Tagged on the end seemingly only because it features
in the new film 'Machine Gun Preacher' is the original Cornell composition
'The Keeper' which actually keeps faithfull to the mood of the album,
reminding me funnily enough of the Eddie Vedder soundtrack album 'Into
The Wild'; it's an upbeat, sweet acoustic countrified tune that rounds
thing off nicely.
Any fan of Chris Cornell past or present should be
happy to have this in their collection. It's a thumbs up from me.
From Lucy Sanderson of Bring
the Noise:
Behold, a selection of words
that will make a lot of people very excited indeed. Chris Cornell. Singing
tracks from all of his former incarnations in Soundgarden, Audioslave
and Temple of The Dog as well as covering Led Zeppelin and John Lennon.
All live and acoustic. Pretty good, right? You know youve reached
legendary status when you can release an album entitled Songbook,
and every note sung by Cornell proves that hes worthy of such acclaim.
Its the first live album hes recorded
as a solo artist, but it is a truly arresting experience throughout the
mammoth sixteen track listing. The combination of that voice with the
sound of acoustic guitar is as simple, substantial and satisfying as a
hunk of bread and butter
and lets face it, hunk is an appropriate
word when it comes to Chris Cornell. Judging by the sporadic predominantly
female whooping sprinkled throughout the tour recordings, theres
a lot of people who are in the firm belief that at 47 years old, hes
still got it.
It goes without saying that Cornell classics like
Soundgardens Black Hole Sun and Audioslaves Like
A Stone sound sublime on this record. The testosterone-smothered
growl that weaves through those stripped back iconic choruses are as colossal,
yet beguiling as the purr of a sleeping lion. New solo originals The
Keeper and Cleaning My Gun sound totally befitting of
this impressive songbook, but its with the cover tracks that the
record hits a sumptuous high. A uniquely rugged rendition of Lennons
Imagine is a thing of pure beauty, but its a delectably
gravelly performance of Zeppelins Thank You that really
hits the spot. With a voice made to tackle classic rock, its what
your ears have always been waiting for.
From Michael Llerena of Live
Music Guide:
Chris Cornell has been one
of the most dominant and iconic rock voices of the last 20 years. Having
fronted Soundgarden, Audioslave and Temple of the Dog, Cornell is very
much accustomed to having his raspy crooning backed by a wall of distortion
and cymbals crashing. However, Cornells latest live solo record
Songbook throws caution and convention to the wind, arming himself only
with an acoustic guitar and those golden vocal chords.
The album comprises Cornells entire career in
retrospective, stripping down old hits and deep cuts, as well as putting
a new spin on classic rock standards. Cornells limited, but engaging
stage banter offer a humanistic warmth that only live albums like this
can offer.
Coming strong right out of the gate, As Hope
and Promise Fade is nothing if not a trump card to any critics claiming
that Cornell had gone downhill since his time in Soundgarden. Folk-inflected
blues guitar paired with the singers trademark soulful wailing immediately
remind listeners that he hasnt lost his touch.
Call Me a Dog is Cornell unequivocally
at his finest. Channeling his unbridled tenor from the Temple of the Dog
era, Cornell soars over aching minor guitar melodies. Distant crowd applause
can be heard as he hits some insanely high notes in the bridge.
The slower, stripped down version of Ground
Zero will intrigue many fans who have heard its more synthesized,
beat-driven counterpart. Here, Cornells coarse vocals evoke a frustration
with the paranoia and despair of post-9/11 America.
Even in the midst of an already delicate, acoustic
ambiance, Cornell reaches the epitome of vulnerable on the unreleased
gem Cleaning My Gun. In a moody ballad about contemplating
suicide in the wake of lost love, Cornell croons And as you lay
sleeping with your eyes softly shut I'll be cleaning my gun/When heaven
or hell takes this life, I'll be done.
One of this albums greatest strengths is how
stripped down versions of guitar rock anthems can come across even more
powerful than their louder counterparts. Acoustic performances of Like
a Stone and Black Hole Sun remove all but bare bones
melodies, letting Cornells effortlessly soulful voice carry the
song.
This notion of acoustic versions superseding the original
studio recordings is also evident on Cornell standards like Wide
Awake and Fell on Black Days. The former track features
some of the singers most politically charged lyrics with lines like
Down on the road the world is floating by/The poor and undefended
left behind/While you're somewhere trading lives for oil/As if the whole
world were blind.
Stellar covers of Led Zeppelins Thank
You and John Lennons Imagine show Cornell paying
tribute to his influences.
While Cornells previous solo work has always
been eclipsed by his tenure in Soundgarden, Songbook has earned its place
as a coveted piece in his lengthy body of work. After more than twenty
years in the game, Cornells voice has not lost its power, nor have
his songs lost their spark.
From Mark Murphy of Oxygen.ie:
In between fronting the multi-platinum,
award-winning bands Soundgarden and Audioslave, Chris Cornell has often
dabbled in the acoustic from the song Seasons for the 1992 Cameron
Crowe film Singles, to his 1999 solo debut Euphoria Morning and now his
first live album, Songbook; documenting a recent American acoustic tour.
Its an understated aspect of his repertoire
and one often overlooked, but Songbook is disarming enough to change that
perception. Songbook is remarkable for tying together Cornells multitude
of disparate musical ropes.
Material for the tour has been culled from every aspect
of Cornells career to date, from Soundgarden to Temple of the Dog
to Audioslave to his solo material. It even includes an unreleased track
originally written for Johnny Cash in the mid-90s called Cleaning My Gun.
Of particular note is a studio recording of The Keeper, a track written
for the film Machine Gun Preacher.
Its speedy fingerpicking isnt too far removed from Seasons, and
if he decides to release a full studio acoustic album in the future its
a good indicator of the potential therein for such a project. Instead
of a mash of contrasting styles grinding against each other from song
to song, we are in fact left with a cohesive set, with Cornell in some
cases totally reworking rhythms to fit his slower, sparser acoustic style.
Even Ground Zero, taken from the unfortunate R&B
experiment album Scream, is reworked totally, and feels more at home here
than it ever did. Its a quiet joy to hear the powerful, downtrodden
psychedelic Soundgarden songs Fell on Black Days and Black Hole Sun reduced
to just guitar and voice, as if they were ever intended to be delivered
in any other style.
John Lennons Imagine and Led Zeppelins
Thank You are both covered here and the former in particular is one of
the better recorded versions, paying a certain amount of respect but twisting
and turning it into a song that only Cornell can pull off.
The near-mumbling of the lyrics on Thank You is jarring;
slurred together yet as intense as the most scorching of Soundgarden tracks.
Cornells voice, being a focus of constant discussion, sounds better
than ever. Regardless of his range, which is as expansive as it ever was,
on these slower acoustic songs hes given a platform to display his
agility, poise, strength and timing.
Lyrics roll out, stained and powerful, sombre and
rough, disappearing into the guitars notes and off into the darkness
of the crowd. When he belts out, holds and raises a single note, as the
guitar strum drops off for a bar, you can hear his throat strain and his
voice stretch like no other singer can.
Songbook isnt Cornell lazily firing off acoustic
versions of his back catalogue, its Cornell typing up his career
to date and crafting something completely new in the process. Cant
change me? We wouldnt even think of trying, Chris.
From Jeremy Stevens of The
Au Review:
Chris Cornell truly is a
musical powerhouse. Most widely known as the lead vocalist and guitarist
of Seattle's grunge pioneers, Soundgarden - who will be visiting our shores
for the 2012 Big Day Out tour very soon - his work with other bands such
as Audioslave, and his solo output, have secured him a wide-reaching base
of passionate supporters.
Songbook consists of various live recordings from
Cornell's solo acoustic Songbook Tour across America, and for fans of
the guy, has a wide selection of songs spanning his entire career, including
Led Zeppelin and John Lennon covers. Its fair to say that this is
aimed not only towards his most devoted fans, but also for newbies like
myself - and it hits the mark.
One of the most noticeable things about this live
release is its atmosphere. Its mixed in such a way as to incorporate
the crowd and the venue acoustics without detracting from Cornells
rich performance, and whether you like his music or not, theres
no doubt that it sounds great.
That aside, his live efforts themselves are engrossing.
His wide-reaching vocal range sounds controlled and held with restraint,
expanding and contracting just enough with every emotional nuance and
turn. There's still a characteristic hint of grungey husk present, but
only in the most intense outpourings does it become overbearing. Armed
with an acoustic guitar, stand-outs like Call Me a Dog and
Cleaning My Gun see Cornells tremendous falsetto take
flight, and Black Hole Sun sounds brilliant stripped back.
This is a live album thatll be enjoyed by both
Cornell's devoted fans, and those unfamiliar with his work. Songs full
of feeling run through this release, and it's special to hear one man
alone on a stage playing with such sincerity and talent.
From Jack Foley of Indie
London:
TO MARK the success of his
Songbook tour, American alt-rock music legend Chris Cornell has decided
to release an accompanying album and its easy to see why
the tour dates have drawn such favourable reviews.
The album features songs written by Cornell as well
as a few cover versions, showcasing them in a new context by keeping them
all stripped back and acoustically based.
As a result, his rich, distinctive voice can really
take centre stage, while the lyrics are laid bare.
This lends extra resonance to crowd-pleasing moments
such as Ground Zero, which is about getting over the shitty, shitty
horror of 9/11 and the atmosphere of hate that resulted. As he says
during the introduction to it: Its about trying to figure
out how we can make the world better instead of stupider.
The song is impassioned yet hopeful and a really thoughtful
response to the emotional fallout of that terrible day in history.
Similarly, the road-trip themed I Am The Highway,
which allows for more personal introspection, or the sensitive Led Zeppelin
cover that is Thank You, another favourite.
The acoustic backdrop occasionally comes alive, too,
showcasing that rockier side to the Cornell make-up. Fell On Black Days
contains some cracking guitar work and distinct riff-making that serve
as a potent reminder of Cornells alt-rock roots. Its also
another track to make sure you hear.
I also really liked the acoustic makeover given to
the richly melodic Doesnt Remind Me, an homage to originality and
unique experiences, that deservedly draws hand-clap support from the crowds.
Admittedly, Cornell gets a little over-excited vocally towards the end
but thats a small price to pay. Its a great song.
Of course, the biggest cheer goes out for the Soundgarden
all-time classic Black Hole Sun, which doesnt disappoint, but his
rendition of John Lennons Imagine (described as a good Easter
song) is beautifully assured and still highly resonant in todays
world, while The Keeper is a suitably thought-provoking finale.
All told, this is a fine collection of songs, re-interpreted
for maximum emotional impact and capable of appeal to both die-hard fans
and newcomers alike. Hats off to Cornell for making it so.
From Simon Gallagher of What
Culture:
As lead singer for Soundgarden
and Audioslave, Chris Cornell carved out a reputation as one of the finest
rock singers of his or any generation, and in Songbook, his brand new
acoustic live solo album, he proves once again what that reputation was
founded on. Cornell takes up his acoustic guitar and leads the listener
through sixteen careful chosen tracks with the engaging presence of a
man completely at ease with his own abilities.
Cornells voice has always been soaked in soul,
as well as carrying an irresistible smokey edge that injected poignancy
to even the most bold rock songs he lent it to in his former roles, and
it has never sounded as good or as hard-hitting as when teamed up here
with a simple guitar as company. Most importantly, for an artist who was
somewhat cruelly criticised from some quarters about his decision to genre-hop
for 2009?s Scream (a critically lambasted relative failure, but underrated
criminally in my opinion), the decision to strip back the famous songs
is a statement outside of the concerns of genre. It is proof that a voice
can sell a song of any type, provided that voice in convincing and charismatic
enough to carry a different agenda within the song than originally composed.
And quite frankly, Cornells voice could convince me of most things.
The playlist is exceptionally well conceived, featuring
stripped bare, emotionally piquant versions of his most famous former
releases, including Like A Stone and the beautiful, brilliant
Black Hole Sun as well as two perfectly pitched covers. On
the first of Led Zeppelins Thank You, the singer
seats in the easy company of Robert Plant, forefronting similarities in
the two mens vocal qualities that have never occurred so insistently
before, and in the second, a hauntingly affecting reimagining of John
Lennons Imagine he confirms that even the most iconic
songs can become something entirely new in his hands.
There are brief snatches here and there of Cornells
effortlessly cool charisma, in his spoken introductions to a number of
the tracks like the off-hand offering that Imagine
is a perfect Easter song, and his anecdotal explanation prologuing Cant
Change Me and more than anything Songbook feels like a personal
insight into his inner workings. We are not only experiencing his song
choices stripped back, but also he himself, and listening to the album
will undoubtedly make fans who missed out on the tour lament the fact
(as it did with me).
Tagged onto the end of the album, but not out of place,
is the studio version of Cornells new acoustic track The Keeper
(which is also featured on the soundtrack to Machine Gun Preacher) which
perfectly knits together his past with his bright new future. And as a
major fan of his voice, I can only hope that the direction is similar
to that hinted on The Keeper. In the context of that tracks
inclusion, Songbook feels more and more like catharsis for
Cornell, who up until this point had toured with material ostensibly belonging
to Audioslave and Soundgarden amongst his solo work now, in their
new guises, the songs feel more like Cornell solo tracks and the execution
hints that they never needed the guitars and drums and bass to back up
his vocals in the first place.
Cornells triumph here is in suggesting newness
and individuality in songs we have heard a hundred times before, in investing
someone elses songs (even those formerly sung by him) with touches
of the newer, more mature Chris Cornell. And in doing so, he manages to
make certain songs sound even better than the originals Cant
Change Me certainly sounds better, while Ground Zero
and I Am The Highway sound like they have been infused with
an entirely different message of personal emotional rawness.
Songbook is a triumphant tribute to a voice
as Cornell proves despite the absence of a hard-hitting backing band that
bare rock songs can remain potent on the strength only of a vocal. There
arent many rock vocalists currently working who could achieve what
he did on the Songbook tour, without the protection of a band or the safety
blanket of playlists and compositions learnt from years of touring the
same material, and Cornell makes a mockery of those limitations in others.
He is so explicitly in-tune with his voice as an instrument able
to make it soar, ornate with flourishes when desired (though never over-bearingly
so), and to cut it all the way back to reinforce the message of the lyrics
or the tone of a particular passage. And in this stripped back format,
you really get the sense of how well he understands the mechanics of vocal
work, of punctuating sound with other sound, and quite frankly it is a
joy to be shown those skills.
From Elliott Alpern of the
Michigan
Daily:
Picture the scene: Tendrils
of smoke drift idly up to a hot spotlight, which concentrates its beam
on a single man perched upon his stool. The small crowd, hidden by the
darkness of the venue, is anxious but hushed in restraint. In the silence
a note rings out, followed by another and another until they blend together
into pure acoustic enlightenment. But this isnt Clapton picking
away the first strums of Tears In Heaven or Bob Dylan getting
ready to render the audience stunned. No, this is Chris Cornell, his raw
voice building a sultry monument to Soundgardens Fell On Black
Days.
For a man whos done so much, its surprising
to see that Cornell has anything new to offer after all, his last
three solo albums commercially flopped (and each garnered more negative
criticism than the last). But Songbook is different: The album consists
of acoustic covers that span Cornells entire career, from the grunge
pioneer Soundgarden to the supergroup Audioslave and everywhere in between.
Songbook seems to have found exactly the target to which it must pander
the nostalgia of longtime fans filtered through a fresh acoustic
lens.
The end product a smattering of 16 live-recorded
tracks from nine different shows is quite easily Cornells
best solo work since 1999s Euphoria Morning. The divine rock idol
pushes an already impressive vocal range early and often. In Call
Me A Dog, a cover from Cornells early 90s tribute band
Temple of the Dog, the mans emotive howl treads ever so softly on
the toes of modern blues masters. His guitar melodies reach comparable
levels of emotion and are all but eclipsed by the singers powerful
vocal belting listeners would be prudent to pay attention on tracks
like Audioslave cover I Am The Highway and the aforementioned
Fell On Black Days.
Yet amid the many changes of venue, Cornells
connection with the audience is well preserved and is occasionally depicted
through the singers various asides between songs. You at some
point try to be a better person and change your ways to make everyone
happy, and then that goes on for a while, Cornell says to the crowd
before one performance, and continues to the punch line: And then
you get to a point where youre like, Fuck it, Im me!
and then you write a song called Cant Change Me.
Over the crowds cheers, the rocker launches into what might be the
most impassioned tune on the record and one thats been colored
with some context by Cornells vague yet revealing anecdote.
Songbook isnt just a summation of Cornells
body of work, even if its title suggests otherwise. In addition to one
lonely new studio track tacked onto the records end (The Keeper),
Cornell tackles Led Zeppelins Thank You and John Lennons
Imagine. The former seems like its always been begging
to be re-done by a true-to-heart rocknroller, and Cornell
knocks it out of the park. However, while the latter is well executed,
the change of style is a bit too abrasive.
Ultimately, Songbook allows Chris Cornell to do what
he does best: scream sometimes, lilt softly at others and altogether flex
his vocal muscles. Every cover is carefully reinterpreted or redefined,
and the transition from the expanse of instruments of his booming power
rock to a single acoustic guitar is magnificently smooth. Cornells
latest shows that the man who used to lead entire arenas in choruses of
his hits can just as easily bare his heart from a wooden stool
and possibly even do it better.
From Rory Carroll of Artrocker:
Back in 1991 the Seattle
grunge bands were riding the crest of a successful, plaid-covered wave
which, by 1995, had subsequently pitched, broken and fully rolled back
on itself, leaving behind a pile of discarded lumberjack shirts and a
group of kids who would eventually grow up to be in bands like Puddle
of Mudd. We know.
Now in 2011, the wave seems to be gaining some anniversary
inspired momentum. There was the reissue of Nirvanas Nevermind;
Pearl Jam released their excellent documentary, Twenty; and
Alice in Chains toured a bit, but then wondered if anyone had actually
noticed.
Soundgarden were, until now, a notable absence from
this list, but the release of Chris Cornells latest LP may quickly
change all that.
Recorded during an acoustic tour of the US, Songbook
acts as the perfect bookend for Cornells career to date. It blends
stone cold grunge classics (Fell On Black Days, Black
Hole Sun), with Euphoria Morning-era solo cuts (Cant
Change Me) and both the good (I Am The Highway) and
bad (Doesnt Remind Me) aspects of the Audioslave back
catalogue.
His voice has undoubtedly softened over time, but
Cornell still has an unmistakable tone - a husky drawl mixed with an anguished
shriek that can turn any track into a classic.
The only questionable spot on the album is a slightly
ill-judged cover of Imagine, but well happily let Mr
Cornell play the I Was In Soundgarden card on that one. Youre
welcome, Chris just remember to pay it forward.
From Johnny Main of Metal
Talk:
You would think that being
part of the recently reformed Soundgarden would keep you busy - not so
for Chris Cornell, who toured the US acoustically from March to May. This
is the document of some of the many different tracks that he performed
during that tour.
At times, there's not a lot
of audience noise, which simply demonstrates just what a great voice Cornell
has. The addition of just his acoustic guitar gives some of the tracks
here a haunting quality and, for others, the chance to hear tracks without
the layers of instrumentation, and offers a new insight into them at the
same time.
The album contains two new
tracks, 'Cleaning My Gun' and 'The Keeper' (written for the film 'Machine
Gun Preacher', which gives a perspective of where he is now, compared
to the other original tracks), and two non-Cornell related covers, 'Imagine'
by John Lennon and Led Zeppelin's 'Thank You'.
The rest of the album is made up of tracks from Cornell's
entire career, including the short-lived and sometimes underrated Temple
Of The Dog. These tracks all demonstrate his versatility as a writer,
arranger and musician.
Amongst the tracks aired here, 'Ground Zero', 'Fell
On Black Days' and the evergreen classic 'Black Hole Sun' sound as good,
if not better than they did when they were first released. Cornell's voice
has rarely sounded better.
From Zee Zee of My
Global Mind:
Chris Cornell is one of those
guys that really should need no introduction
But in the interest
of those that may not know much of him lets just have a brief recap.
Cornell is most famous for being the frontman of Grunge pioneers SOUNDGARDEN
and is actually widely regarded as one of the pioneers of the entire movement,
even though similarly to ALICE IN CHAINS, SOUDGARDEN had a bit more of
a metal flair than other bands of the era like for example NIRVANA and
PEARL JAM. But asides from that he also spent some time in the supergroup
AUDIOSLAVE which he formed with some members of RAGE AGAINST THE MACHINE.
His other accolades include founding the Grunge supergroup TEMPLE OF THE
DOG, a handful of solo albums and also numerous film soundtrack contributions.
His most controversial move however was with his last solo album, titled
SCREAM, which saw Chris move toward contemporary pop music and collaborating
with TIMBALAND.
SO thats it for our brief history lesson, now
lets look at Cornells latest effort, SONGBOOK, which is a
live compilation of tracks from every era of his career done is pure acoustic
fashion culled from the solo acoustic tours he has been doing for the
last couple of years. So, does it work?
Oh, yes it sure does! Chris
is already the lucky owner of one the best and more unique voices in rock
history, the fact that nearly every one of these songs stand up to the
bare-bones stripping back makes it all the more sweeter. The guitar work
is kept minimalistic and basic throughout which really gives Cornells
vocals centre-stage, and I think this is the best he has ever sounded,
showing that his ability to croon on a lower register is just as significant
and powerful as his high-pitched wail that he is more widely recognised.
The opener AS HOPE AND PROMISE FADE is one the best
one-man, one-guitar performances youll likely ever hear and whilst
the high quality is kept up across the entire sixteen tracks, this one
is probably the main highlight. CALL ME A DOG is even more potent in this
format than what it was when originally released. LIKE A STONE, I AM THE
HIGHWAY and DOESNT REMIND ME all show just how good Cornells
lyric writing was in his time with AUDIOSLAVE and Chris most well-known
tune BLACK HOLE SUN has never sounded better. Theres a couple of
covers here too with a pretty standard rendition of IMAGINE (John Lennon)
and an interesting version of LED ZEPPELIN track THANK YOU. Theres
also two previously unreleased tunes in the mix with CLEANING MY GUN,
a suicide inspired tune written back In the day, and THE KEEPER which
works as bit of sneak-peek for Cornells next solo album, whenever
that may be. Even the SCREAM era is represented here with GROUND ZERO,
a tune based on the 9/11 attacks which was easily the pick of the bunch
from the SCREAM album, although its actually the weakest track on
SONGBOOK, except for the moving lyrics of course.
This album will be a real treat to anybody that has
followed Cornell through his many iterations, and casual fans will surely
find something of value here too. With songs like SPOONMAN, RUSTY CAGE,
JESUS CHRIST POSE, BLOW UP THE OUTSIDE WORLD, PRETTY NOOSE, 4TH OF JULY
and MY WAY still missing, a Part 2 seems inevitable (Lets
hope so anyway), but we will likely have to a while as Chris Cornell is
currently busy with the recent reformation of the almighty SOUNDGARDEN
and the subsequent upcoming new album. Until that eventuates, SONGBOOK
should be enough to keep most fans very, very happy.
From Clarissa Olivarez of
The
Nervous Breakdown:
The November release of Chris
Cornells album Songbook, recorded during live performances of his
recent tour, is not intended for new fans. This album features tracks
that date back to Cornells involvement with bands such as Temple
of the Dog (a band that featured former members of Mother Love Bone, Jeff
Ament and Stone Gossard, as well as a rising vocalist of the early 1990s,
Eddie Vedder). The setlist offers long-time fans something from each Cornell
era (from Temple of the Dog, to Soundgarden, to Cornells solo career,
to Audioslave, and back to his solo career). Dont be fooled, though
this is by no means a Greatest Hits-type compilation. The album
recasts earlier songs and successfully presents them in a strange yet
familiar framework. It should be noted that, with the exception of one
song, The Keeper, there are no new tracks on this album. Cornell
takes his best headbanging hits and his most beloved rock ballads and
introduces them to his audience anew. This live, acoustic version is both
surprising and impressive its just a man and his guitar.
In this way, Cornell not only reaffirms that he is a dynamo unto himself,
but that he can single-handedly capture the full attention of his fans
by once again laying out the full range of his vocal capacity and reminding
his listeners of his brilliance in songwriting.
Chris Solo vs. Chris with a Band
I have always maintained that Chris Cornell performs
at his best when he is in a band and not when he is recording, or playing,
solo. Although he is an excellent songwriter, something that he has proven
time and time again, I always held the belief that he was more powerful
when he was working off of the chemistry he had with Eddie Vedder in Temple
of the Dog, or with Kim Thayil in Soundgarden, or amongst the remaining
members of Rage Against the Machine, while in Audioslave. His solo albums,
in and of themselves, have a few songs on each album that always seem
to catch the attention of the masses (e.g., Cant Change Me
off of Euphoria Morning); but, it seems that while listening to any album
by Audioslave, Temple of the Dog, and Soundgarden there are no tracks
that one could safely skip and feel ok about skipping. Every song is just
that good. I have not been able to say the same for Cornells solo
efforts in the past
until now. Perhaps now I am able to see the full
extent of his songwriting abilities and the arresting nature of any performance
of which he is a part.
THE BREAKDOWN
Just FYI, you can listen to these songs for yourself
on Chris Cornells website: Songbook.
Cornell opens the album with the heavy-handed and
lyrically vulnerable track As Hope and Promise Fade. As he
croons Never more than two drinks away from crying, he decidedly
begins his album with a classic anthem about love lost. With each new
commentary that Cornell provides, his performance gradually becomes akin
to an episode of Storytellers. This is a good thing. Cornell speaks.
Temple of the Dog: From his Temple of the Dog era,
Cornell decides to cover two tracks: Call Me a Dog and All
Night Thing. Next to Say Hello 2 Heaven, Call
Me a Dog is my favorite song by Temple of the Dog and I was glad
to see it included in this album. Fans immediately cheered as the song
began, which clearly indicated that they recognized it. The re-imagining
of the 1991 track proves that at 47, Cornell can still belt the fuck out
of his lyrics. Cornells solo rendition of All Night Thing
is so great simply because it sounds as if it could have been recorded
in 1991. Cornells vocals never fail to impress and this grungy
version successfully transports the listener to a time without studio
excess.
Soundgarden: The acoustic version of Fell on
Black Days is quite haunting without the drums in the background
or the vibrato electric guitar. I absolutely love this bare-bones minimalist
approach to this classic grunge tune. Cornells replacement of the
electric guitar with the acoustic still preserves an intense level of
edginess and rock n roll. On the other hand, the acoustic version
of Black Hole Sun is eerie and disarming. While listening
to the song, the track does not automatically bring to mind Barbie dolls
roasting on a skewer or distorted, melting wax-like faces painted in suspense
of a black-hole sun.
Heres an experiment Queue up the video
on Youtube (link below) and hit play on the album (link to Songbook at
the beginning of the track list) and youll see what a sharp contrast
there is between the remake of the song and the original rockin
concept for the video.
Solo Cornell: Cornell revisits three songs from his
solo career. From his 2007 album Carry On, Scar on the Sky
is not markedly different from the original version and does well to further
showcase the trademark raspiness of Cornells voice. His version
of Cant Change Me, however, fails to impress. I guess
Im used to the heavily produced studio version on Euphoria Morning,
but it seems that the acoustic version doesnt lend itself well to
the lyrics of the song. The acoustic version powers-down the impact of
the song and leaves the listener feeling as if he or she is sitting around
a campfire (which might be acceptable to some). At the very least, people
know the song and can sing along. Lastly, the previously unreleased song
Cleaning My Gun instantly identified Cornells faithful
concert-goers. Cornell explains that its about a man who loses the
love of his life and then contemplates suicide. Theres a reason
why this song has only been performed live. I cannot imagine it being
recorded, and subsequently mixed, in any studio. Its a simple track
that requires a simple delivery.
Audioslave: The acoustic version of Ground Zero
is the best thing Cornell could have done for this song. The funkadelic
mix that was released as part of his 2009 album Scream was distracting
and moved the listener away from his intended message. In this version
Cornell mentions the attacks of 9/11 and prefaces his performance of the
song by stating that he wants to find a way to make the world better
instead of stupider. I Am the Highway translates very well
into the stripped-down version that Cornell presents us with. The key
chords and vocal inflections are retained, which makes for a nice interpretation
of the song. Doesnt Remind Me and Like a Stone
also prove to be successful crowd-pleasers. However, Wide Awake
is a rocking track from Audioslaves 2006 album Revelations. The
lyrics I find you guilty of a crime / Of sleeping at a time / When
you should have been wide awake serve to reinforce the fact that
this song needs to be on your stereo at full-blast. For this reason, I
find the song an odd choice for this setlist.
Covers: I have a lot of problems with Cornell covering
non-Cornell songs. For instance, can the Led Zeppelin classic Thank
You work without John Bonhams drums? Can it work with anyone
but Plant? I think not. Sorry, Chris Im a purist at heart.
And while Cornells rendition of John Lennons Imagine
is interesting, it is not quite as interesting as Cornells version
of Michael Jacksons Billie Jean. I almost expected this
Lennonian-standard performance from Cornell at some point. The version
is ok.
New Stuff: Lastly, the folksy new single from Chris
Cornell entitled The Keeper, and made for the movie Machine
Gun Preacher, is simply stunning. Listen to it. Enough said.
Quick Sound-Bytes
Most Successful Acoustic Translation: Scar on
the Sky
Least Successful Acoustic Translation: Cant
Change Me
Most Surprising Acoustic Translation: A tie between
Ground Zero and Soundgardens Black Hole Sun
Least Surprising Acoustic Translation: John Lennons
Imagine
From Kat Papakyriacou of
This
Is Not A Scene:
Chris Cornell is a hugely
successful musician with over twenty years of musical history to his name.
As the vocalist of Soundgarden, the band at the forefront of Subpops
Grunge movement, to breaking down all barriers with the unexpected
release of an urban dance-pop album where he collaborated with prestigious
hip-hop/R&B producer, Timberland. Chris Cornell seems to relish on
never being restrained by genre, trends, style or time. This is highly
evident on his fourth solo release, Songbook.
Songbook is Chris Cornell laid bare, stripped
of any fancy equipment and relying on nothing but a voice and an acoustic
guitar. There really is no margin for error here. No other musicians to
cover any mistakes. This could be spectacular, or show the World that
Chris Cornell no longer has what it takes to stand out vocally.
Recorded on a solo tour during the spring of this
year, Songbook is a 16-track album that showcases an entire
career. Many of the songs are acoustic versions of familiar songs written
by Cornell. Here work from solo albums (Scar on the Sky, Cant
Change Me, Ground Zero) sits comfortably alongside songs
written for the two Grammy Award winning bands the vocalist has fronted
Soundgarden releases (Fell on Black Days, Black
Hole Sun) and Audioslave (I am the Highway, Like
a Stone, Wide Awake, Doesnt Remind Me).
Songbook even includes two songs written for super group,
Temple of the Dog, in which Cornell wrote and performed with the remaining
members of Mother Love Bone in tribute to late front man and friend, Andrew
Wood (Call me a Dog, All Night Thing).
New songs As Hope and Promise Fade, The
Keeper and Cleaning my Gun (originally written for Country
legend, Johnny Cash, but never recorded) keeps fans thirst for new
material at bay. New songs flow into songs that are twenty years old.
There is no denying that Chris Cornells song writing ability truly
is timeless, and genre-less. Songs that were originally recorded with
a full band work as if they had always be written to be played in an acoustic
manner. This is highly evident on the song taken from Cornells 2009
solo offering, Scream. Ground Zero translates
beautifully on this record, and the message behind the track written
about the 9/11 attacks seems so much clearer when produced in this
way.
The album also includes two hand picked covers; Led
Zeppelins Thank You, and Imagine originally
recorded by John Lennon, which is The perfect Easter song,
according to Cornell. Both of these covers respect the original compositions,
whilst sympathetically adding Chris Cornells unique style.
Cornells vocals are flawless throughout. Effortlessly
reaching the height of his trademark vocal range, and then allowing his
voice to soften when necessary to allow the resonant meanings of the lyrics
to linger. Chris Cornell knows how to use his voice as an instrument.
His pitch, tone, dictation and timing are all astounding.
Songbook is an anthology of one mans
career in music. And what a remarkable career that has been. Delving his
fingers in many pies and never restricting himself artistically has paid
off. Hearing all these songs on a single album forces a sentimental smile,
appreciative of one mans journey through music. The acoustic nature
of this album evokes a very calming atmosphere, and the live aspect of
it gives us an insight into Chris Cornell himself. His often comedic interactions
with the crowd make this album more personable than other releases.
This may not be the Soundgarden release that the world
is eagerly awaiting, but it is a bloody marvellous album in its
own right. Chris Cornell powers through hits with a delicacy that is required
for an acoustic record. This album is not only a showcase for Chris Cornells
talents, its also a beacon for what music should sound like live
and uncluttered by production. Bravo!
From Jon Bye of Virgin.com:
It’s rather wrong for the implications of an album
to be as exciting as its content. But this is exactly what I find myself
thinking with Chris Cornell releasing a solo album
of live tracks from his long career in Soundgarden,
Audioslave, Temple of the Dog and
his own material.
Is he pushing his own solo career, bankrolling a new Soundgarden record
touted for some time now, or simply cashing in on a career of songs
usually where royalties were shared with other band members? Certainly
not – but what can it all mean?!?
Frankly there aren’t any answers on this album, but there are some great
live performances of some fantastic tunes. There’s a reason why Cornell
is frequently voted highly on lists of the best rock vocalists of all
time and it’s arguable that he is getting better with age; slipping
into a more gravelly territory that would give Tom Waits
a run for his money. Yet his range remains as good as his early 20s
with, some of the highs he hits enough to make you think there had to
have been some testicular pain involved in reaching it.
The spread of tunes on ‘Songbook’ is also to be commended. The inclusion
of ‘Call Me a Dog’ originally by side project Temple of The Dog brings
new life and depth to a tune long lost to the echelons of time. New
tracks as well are better than some of Cornell’s early solo efforts,
which frequently suffered from a disjointed quality. Such problems have
been firmly ironed out for the likes of ‘As Hope and Promise Fade’ which
stand as a high point in his writing.
Of course this album will be principally of interest
to Soundgarden fans and ‘Fell on Black Days’ and 'Black Hole Sun' are
both carried off admirably, even if the latter feels a little token
rather than properly meriting a live rendition.
Surprisingly, it is the Audioslave material that comes across the most
powerful. ‘Like a Stone’ and ‘I Am The Highway’ were gems on their original
release and remain so, but ‘Wide Awake’ on the other hand was a little
lost at the tail end of Audioslave’s final (and rather sub-par) album
'Revelations'. Here however the song gains real presence and punch,
with its political message following Hurricane Katrina really hitting
home. The late addition of a cover of John Lennon’s
‘Imagine’ is a little gulchy – more like an X Factor audition - but
wraps up a selection of songs that have a vaguely political message
quite nicely.
Overall, Songbook proves a good way to get into the broader canon of
Cornell’s work, proving his musically dexterity both inside and outside
of bands. Certain to entertain Audioslave and Soundgarden fans, it will
hopefully open even more people up to a man who’s talent continues to
grow with age and releases.
From LM of Metromix:
Once and future Soundgarden
and Audioslave frontman Cornell covers those bands and others in this
unplugged compilation from his spring 2011 tour. His first live, solo
album boasts an extensive spreadbesides songs from Cornell's two
main projects, the singer also revisits Temple of the Dog, the Andrew
Wood tribute band Cornell formed with members of Pearl Jam, and takes
a pass at Led Zeppelin and John Lennon as well. One of the high points
is the release's one studio track, the sweet, folky album-closer "The
Keeper," which Cornell wrote for Marc Forster's latest film, the
tepidly reviewed biopic "Machine Gun Preacher." Also of note
is Cornell's expressive take on Zeppelin's "Thank You."
From Danielle Millea of Leeds
Music Scene:
This release by Soundgarden
/ Audioslave frontman Chris Cornell is a collection of acoustic songs
recorded live from his solo acoustic tour in the US during March to May
2011. They are stripped back versions of some of his greatest tunes from
across his musical career, featuring tracks from his time with Soundgarden,
Temple Of The Dog and his other solo album releases. There are also some
unreleased songs by Chris, and a couple of covers (John Lennon's 'Imagine'
and Led Zeppelin's 'Thank You').
There are introductions to most songs, like the meaning
for writing the song 'Ground Zero' (self-explanatory really). Classic
songs like 'Fell On Black Days' are amazing transformed into solo acoustic
tunes, with Chris' raw vocals still as strong as if the rest of Soundgarden
was behind him. Same goes for the Audioslave tracks 'I Am The Highway'
and 'Like A Stone'.
Cornell's guitar skills are solid too, and the crowd
can be heard clearly loving the choice of songs. Any Chris Cornell fan
would love this collection too, showcasing how much this man has done
for music (thankfully there is only 'Ground Zero' from the bottom of the
pile 'Scream' album, which is a lot better here, stripped back so people
can appreciate it).The Temple Of A Dog covers get a huge response, calling
the need for a reunion tour (there have been the odd shared stage time
with Pearl Jam however). Stand out tracks for me are 'Call Me A Dog',
'Fell On Black Days' and 'Can't Change Me'.
The fact that there is no cover of Michael Jackson's
'Billie Jean' is a surprise as this was always covered at Audioslave shows
by a solo Cornell, but the collection here is more than enough to show
Chris' amazing vocal talent stripped bare. A must for anyone who has or
even hasn't heard of him.
From Jeremy Lukens of Glide
Magazine:
Throughout his enviable career,
Chris Cornell has always enjoyed taking his music in different directions.
Whether blazing the trail for the grunge movement with Soundgarden, fronting
rock supergroup Audioslave or releasing solo albums, Cornell was always
experimenting with his artistic expression. Though at times his experiments
failed, such as his ill-conceived collaboration with Timbaland, even at
his worst Cornells music had one nugget of redemption: that voice.
Cornell has the most distinctive voice of his generation,
with his oft-imitated closed-off delivery, smooth baritone and impossibly
high screams. Along with his trademark alternate tunings, Cornells
vocals can instantly transform any melody into a classic. For that reason,
Songbook is the solo album Cornell was born to make and is his best album
since 1999s Euphoria Morning.
Songbook is a true solo album, recorded live with
Cornell and his acoustic guitar alone onstage. The stripped down sound
gives more weight to his soulful vocals and allows classic songs to be
reinvented. The track list is comprised of songs throughout Cornells
extensive catalog, including songs with Soundgarden, Audioslave and Temple
of the Dog, solo songs and two covers.
The true test of a song is how good it sounds stripped
down to its bones, and with the exception of Doesnt Remind
Me, each song surpasses expectations. The bluesy ode to sobriety
As Hope and Promise Fade becomes a powerful acoustic anthem.
Hit Black Hole Sun sounds even more ominous as a ballad. Though
its fascinating to hear Cornells old songs take on new life,
the albums finest moments are two new songs, a cover of Led Zeppelins
Thank You and the previously unreleased Cleaning My
Gun.
Though best known for loud rock numbers, Cornells
talents are never clearer than on Songbook. His full-throated screams
echo through the auditorium while his the vibrato in his gentle crooning
caresses the audience. After experimenting with Timbaland and Audioslave,
Cornell has finally found the perfect music for his post-Soundgarden career.
From Ben Hogwood of MusicOMH:
Anybody reading this who
has had the pleasure to witness Chris Cornell live will surely agree that
the man has an astonishingly good voice. Not only that, but it can mould
to a number of different styles, with doom-laden rock more recently giving
way to an upbeat approach on his solo material, though that has itself
become scattergun in its direction of late. Scream, his last album in
2009, was made with Timbaland, and was a hotchpotch of styles with some
incredible singing. So what now?
A live acoustic album, that's what - just the man,
his guitar and an enthusiastic band of admirers who came to see him on
a recent North American tour. The songs are drawn from a number of different
stages in the singer's career - Soundgarden, solo and Audioslave. The
Cornell pipes are still in incredibly rude health, freely emoting as he
describes the feeling of being "only two drinks away from crying"
in As Hope And Promise Fade. His is a very believable voice, and works
better without crowd pleasing histrionics. There are a few of those, but
not enough to harm the overall impact - and in songs like Wide Awake you
simply have to listen and wonder at the heights of his voice.
So why does it not fully work in this format? A big
contributor is the layout of the collection, which sounds largely similar
the whole way through, and there are times when you yearn for some guitar
heft to complement the voice. The tempo choice, too, remains on the slow
side. With less evidence of Cornell's recent forays towards soul and R&B,
the pitch is generally a safer rock one. Ground Zero, for example, is
profound - but sits closer to the middle of the road. One that benefits
from this approach is Can't Change Me, one of Euphoria Morning's best
songs. Introduced by its singer as talking about a life "that goes
on for a while and then you get to a point where you say, "Fuck it,
I'm me!", it works well.
The big draws are the Soundgarden numbers, but perhaps
inevitably these are Fell On Black Days and Black Hole Sun, the first
note of the latter drawing a primeval roar from the audience. Both translate
very well to the acoustic idiom, but given the wealth of the available
catalogue it seems almost a shame to focus on these two at the exclusion
of the likes of Burden In My Hand, one of those songs where the Cornell
lungs get a really good going over. More welcome is the Temple of the
Dog song All Night Thing, powerfully sung.
There is a song that has "never been on anything",
according to its careful owner. Cleaning My Gun is softly sung with that
slightly nasal tone that makes Cornell such a distinctive vocalist, and
he opens up the throttle in the chorus to a full blown husk. The Keeper,
meanwhile, is a new song that closes the collection, in a studio recording
made for the Machine Gun Preacher film.
Cornell's voice might not be as tight as it was back
in 1994, but it remains a formidable instrument - and lifts this collection
well above that of an average live album. It's the lack of variety that
stops it from becoming truly great.
From Jen Walker of Rock
Sound:
Just when you thought a new
Soundgarden record was on the horizon, a new Chris Cornell record has
appeared! Never fear though, its much better than Scream
(though Ground Zero does appear, hugely improved we hasten
to add). Songbook is a live and acoustic compilation of many
of Cornells finest songs and a few covers, but itd be a far
easier listen if it was a proper studio release. After spinning this,
though, Soundgardens UK visit cant come soon enough
that voice!
From Sticky
Noise:
Weve been in awe of
Chris Cornells voice and song-writing capabilities since mid-1991
when we first heard the now legendary Temple of the Dog album. Just take
a spin through Times of Trouble on that record and youll know what
we mean.
We were going to wait until November 21 to review
the complete album, since Chris decided to release Songbook in three installments
over the course of this month, but we simply couldnt wait. (Songbook
1 was released on Nov. 1, Songbook 2 today, and Songbook 3 coming on Nov.
21).
Songbook is an acoustic live album from solo shows
performed earlier this year, showcasing songs from throughout Cornells
career. There are songs here from Temple of the Dog, Soundgarden, Audioslave
and Cornells solo career (as well as a few covers). And, from what
weve heard so far, it is brilliant.
The guy is essentially a one-man show. With acoustic
guitar in-hand, Cornell wails each gem with such grand emotion and precision
its impossible to disconnect yourself from what hes singing
and feeling. Each song is new and refreshing, despite the fact that youve
likely heard it in some different form in the past.
If there were skeptics before, there can hardly be
now. With Songbook, Chris Cornell has quite elegantly proven once again
(as if it was necessary!) that he is a gifted musician, songwriter and
singer
and quite frankly, one of the greatest of each in rock history.
Hey Chris, Stone, Jeff, Eddie, Mike and Matt
how about a second album from Temple of the Dog? We think the time is
right.
From Joe Calabrese of The
Aquarian:
There arent many things
that Chris Cornell hasnt accomplished in his career, and Songbook
acts as witness. Songbook was recorded while Cornell was on tour following
the 2010 Soundgarden reunion. This album contains acoustic versions of
some of his most famous tracks and features selections from every step
in Cornells career. Everything is fair game for this disc: From
Soundgarden and Audioslave to Temple Of The Dog to solo and cover work.
Leading off is As Hope And Promise Fade,
previously known as Two Drink Minimum, a hidden track off
of Scream. It tells the story of a man that decides to abandon the bottle
because of all the trouble it causes him, similar to how Cornell himself
recently gave up drinking. Many of the songs, in fact, tell beautiful
stories, like how Ground Zero is advice on how to move on
from the infamous 9/11 attacks, as well as Cant Change Me,
which is pretty self-explanatory.
The hits are still strong as ever on this album. I
Am The Highway, Black Hole Sun and Like A Stone
are all still great, but the real gems are Cornells previously unreleased
works. Cleaning My Gun has been played on tour for many years,
but was never released, and The Keeper, the albums final
track, is an unreleased studio version. Both are fantastic. Cornell also
pays homage to Led Zeppelin and John Lennon with covers of Thank
You and Imagine.
As a whole, Songbook is a perfect balance of the well-known
and unknown beauties from the lifework of this great singer/songwriter.
Thank you, Chris Cornell, this album makes me want to go home, peruse
all my old Soundgarden albums and pretend that I was lucky enough to understand
what good music was back in the 90s.
From Dan Aquilante of the
New
York Post:
While Chris Cornell is famous
as the frontman for big, loud bands such as Temple of the Dog, Soundgarden
and Audioslave, this year the singer has experimented with quiet-riot
arrangements in a series of small-theater solo concerts.
Songbook is a live compilation featuring
the best performances from his 2011 spring tour. In each of the records
16 tracks, Cornell is alone onstage, with just a guitar. Unplugged yet
energized, the singer deconstructs originals and classic rock covers,
letting the weight of each song rest on his gritty baritone.
Cornell is a unique vocalist
in todays pop; his bluesy, emotional delivery seems to draw its
influences from Jim Morrison on L.A. Woman, his last recording
with The Doors.
Among the many peaks on this record is the cover of
Led Zeppelins Thank You, on which Cornell pays vocal
homage to Robert Plants essential wailing vibrato. Cornell is thoughtful
in recasting his Temple of the Dog tune Call Me a Dog as a
strum n hum ballad, and he actually achieves a dreamy folk
quality on the darkly dangerous original Cleaning My Gun,
which he says is a song I wrote a while ago, but never recorded.
There is a pretty version of John Lennons Imagine
that ranks among the best covers of the classic available, and the Audioslave
hit Doesnt Remind Me is also notable. The best of this
very good record is Black Hole Sun, from Cornells Soundgarden
tenure.
This rock classic about cleansing the Earth through
total destruction is stripped down to voice and guitar. The laid-back,
slow jam tempo suits the tune, allowing Cornell to sound as if hes
creating the lyrics off the top of his head. Its an intimate and
compelling piece on a very personal album.
From Dave Lake of Seattle
Weekly:
There's no denying Chris
Cornell has one of the gnarliest voices in rock. His upper-register howl
is powerful and primal, helping to plant Soundgarden at the top of the
'90s hard rock heap. There's not a lot Cornell can't sing, and there aren't
a lot of singers who can sing Cornell (when was the last time you heard
a kickass Soundgarden cover?), but his voice is at its best when he's
wailing over the top of grooving, loud, metal, or subsequently, when he's
nuanced and restrained.
Like a lot of live albums, Songbook is uneven, largely
because of Cornell's spotty output as an artist. As you'd expect from
a solo acoustic record, there's not a lot of Soundgarden material. Only
"Black Hole Sun" and "Fell on Black Days" make the
cut, the latter of which is one of the highlights. The Audioslave material
is the weakest here, as those songs lack the power of the Soundgarden
stuff, while also not possessing the melodic movement of his solo work
or the pair of Temple of the Dog tracks that appear.
The album's brightest spot is John Lennon's "Imagine,"
which lets Cornell showoff both his wail and his warble, as he segues
seamlessly into the falsetto parts at the end of each verse. The arrangement
even heads into Jeff Buckley-esque territory as it hits the final verse,
though it's hard to imagine Buckley doing the American Idol-style vocal
run Cornell throws in at its conclusion.
Fans of Cornell's solo material ought to dig this
most, and there's one track, "Cleaning My Gun," that hasn't
appeared anywhere else previously. Songbook may not be an ideal career
retrospective, but it does shine a light on at least part of what makes
Cornell one of the best frontmen of his generation.
From Cack
Blabbath:
Chris Cornell needs little
introduction. Whether you like his voice or not, you have to respect him.
With a career spanning over twenty years, encompassing styles from grunge/alt.
rock to dance-pop, Cornell seems to be a man who isnt fazed by trends,
genres, sub-genres or any of that nonsense. At least thats the impression
he gives us.
As the artist on the album title suggests, this is
a Chris Cornell record and not a Soundgarden offering. For those annoyed
by this fact, I would like to point out that this is not the vocalists
first solo project. It strikes me as ignorant to assume that an artist
cant or rather shouldnt release a solo album
whilst being part of a band where there are huge expectations for an impending
release. With that out of the way lets get on with the review;
As a long time fan, I was a little worried giving
this a first listen. I wanted it to be great, but I also remember how
I felt when listening to Scream. Appreciative that one man in such a creative
business needs to spread his wings and experiment, I was disappointed
with what seemingly felt like a lack of Cornells influence. I also
held concerns for his vocal ability. Would the years of damage from cigarettes
and the rock and roll lifestyle be evident with a lesser quality vocal?
I neednt have worried at all.
Songbook is Chris Cornell in his purest form yet.
Its a very raw and simplistic live album, which relies solely on
one acoustic guitar and a voice. And what an amazingly powerful voice
that is. There is little room for mistake with so few instruments. Thankfully,
Cornell doesnt seem to put a foot wrong throughout the entire album.
Recorded entirely on what was dubbed The Songbook
Tour in April of this year, the 16-track album showcases every element
of Cornells talent, from his now legendary vocal range, to his song
writing ability. What is harder to make note of is the powerful and atmospheric
mood his music creates. Songbook is calming, captivating and an outstanding
showcase for music in general.
Fans of previous work will already be familiar with
many of the songs on the album. However the opener, As Hope and Promise
Fade, is a brand new song which immediately throws you head first into
Cornells vocal acrobatics! If there ever was a song to make the
most out of his range, this is it. The sound is completely stripped down,
the lyrics are enchanting and his voice really does send a tingle up your
spine. Scar on the sky (originally on Cornells second solo record,
Carry On) breeds familiarity into the record; as does Temple of the Dog
classic, Call me a Dog.
Ground Zero interests me. As I said, I wasnt
a fan of Scream
so how would an urban pop record translate acoustically?
Stripped down this song is magnificent. The lyrics and melody seem stronger
without the addition of the electronic samples. I, for one, would be happy
to hear Scream entirely reproduced because underneath the dance beats
I think it could be a gem of a record.
Cant Change Me, taken from 1999s Euphoria Morning
is introduced as a song the vocalist wrote after trying to change, then
realizing fuck it! This is who he is.. Deal with it! The crowd applauds
in agreement. Its nice to hear these snippets of Cornells
crowd interaction, which seems as engaging as his music.
Audioslaves I Am the Highway is another reminder
of a career that has been nothing short of amazing. That is followed by
Thank You. A Led Zeppelin classic which treats the original with respect,
but which the vocalist makes his own. The same can be said for the second
cover on this album, Imagine by John Lennon which features later on.
We are also treated to a song that was written for
legendary Country artist, Johnny Cash. Unfortunately Cash died before
this was ever recorded, but Cleaning My Gun makes its recorded debut appearance
here with unrivaled soft beauty.
Renditions of Audioslave (Like a Stone, Wide Awake,
Doesnt Remind Me), Soundgarden (Fell on Black Days, Black Hole Sun),
Temple of the Dog (All Night Thing) lead us to the last song on the album,
The Keeper.
The final song on the album is The Keeper, an original
song written for the movie Machine Gun Preacher. However as this is a
studio-recorded track I feel its a little out of place here on a
live acoustic album. That said, it is a beautiful song and as always is
nice to hear something completely new from Cornell.
What you get with Songbook is an anthology of one
mans career in music. And what a remarkable career that has been
Through fronting two Grammy Award winning bands, One super group in Temple
of the Dog, as well as his own solo career, of which this is his fourth
recorded release.
Still all those songs sit very well next to each other,
proving that Chris Cornell has unparalleled and timeless song writing
ability. Vocally, he remains one of the most emotionally fueled, soulful
voices in music today. His ability to control his voice as an instrument
is inspirational, knowing when to soar into falsetto, and when to relax
and let the lyrical content come through. His tone, pitch, technique and
phrasing are all flawless on this release. This album is already one of
my favourites. Well done, Mr. Cornell. Heres to the next twenty
years!
From Jim Norton of Planet
Loud:
Chris Cornell has a lot of
making up to do. Only two years have passed since the former Audioslave
and Soundgarden frontman drafted in uber-producer Timbaland for an urban
makeover on his third solo effort. Sure, progression is key for any artist,
but this was no Judas moment of musical foresight a la Bob Dylan. The
opposite in fact: nothing on the album Scream offered any
form of musical enlightenment, instead, it was a decision that suggested
a mid-life crisis was attempting to wreak havoc on the grunge legends
legacy.
So, as an apology or concession to his fans, Cornell
has ditched the sub-Justin Timberlake nonsense and returns to the stage
with just an acoustic for Songbook. And its a generous apology;
mixing songs under previous guises with Led Zep and John Lennon covers,
plus introducing a couple of new ones. Opting for crowd pleasers works,
though its the voice that really compels. With the acoustic accompaniment,
the grunge god soulfully bellows through each with a voice so rich it
never fails to capture the emotion and grit of the lyrics. Its the
perfect platform for his pipes. Without Timbalands production, the
two songs from Scream are far more powerful particularly As
Hope and Promise Fade (previously Two Drink Minimum). Its
crushingly heartfelt and repeats the phrase No more than two drinks
away from crying with devastating effect. A stunning opener. It
continues as songs from Audioslave, Soundgarden, and Temple of the Dogs
back catalogues all get raw acoustic reworkings. What the songs lose in
atmosphere without the band is more than made up for by Cornells
engaging voice.
Cornells confidence is obviously high
despite the critical mauling of Scream and he even has the audacity
to cover a couple of classics. Nothing will ever beat the serene beauty
of the original, but Cornells attempt at turning John Lennons
Imagine into a warbling rock ballad sidesteps a butchering and works well.
So too does his version of Led Zeppelins Thank You, a tender homage
to rocks forefathers. Songbook also offers two new songs. The first, Cleaning
My Gun, talks of a cheating lover and sings the rather foreboding line
As you lay sleeping with your eyes softly shut, Ill be cleaning
my gun. Its not a standout, but does suggest there are plenty
of inner demons still for Cornell to write about in the future. The second
newbie takes a different tack. After writing the best Bond theme in a
decade (You Know My Name), he has been drafted in by the Machine Gun Preacher
producers to write a song for the soundtrack. Its a prettily fingerpicked
song you can imagine accompanying a shot of a scenic dry Savannah as Gerard
Butler wanders across saving all the Africans. It will also instantly
remind some of equally qualified rock legend Eddie Vedders own foray
into soundtracking for Into The Wild, particularly Guaranteed. The only
reason one wouldnt remember is because they could quite feasibly
think they were listening to the same song.
Interestingly, Cornells new Jesus style hair
and beard combo are also eerily reminiscent of Vedder. But hey, the difference
between influence and imitation is difficult to determine, so lets
leave it at that. Originality is not the rationale for Songbook, anyway;
its an offering to appease fans and to show that Cornells
voice is better than ever. As apologies go, Songbook is Christmas come
early for Cornell fans.
From Melissa Caruso of Elmore
Magazine:
THE SOLO ENDEAVOR by Chris
Cornell highlights gems from his efforts with grunge outfits Temple of
the Dog, Soundgarden and Audioslave. On Songbook, live recordings from
His 2011 tourfull of gregarious asidesoffer the closest thing
to the unearthly Grunge God.
Here, amps and drum kits are set aside as Cornells
distinctively ethereal singing takes center stage, with perceptive poetic
prose fans cant help but latch onto. The protest Ground Zero
steers clear of becoming preachy, appropriately situated next to the individualistic
I Am the Highway. Other standouts include Led Zeppelins
Thank You and Lennons Imagine, where Cornells
grunge-laden pipes offer beautiful desperation. Wide Awake
shows Cornells finest restraint of frustration before softening
up on All Night Thing and Doesnt Remind Me.
With staples like Black Hole Sun and Like A Stone,
this album offers a time capsule of rocks finest gems. Dig it.
From Michael Brown of Drowned
in Sound:
Finally, Chris Cornell is
giving his fans what they want. After a number of attempts at pushing
them away with misguided Timbaland collaboration Scream and tours with
Linkin Park, he now eagerly ushers them back into the fold, first with
a Soundgarden reunion and now his debut acoustic album, Songbook. While
the fruits of Soundgarden 2.0s labours are yet to be seen, Songbook
comes off the back of Cornells highly rated solo acoustic shows
in the USA. However, as is often the question with live compilations (including
Soundgardens own Live on I-5), can a collection of live performances
really gel as an album?
First impressions are that the tracklisting is a bit
predictable. Of course, any compilation, live or otherwise, is likely
to be populated with hits but with Cornell, many of the choices here are
not what people were talking about after his live shows. Anyone whos
spent a few minutes on YouTube will be asking why Seasons,
Like Suicide, Mind Riot, When Im Down,
Sunshower and countless others are so obviously missing; all
were highlights of Cornells acoustic shows yet strangely absent
from this collection.
Still, whats here is good, occasionally bordering
on brilliant. Theres no denying that giving up the smoke and the
booze during the Audioslave era has helped Cornells vocal cords
immeasurably, as his high notes soar and his lows rumble with a timbre
only vocal maturity can bring. This is best observed in a rendition of
the aforementioned super-groups Wide Awake, which is
transformed from a clunky rawk anthem into a dark murder ballad, with
Cornells previously painful screams now a comfortable wail. Other
songs benefiting from the acoustic treatment include Screams Timbaland-free
Ground Zero and, perhaps the compilations finest moment,
Soundgarden classic Fell on Black Days, jaw-dropping in its
vocal dexterity and stripped-down intensity.
Elsewhere, weve got a disappointingly limited
selection of solo material (Cant Change Me, Scar
on the Sky), a couple of Temple of the Dog nods (Call Me a
Dog, All Night Thing) and some fairly impressive rarities
(opener As Hope and Promise Fade, Cleaning My Gun).
All are capable enough renditions but lend themselves so effortlessly
to the acoustic setting that they fail to be ground-breaking. Top that
off with a distinct lack of atmosphere, banter and flow between tracks
and, no matter how well intended, these particular song choices feel like
a wasted opportunity.
Ultimately, Songbook is not let down by performances
or production but by its tracklisting. This release had the potential
to be utterly essential, should it have included some of the more unorthodox
arrangements Cornell had been popularising on his acoustic tours, but
instead settles for the overwhelmingly obvious. There are some tracks,
like obligatory Soundgarden masterpiece Black Hole Sun, which
form necessities but is Doesnt Remind Me really worthy
of a spot? Not even a touching version of Led Zeppelins Thank
You or an overly saccharine homage to hero John Lennon in Imagine
can quite obscure the fact that this could have, and should have, been
better.
As a beginners introduction to Cornells
work, Songbook is exemplary, but for the fans, who this is apparently
aimed at, it fails to completely satisfy. Closing studio track The
Keeper does bring with it a considerable amount of hope for the
future but, for now, Songbook is a disappointing substitute for even the
grainiest of YouTube footage.
From Ben Walton of Contactmusic:
It has been said that a truly great song can be stripped
down to a basic vocal and instrumental accompaniment, and still be every
bit as powerful and affecting as a full band version. This is the approach
Chris Cornell has taken on Songbook, a live album collecting an impressive
array of cuts from his solo acoustic tours.
The sheer range of material included here reminds
you how varied and interesting Cornell's career has been. You get a couple
of Soundgarden tracks, six of his own solo songs, some Audioslave tracks,
some Temple of the Dog songs and even a few covers just for good measure.
You cannot feel ripped off by so much back catalogue rummaging. There
is indeed something for everyone in the Songbook.
Even though the songs are stripped back to their barest
of bones, none of the songs particularly suffer from their lack of instrumentation
and in fact, some are even enhanced by it. In particular, the overworked
hip hop stylings of Ground Zero from his last (and incredibly controversial)
solo effort Scream is turned into a kind of funky work out that allows
Chris's voice to really shine, which, by the way, is stronger than it
has sounded in years. Call Me a Dog from the Temple of the Dog album becomes
a beautifully delicate track, even more fragile than its original album
version. Soundgarden's biggest hit Black Hole Sun is transformed from
Beatles-esque psychedelia into an even more haunting, sinister tune. All
of the Audioslave tracks are brilliant as well, some - I am the Highway
and Wide Awake in particular - actually eclipse the studio versions by
many thousands of miles.
Of the less familiar material, Cornell's re-workings
of Led Zeppelin's Thank You and John Lennon's Imagine are fantastic, even
if they add nothing to the originals. Cleaning My Gun is an unreleased
gem from the Chris Cornell archive that has a lot in common with the Temple
of the Dog tracks. It's pleasant enough, but had it been released before
now, it probably wouldn't have set the world alight. If further criticisms
are to be made, then one would have to say that Chris easily has enough
amazing songs to fill a second disc. Imagine a stripped back Getaway Car,
Hunger Strike or Burden In My Hand. I know for a fact that on the tour
this album chronicles that Cornell played Soundgarden's Mind Riot almost
nightly. Had this been included, I would wager that a large proportion
of the 'Garden's fan base would have collectively lost its mind.
The collection finishes with a slightly stripped back
studio version of The Keeper, which Cornell wrote for the film Machine
Gun Preacher. The song is easily the best Cornell solo track since 1998's
Euphoria Morning album, and proves that should the Soundgarden reunion
encounter any hurdles, a new Chris Cornell solo record would not be such
a bad thing.
From Karina Halle of Consequence
of Sound:
Chris Cornells career
has spanned the spectrum of rock and roll, from his start in Soundgarden
to the beloved Temple of the Dog, to his supergroup Audioslave and his
solo work. Earlier this year, Cornell went on a quick solo tour playing
an acoustic set in various intimate settings. To those unfortunate enough
to miss the shows, they are now a part of his solo acoustic live album,
Songbook.
Every musical project that Cornell has had a part
in is featured in this album. Audioslave is toned down with the haunting
I Am the Highway, Soundgardens distortion is intricately
simple on Black Hole Sun. From his solo album Scream, theres
As Hope and Promise Fade, a heartbreaking, personal track
where Cornell is never more than two drinks away from crying.
Theres a few covers like Imagine and the tear-inducing
Thank You. Theres even The Keeper, a catchy
number that was written for Marc Fosters film Machine Gun Preacher.
The fitting song selection isnt the only thing
that stands out here: The album sounds fantastic. The sparseness of the
recording comes shining through with Cornells emotive voice sounding
crystal clear, the mood and clarity resonating with each strum of the
strings. Normally live albums get bogged down with loud audience chatter
or too much talky-talk from the performers. Not in Songbook. It sounds
sharp and the audience only appears in atmospheric hoots and hollers that
dont compete with the music. As for Cornell, while he does talk,
he sets up the scene and lets it get on its way.
Songbook is more than a worthy addition to any Cornell
fans collection; its a beautiful showcase of his career that
any music lover should have. When his voice strains with emotion during
Cleaning My Gun and Temple of the Dogs Call Me
a Dog, you feel everything he feels. And its wonderful.
From Michael Christopher of the Boston
Phoenix:
Chris Cornell's reaction
to the critical lynching his Timbaland-produced debacle Scream took in
2009 was to grow his hair back out, reunite with Soundgarden (currently
in the studio), and embark on a solo tour stripped down to just an acoustic
guitar. Songbook is the colorful sonic snapshot of that jaunt, and it
has a little bit of everything Audioslave, Soundgarden, Temple
of the Dog, and solo material. That patented caterwaul is in fine form;
Cornell easily hits all the notes on "All Night Thing," "Fell
on Black Days," and "Wide Awake" even a pair of
tracks from Scream work in the bare-bones setting. The buzz has been about
the inspired takes on Led Zeppelin's "Thank You" and John Lennon's
"Imagine," but the highlight is the first appearance on an official
release of "Cleaning My Gun," a haunting track about a narrator
who reflects on the fleetinginesss of relationships and life in general
while his lover sleeps. The song choices are a bit predictable, especially
since gems like "Sunshower," "Seasons," and "Mind
Riot" which joined covers of Syd Barrett, the Beatles, and
Mother Love Bone on the road are omitted here. Then again, there's
always volume two.
From Rick Florino of Artist
Direct:
On his brand new solo acoustic live album, Songbook,
every side of Chris Cornell shines.
Right before launching into "Can't Change Me" from Euphoria Morning,
he tells an engaging anecdote about the song.
"You at some point try to be a better person and change your ways to make
everyone happy, and then that goes on for a while," he exclaims. "Then,
you get to a point where you're like, 'Fuck it, I'm me!' And then you write
a song called 'Can't Change Me'."
It's those moments of revealing levity that made Cornell's Songbook tour
unforgettable and now they make the album an undeniable gem. Cornell sounds
flawless singing "Can't Change Me", adding soulful heft to the already robust
refrain. Each note and lyric resounds clearly, and his talents as a storyteller
and poet come through as loud and clear as any rumbling riff on a Soundgarden
record.
Cornell channels the mystical intensity of Robert Plant on his cover of
Led Zeppelin's "Thank You", while imbuing his own vulnerability to the verse.
"As Hope and Promise Fade" is an elegiac folk number that sails on the strength
of the singer's impressive pipes. "Scar on the Sky" comes to life vividly
as Cornell carries the line, "We will rip the night out of the arms of the
sun one more time" over a soft acoustic strum.
One previously unreleased gem, "Cleaning My Gun", rises in hypnotic and
haunting haze emblematic of Cornell's uncanny ability to make dark subject
matter strangely sweet. That juxtaposition also burns bright at the heart
of his acoustic take on Audioslave's "Like a Stone", another death rumination
that's undeniably beautiful. "Black Hole Sun" remains just as potent stripped
back like this and Cornell's take on the "Easter song" John Lennon's "Imagine"
is a true tearjerker. Ultimately, Songbook is a classic live album and one
of the most powerful in Cornell's catalog.
Music has few individuals left who can grab an acoustic guitar alone and
make a sold out crowd laugh, cry, feel, and dream. Cornell is one of the
last. Thankfully, we can be sure he'll never "change" either.
From Evan Schlansky of American
Songwriter:
Now that the Soundgarden
reunion is official with a subsequent untitled album set to drop this
year, Chris Cornell spent much of 2011 looking back. In addition to hitting
the road for a small string of dates with his old band mates and releasing
the groups first live album, Cornell went on a brief solo acoustic
tour earlier in the year during which time he trotted out material from
the various stops of his musical life. The Seattle native was kind enough
to cherry-pick a number of these performances for what became his fourth
solo album. Despite the fact that this is a bare-bones live recording,
the combination of Cornells engaging stage presence, the formidable
punch his singing packs and the strength of these songs makes this a record
that will appeal to more than just Soundgarden/Audioslave fans.
Over the past two and a half plus decades, Cornells
voice was always admired for its supple tone and impressive range, characteristics
even more apparent with all the loud guitars and crashing rhythms stripped
away. And having given up alcohol and drugs for nearly ten years, his
vocals are even more impressive. While some of the set-list selections
are of iconic Soundgarden songs like Black Hole Sun and Fell
on Black Days, a number of lesser-known but no less welcome gems
are plucked from the Cornell canon. A pair of numbersthe mournful
Call Me a Dog and its soulful cousin All Night Thingare
resurrected from the sole Temple of the Dog album while the aforementioned
Audioslave is represented by a quartet of songs including the politically-charged
Wide Awake and its mention of trading lives for oil. While
a perfunctory cover of Imagine provides an obvious link to
those socially conscious sentiments, the outspoken singer-songwriter is
more effective with Ground Zero, his own post-9/11 observation
that was effectively resurrected off Scream, his disastrous 2009 collaboration
with Timbaland.
Early on in Soundgarden, Cornells yowl and leonine
locks gave him the semblance of a latter-day Robert Plant, so its
no surprise that he trots out a solid yet straightforward version of Led
Zeppelins Thank You. And for as unremarkable as this
may seem, he does impress with a pair of obscure solo cutsCleaning
My Gun, a lament about lost love that works despite its seemingly
threatening title and The Keeper, the only studio song. Self-penned
for the 2011 film Machine Gun Preacher, the mix of Alain Johannes
acoustic guitar chords and its composers light croon has it resonate
long after the playing ends. A nice summation of Chris Cornells
career up to this point, Songbook makes for a fine springboard into the
next creative chapter of his life.
From Stephen Thomas Erlewine of Allmusic.com:
After spending over a decade avoiding his past, Chris
Cornell reconnected with it in a big way during 2010. First, he reunited
with Soundgarden, their tour so successful it spilled over into a studio
collaboration interrupted by Cornell launching an acoustic tour where
he revisited his catalog, quite definitively tying his solo career and
time with Audioslave to Soundgarden. Songbook is a live album culled from
this tour and has Cornell sampling from all phases of his career, often
spinning harder-rocking songs into moody reflective territory. Unlike
his solo debut, Euphoria Morning, this never sounds solipsistic; Cornell
is engaged, looking outward to the audience, giving subtly forceful performances
that often rescue overlooked tunes -- including selections from his electronica
makeover Scream -- and freshen up familiar songs, including covers of
Led Zeppelins Thank You and John Lennons Imagine.
He sounds at peace with his past and comfortable with his present, and
that casual assurance makes Songbook his best solo offering to date.
From Sion Smith of The
Void:
There was little chance of
this not being one of the best albums of the year even before its release.
I adore Chris Cornell (although
I dont always love everything he does) and my honest opinion of
him is that he has given more than most will ever know to rock over these
last few years.
If my suspicions are correct, the best may still be
to come.
Songbook is what rock gods sounds like when theyre
at their best. Stripped back to an old acoustic and an appreciative audience,
this is one fine, fine album that no rock fan should even think twice
about adding to the collection. What makes it work is the honesty. Theres
no pretension here, a smattering of the familiar, a smattering of the
not so. Its incredibly beautiful, utterly compelling and thankfully,
flawless. As to what it may do commercially, thats anybodys
guess. Its been pretty low key so far, so unless youre looking for
it, theres every chance it will pass you by and that would be a
crying shame.
The big talking point of Songbook is Cornells
voice. After all these years in the field, its taken its fair share
of abuse and, like the hands of a farmer, has adapted itself to the point
that it takes something pretty serious to get through the scar tissue
covering it. Capable of reducing any soul to crying in the gutter, the
world should be paying more attention to Cornell rather than lamenting
those long since passed by Buckley springs mainly to mind but there
are others. What is this fascination we have with worshipping the dead
and letting the living go about their business?
Calling on material from his entire career and throwing
in some covers in the shape of Thank You and Imagine, whatever your stance,
take some time out to at least investigate this because I guarantee you
wont hear anything quite as wonderful as this for a very long time.
You can hear some scraps from it at http://chriscornell.com/songbook/
but youll be doing yourself a massive disservice by not slipping
on the headphones, turning out all the lights and burying yourself in
its entire soundscape.
From Edna Gunderson of USA
Today:
A stunning solo acoustic tour yielded this live sampler,
and while some track list picks are mystifying (John Lennon's Imagine
instead of Sunshower?), Songbook's pristine recordings nicely showcase
Cornell's vocal dexterity and emotional thrust. Selections span his career,
from Soundgarden and Temple of the Dog to Audioslave and solo efforts,
and even the loud, dense originals shine after a stripdown.
From Jim Farber of the New
York Daily News:
When most musicians banish their sidemen and cut the
electricity, they mean to come clean. They want to sound intimate and
close without the distractions and asides of volume and company.
Not Chris Cornell.
He may have launched his first-ever, one-man acoustic
tour this year, but if you think one of the world’s greatest bravura singers
would use that opportunity to whisper and mewl, think again.
“Songbook,” the CD document of the tour, finds
this famously macho frontman of Soundgarden, Temple of the Dog, and Audioslave
in full “golden god” yowl. Though accompanied solely by his lone acoustic
guitar, Cornell sings loud and hard more often than not. In other words,
he hasn’t suddenly turned into Bon Iver, or even James Taylor.
Some might see this as a failure of nerve. Certainly,
his chest-pumping approach robbed the tour and album of shock value. But
the result has two compensating features. For one, Cornell’s brawling delivery
expresses a very masculine kind of vulnerability — the equivalent to a tough
guy hitting the wall in anger instead of expressing his frustration in tears.
More, the approach means fans get to bask in the sheer power of Cornell’s
instrument without any parallel wailing electric guitars and pounding drums
to get in the way.
In that sense, “Songbook” reveals Cornell as a kind
of rock opera singer, a big-chested orator of his inner life. His choice
of songs aids that mission. Embedded in their big chords and rich arrangements
lie genuine confessions.
To ferret them out, Cornell made careful, and uncommercial,
selections in his repertoire. Only two Soundgarden touchstones turn up:
“Black Hole Sun” and “Fell on Black Days.” The latter proves it doesn’t
need its original heaviness to achieve motion and mystery. Two oldies
from Temple of the Dog appear, the better being “Call Me a Dog,” which
showcases Cornell’s chops and range.
The singer favored songs from his iffy solo albums
here, but they sound more melodically worthy in this bony form. Many boast
a psychedelic-pop finery. One song, written for a solo album that never
appeared on one (“Cleaning My Gun”), deserved to. Even songs from Cornell’s
ill-advised project with Timbaland, like “As Hope and Promise Fade,” sound
more robust stripped down. (It would have been better, though, had Cornell
stuck with the song’s original, catchier title: “Two Drink Minimum”).
The disk includes one studio solo spin (“The Keeper”),
featuring a more subtle vocal from Cornell, which proves he was indeed
playing to the crowd live. So, dock him a few points for that. But if
his main aim with his spare setup was to wow us, wow us he did.
From Scott Bartlett of Subba-Cultcha:
Chris Cornell and Co got
the Grungers salivating of course when they announced the mighty Soundgarden
were reforming to tour and hopefully release new material in 2012. A band
of almost unrivaled power in their day, the comeback has been celebrated
and, of course, helped gloss over the flack Cornell has taken from some
of his more recent solo outings.
While its good to see people trying different
things the lack of quality control of late has sometimes been hard to
forgive, even though hes earned the right to make a few howlers.
Here, on Songbook he bravely takes his guitar and
barstool to the masses to perform a mix of material. The chest beating
rock God stripped bare, indeed. The results are, overall quite stunning.
His voice is at its unpolished, graveled best and his delivery is never
less than sincere.
People will naturally focus on Soundgarden classics
Black Hole Sun and Fell On Black Days where Cornell is at his emotive
best. Both sound incredible here. The Temple Of The Dog era Call Me A
Dog and All Night Thing, Scar On The Sky from his second solo album Carry
On and Audioslaves Wide Awake also stand out and he lives up to
all those Robert Plant of grunge comparisons hes been
tagged with over the years more than adequately on Led Zeppelin's Thank
You.
In fact, public service announcement and point of
order; anyone who doesnt own the Temple Of The Dog album should
get a copy right now. Thank you.
His version of Imagine is a little bit student party
but carries just enough swagger to pull it off. The Keeper from
the Machine Gun Preacher soundtrack, fares much better, gentle, folksy,
and overflowing with charm.
Back to basics certainly suits Cornell. Ravaged but
in turn richer from years of wailing, he sounds in very rude health.
Press reviews of Chris Cornell's
single The Keeper, the theme song for movie Machine Gun Preacher:

From Marc Hogan of Spin:
From the soundtrack to new action movie Machine Gun
Preacher, "The Keeper" is slow, ruminative folk-pop from the
perspective of a world-weary wanderer. "It doesn't take too long
for this road to become a battlefield," Cornell sings with a gentle
rasp. On Letterman, the song leaves ample room for the rocker to show
his voice's prettier side as the tune comes to a honeyed, ooh-ing conclusion.
From Rick Florino of Artist
Direct:
Chris Cornell's brand new song, "The Keeper",
is just as riveting as Machine Gun Preacher is.
Of course Cornell penned the song with the film's
main character, real-life hero Sam Childers [Gerard Butler], in mind,
but it still possesses the hallmarks of the iconic singer's sound. He
tells a story of struggle and triumph in barely over three minutes, and
with his inimitable pipes, he communicates an avalanche of emotions that
mirror the protagonist's journey from a hardened, drug-addled outlaw into
a savior for oppressed children in Africa.
That emotional heft can be felt in each chord strum
as well as the heavenly refrain that Cornell delivers with the same passion
that made Badmotorfinger and Superunknown classics. His finger-picked
melody nods to Led Zeppelin's "Going to California" in reverent
fashion as each note resounds clearly.
The lyrics palpitate with a visceral and vulnerable
vibrancy. Cornell sings, "And before I let one more tear hit the
ground, I will be the one standing between you and the sound of the rounds
echoing out, out of the dark, the smoke and the spark, aimed at the heart
of the flame".
It's poetic, powerful, and poignant, especially as
the bridge sails off into sensitively psychedelic space. Cornell manages
to channel Bob Dylan and Robert Plant all at once in one of the best songs
of his own catalog. Download it now on iTunes!
5 out of 5 stars
From Corban of Stereogum:
The soundtrack for the forthcoming film Machine Gun
Preacher features a new Chris Cornell track called The Keeper,
which is a welcome return to the spare acoustic work of his early material.
For the first 24 hours, the track will be available on Cornells
website and all proceeds will benefit Sam Childers Angels of East
Africa charity.
From SFCritic.com:
Soundgarden lead singer, Chris Cornell, who holds
a special place in our teenage hearts for Blackhole Son", [sic]
has released The Keeper off the soundtrack from the movie
Machine Gun Preacher. For the next 24 hours the track is available for
donate-to-download with proceeds going to the Machine Gun Preacher Organization,
which helps provide a safe haven for the multitudes of children and adults
fleeing enslavement by the brutal Lords Resistance Army in Northern
Uganda and Southern Sudan. On The Keeper Cornell softly sings
Beauty and truth collide where love meets genocide, where laughter
meets fear, confusion all around while I try to feed these mouths
as he gently shifts between notes on an acoustic guitar. Its nothing
like Soundgarden, but much more comparable to Eddie Vedders work
on Into The Wild. Please donate, help, and enjoy.
From All Music For Apple:
This track from the movie Machine Gun Preacher sounds
like Chris Cornell returning to the sonic vibe of Temple of the Dog. Acoustic,
a little eerie, and 100% heartfelt. Beautiful melodies stacked on top
of a real traveling feel on the guitar, like a man walking across the
plains in rural America--not wandering, but with a purpose and a quiet
focus. Brilliant.
Press reviews of Soundgarden's
retrospective live album, Live on I5, out March 22:

from Gregg Moffitt of the BBC:
The first ever live album from Seattle grunge pioneers
Soundgarden should have appeared years ago, literally. Recorded at various
locations during a 1996 US tour, Live on I-5 was intended for release
the following year. Sadly, after the band split in April 1997, the tapes
were left to gather dust on a studio shelf and even now have probably
only been unearthed in the wake of last year’s reunion. We should be thankful
they bothered: Live on I-5 is stuffed with searing performances from a
band at the peak of their powers.
Although stitched together from material culled from
several shows, Live on I-5 doesn’t suffer from the lack of cohesion which
often blights live albums assembled this way. This says a lot about the
band’s consistency, and although single-event recordings possess a unique
aura, this 17-track set is a worthy document of Soundgarden’s glory days.
There’s certainly nothing here which hints at a group on the road to self-destruction.
Opening and closing with hit singles may be an obvious
crowd-pleasing ploy, but Spoonman and Jesus Christ Pose bookend a set
littered with songs which will be familiar to anyone alive during the
1990s, never mind those immersed in the music which did so much to define
the decade. From the hard rock swagger of Searching With My Good Eye Closed
and Let Me Drown to the grunge-101 of Outshined and Rusty Cage, the band
somehow bludgeon with the finesse they bring to moodier material such
as Slaves and Bulldozers and Nothing to Say. Even songs from their final
studio album, the markedly more lightweight Down on the Upside, sound
vital and invigorating.
A slow-burning take on The Beatles’ endlessly-covered
Helter Skelter and a run-through of The Stooges’ Search and Destroy shed
some light on the band’s roots and on grunge itself as a somewhat unlikely
hybrid of both establishment and anti-establishment elements. Like most
music movements, grunge eventually ate itself, degenerating into just
another fad. But in Soundgarden – as with Nirvana – it spawned a band
beyond lazy labels and genre limits, and Live on I-5 is simply a great
rock record, period.
from Chris Kies of Premier
Guitar:
Live on I-5 compiles 17 greatest hits-worthy
tracks from Soundgarden’s late-’96 tour that ventured up-and-down the
Pacific Coast, captured by a rented 24-track recording truck. While this
was a schism-laden time between band members that sparked their downward
spiral and eventual breakup in April 1997, the music packaged here doesn't
show it. (Maybe that’s why they went with a live CD release rather than
a DVD release.) Guitarist Kim Thayil is on his odd-time-signature game,
offering Seattle-sludge riff after riff with standouts efforts on a rampaging
“Jesus Christ Pose,” feedback-harnessed solos on “Slaves and Bulldozers,”
and even a bit of wah-wankery on the Stooges’ “Search and Destroy” and
“Searching With My Good Eye Closed.”
Chris Cornell helps thicken the guitars by providing support throughout,
but most noticeably on the heart-pounding opener “Spoonman” and mach-speed
“Rusty Cage.” But Cornell’s presence on guitars is overshadowed by his
spine-tingling heroics on vocals. His primal, blood curdling roars and
signature falsetto screams are spot-on during showstoppers “Ty Cobb,”
"Rusty Cage," and “Black Hole Sun”—which is nearly a cappella except for
a lone guitar. However, Cornell excels similarly when he cleans it up
and shows his dynamic range on “Burden in My Hands,” "Fell on Black Days,”
and the Beatles’ “Helter Skelter.”
The tracks are gathered from a handful of shows making the disc more of
a live compilation than a true concert album, however, the music is cohesive,
the performances are tight, and the overall collection is as powerful
as Soundgarden ever sounded.
4.5 out of 5
from James Greene Jr of Crawdaddy:
1990s grunge superstars Soundgarden
cycled through all the expected rock n’ roll tropes during their original
13 years together: they started as underground heroes, sleekly transitioned
to the mainstream during Seattle’s sonic boom, satiated hard rock fans
with a slew of powerful and arena-ready riffage, found their greatest
success with a five minute ballad, and broke up arguably at the height
of the fame amidst rumors of serious group acrimony. The only thing they
forgot was the requisite live album; thankfully, last year’s unexpected
Soundgarden reunion has begat that final missing piece of the puzzle.
Live on I5 (a reference to a specific stretch of Pacific coast
highway) gathers concert recordings from a 1996 Soundgarden tour, and
damned if it ain’t a fine reminder of the lumbering beast Cornell, Thayil,
Cameron, and Shepherd created when put together.
A surprisingly crisp sound pervades I5?s
recordings as Soundgarden nimbly rip through rhythmic standards such as
“Spoonman” and “Slaves and Bulldozers”, and no atmosphere is lost when
the band tones it down for more insular properties like Superunknown’s
mellow “Head Down”. Of course, any superfan attending a Soundgarden concert
in 1996 was probably there mostly to hear the bare-knuckle motorcycle
roar of the band’s breakthrough hit, “Outshined”; here, singer Chris Cornell
is a little shaky in his delivery, but the extra gristle on Kim Thayil’s
guitar more than makes up for Corny’s melodic wavering. To be fair to
Chris, there are plenty of spots on I5 where his singing is the
absolute highlight. “Nothing to Say” would be pretty rote without those
cascading, anguished howls.
If there’s any honest misstep to be heard during Live
on I5, it might be Soundgarden’s moody interpretation of that Beatles
classic “Helter Skelter” just before the ever-uplifting “Boot Camp”. “Skelter’s”
arrangement is sort of grunge lounge—it’s easy to imagine Cornell in a
powder blue tuxedo, running his hands through his hair and not looking
at anyone in particular as he groans out, “You may be a luhvuh but you
ain’ no dance-uh!” into one of those oversized 1930s box microphones.
On the other hand, maybe that was the intent. I have similar quality control
questions about the speed of “Ty Cobb”, Soundgarden’s balls-to-the-wall
Ramones tribute, as performed on I5—it seems a hare too fast
for its own good—but methinks I just miss the kooky banjo overdubs that
are all over the studio version. Real talk: my toes were a-tappin’ all
the way through this (possibly extra) speedy “Cobb”.
Any lingering historical doubts regarding Soundgarden’s
musical prowess are obliterated by Live on I5?s monolithic closing
rendition of “Jesus Christ Pose”. Rising up like some ancient pissed off
Sumerian god, the band breathes incredible life into that creaking giant
of modern rock and leaves no possible room for improvement. Matt Cameron’s
limber drum work reminds us the secret to all great bands is an ace percussionist.
There’s grace to be heard even as the song collapses on itself and fades
into a thin fog of amplifier feedback. Truly, this group was/is a garden
of sounds, one basically unmatched by its goatee’d, nose ringed peers.
Listen: the whole daggum thing on
Facebook.
From Steven Fanning of Subba
Cultcha:
The primal force of grunge from one of its finest
exponents
Having been one of the defining bands of their generation,
released some of the seminal albums from the early nineties and earned
a legion of devoted fans across the globe, the decision some twenty years
since grunge was tearing up the world to finally release a live album
is perhaps the penultimate part in the Soundgarden story, before a b-sides
and rarities compilation finally makes a long overdue appearance. Those
who saw Soundgarden live tell different stories, they were seemingly either
very, very bad or very, very good on stage, there was no middle ground.
On the one occasion I caught them live they were in decline and their
performance wasn’t brilliant, to say the least, so it’s with not a little
apprehension that I hit the play button and sit back to listen to Live
On I5.
This isn’t a recording of a complete gig, the 17 tracks on here were recorded
on the West Coast leg of their tour in support of their final album Down
On The Upside in 1996 at various venues and have been cherry picked
by the band. The emphasis is on their final three records – Badmotorfinger,
Superunknown and Down On The Upside with only ‘Nothing
To Say’ making the cut from their early Sub Pop days and Louder Than
Love and Ultramega OK being overlooked entirely.
‘Spoonman’ begins things in typical chunky style, the descending riff
slightly slower than the record but with a nicely extended mid section
and a great guitar solo from Kim Thayil. ‘Searching With My Good Eye Closed’
is as good as the studio version and ‘Let Me Drown’ (which iTunes thinks
is called ‘Let Me Down’ from the album Love On I5 – someone needs
telling off) is one of the real highlights on here. It’s dark, dirty and
beautifully heavy, a distinct vibe running through it that can only be
captured live. ‘Head Down’ follows, a slower antidote to the intensity
of the preceding track and demonstrating some great musicianship. ‘Outshined’
is simply brilliant. It’s a great song to start with, but captured here
in all its full-on glory gives it a new lease of life. ‘Rusty Cage’ is
fast and furious, Cameron’s drumming giving it another edge and making
the song as brutal as the lyrics.
The two covers on here of the Beatles' ‘Helter Skelter’ and the Stooges'
‘Search And Destroy’ show a different side to Soundgarden. The treatment
of ‘Helter Skelter’ is to make it disjointed, ponderous and bluesy whereas
they race through ‘Search And Destroy’, doing some kind of dubious justice
to both in their own way with the grunge makeovers bestowed upon them.
‘Nothing To Say’ is a welcome reminder of where Soundgarden came from
and demonstrates how they shaped the sound of the music to come, and it’s
a shame that some more of the early Fopp and Screaming Life
tracks weren’t included on here and that ‘Hands All Over’, from Louder
Than Love, wasn’t performed either, but these are minor grumbles.
‘Burden In My Hand’, ‘Dusty’ and ‘Boot Camp’ are unfortunately as unremarkable
live as they were on record, and ‘Ty Cobb’ is pleasantly thrashy but wasn’t
really what Soundgarden were all about, this was Down On The Upside’s
‘Kickstand’ but without the finesse and doesn’t really sit too well alongside
the overriding metal guitar that was Soundgarden’s style, although it’s
notable here just for the interplay between Ben Shepherd and Matt Cameron.
‘Slaves And Bulldozers’ in contrast is epic, grinding rock, although Cornell’s
voice doesn’t quite cut it on here it’s this added dimension of imperfection
which augments the live experience, the extended performance of the song
is compelling and you get the feeling that this is Soundgarden really
expressing themselves and in doing so engaging their audience.
‘Fell On Black Days’ is one of the defining moments of grunge,
a truly brilliant and cathartic song given a good airing here, Cornell’s
vocals softer perhaps than on record and a little restrained and the decision
to include a solo performance of ‘Black Hole Sun’ was an inspired one.
‘Black Hole Sun’ was the song that finally saw Soundgarden hit the mainstream
and as a consequence it became overplayed and suffered from an immense
amount of overkill, so a different take on it, stripping it down to the
bare bones of one man and his guitar is a welcome change, a trick that
Cornell has repeated consistently since on his solo tours in the intervening
years between Soundgarden’s break-up and the reformation last year.
This brings us to ‘Jesus Christ Pose’, arguably Soundgarden’s finest song
and the track that first began their assent to super-stardom. The deep,
heavy riff offset with Cornell’s piercing vocals make for a timeless rock
song, but the real star of this version is Cameron on the drums. His tirelessness
and innate ability to make the drums such an integral part of the performance
are quite remarkable. His contribution to Soundgarden and Pearl Jam is
often too understated, but he is the glue that holds these bands together.
This record is long overdue and is a welcome addition to the Soundgarden
legacy, documenting them when they were on fine form live. The decision
to cherry-pick tracks from across a tour was probably a good idea, the
more lacklustre moments of their live shows easily removed to provide
an experience of what they perhaps consider the perfect Soundgarden gig.
Sure, there are always some songs you wish they’d played, but it’s enough
to be thankful for those that they did. The nineties were a great time
to be alive, and this is a none too gentle reminder of what made the grunge
era so special and another example of why and how Soundgarden outshined
so many of their contemporaries. Fingers crossed that when they finally
get on the road again they can recapture their magic because when they’re
good, they’re very, very good.
9 out of 10
From Rick Florino of Artist
Direct:
Most live records don't capture the primal, poetic
power that Soundgarden's Live on I5 does.
In fact, most studio records don't either, but that's another story. Recorded
over various dates during the west coast leg of Soundgarden's 1996 tour,
Live on I5 is the legendary band's very first proper live release, and
it stands alongside their classic albums Louder Than Love, Badmotorfinger,
Superunknown, and Down on the Upside proudly. There's an urgency to the
recording, and you can practically hear guitar god Kim Thayil picking
the meandering riff during opener, "Spoonman." An older gem, "Searching
with my Good Eye Closed," builds with a rhythmic darkness from drummer
Matt Cameron's polyrhythmic pummeling and Ben Shepherd's brooding bass
lines. At the heart of the sonic maelstrom, Chris Cornell bleeds every
inch of his soul into each into each note of "Let Me Drown" and the psychedelically
invasive Superunknown standout "Head Down." There's a paranoid sensitivity
pulsating through these live renditions that takes hold of the record
and doesn't let go—just like everything the band's done.
"Burden in My Hand" sees Cornell reach heights that only Robert Plant
could, while the chug on "Slaves & Bulldozers" celebrates Black Sabbath
musically, while encasing the delivery in its own sludgy brilliance. The
band's cover of "Helter Skelter" proves poignant, seeing Cornell tear
through the song with a punk fire and the accompanying music morph into
full heavy metal rapture.
"Fell on Black Days" comes to life on stage as the crowd echoes its calculated
catharsis in the dark hook. The band subtly shines in pockets of instrumental
virtuosity bubbling up just under the surface of their mega-hit "Black
Hole Sun," as the audience's energy practically roars through the speakers.
Everything culminates with a divine "Jesus Christ Pose," as Cornell's
screams reach out to heaven before one final crushing embrace of guitars,
drums, and bass sends it all home.
I5 never sounded so beautiful, and Soundgarden have crafted a classic
live album. This is essential listening and the perfect way to whet your
appetite for the band's anxiously awaited forthcoming studio album.
4.5 stars out of 5
Live albums can be notoriously hard to review. After
all, they’re usually the mixture of a band’s finest songs -“best of” moments
carved out in time – and it’s hard to complain about some of the most
iconic and revered songs in an artist’s discography. It’s also difficult
to encapsulate the power of a live performance when the listener isn’t
there to witness it themselves. As great as the best live album might
sound, it still pales in comparison to the real thing. To see it is to
believe it.
Soundgarden’s first-ever live album, Live on the
I-5, has three things which make it stand out from other releases
of its kind, right off the bat. For one, this is the first material Soundgarden
has released since their breakup in 1997 (not counting last year’s resurrected
“Black Rain”), which makes it automatically appreciated by any self-respecting
fan. Second, the recordings were all captured during a slice of their
1996 tour, back when Chris Cornell’s voice was at its most powerful and
the band still produced an aura of unity. Third…well, it’s Soundgarden.
To say they were one of the strongest purveyors of grunge may sound outdated
now, but there’s no denying the band’s near legendary place in that particular
music scene.
The album title takes its name from Interstate 5,
which runs up the West coast. The recorded shows all fall somewhere along
that road, including Vancouver, BC, their hometown of Seattle, WA, Oakland
and Del Mar, CA, and Salem, OR. Aside from playing a lot of their hits,
such as the energetic “Spoonman” (in Del Mar), a raucous “Rusty Cage”
(in Vancouver, BC), and the schizophrenic “Jesus Christ Pose” (in Oakland),
there are some unusual twists and turns. A successfully slinkier
version of “Black Hole Sun” (performed in Seattle), and a frenzied rendition
of “Ty Cobb” come to life, while a slowed-down cover of “Helter Skelter”
and a version of The Stooges’ “Search and Destroy” give fans some “new”
material to feast their ears on.
Cornell’s voice sounds noticeably rough and broken
at parts (“Let Me Down” comes to mind), but, for the most part, he manages
to maintain his famous guttural wail throughout. The sound is also exceptionally
well-mixed, and the output from the audience never overpowers the songs.
Instead, it adds just enough excitement and atmosphere. The only caveat
here is that the recordings were done at different shows during the tour,
which can hamper any feelings of continuity. Luckily, these recordings
flow together nicely for the most part, at times giving the impression
that they could have been recorded in one place, at one time.
There’s nothing too exceptional about Live on
the I-5, but given that this is the first new release from the recent
reincarnation of Soundgarden, it’s worth a listen. Plus, knowing that
the band is working on new material, it’s just enough to tide over the
band’s patient fanbase while still keeping people on their toes.
3.5 stars out of 5
From The
Music Fix:
The Interstate 5, or I5 as
it is commonly referred to, runs the length of the West Coast, from the
Canadian boarder all the way down to Mexico. On its way South, it passes
though grunge mecca Seattle, Washington, home of the mighty Soundgarden.
They was grunge even before there was grunge. They were the forefathers,
the leaders. In their heyday they could not be touched, not even by that
other celebrated Seattle band. With Chris Cornell's Wagnerian vocals (which
could go from gut growling roar to a blood curdling scream in seconds)
matched with Kim Thayil's ferocious guitar, they perfectly melded the
70s rock might of Led Zeppelin with the stripped down, bare bones no nonsense
sound booming out of Seattle clubs in the mid-80s.
Live on I5, recorded during the West Coast leg of
their 1996 tour for Down on the Upside, was set to be released after the
tour, however the band's demise the following year meant that it was left
gathering dust in a Seattle recording studio for 13 years. Now, in celebration
of their 2010 reunion tour and release of the retrospective collection
Telephantasm, this gem can now see the light of day and remind people
just what all the fuss was about. Incorporating songs from their last
three studio albums - Badmotorfinger, Superunknown and Down on the Upside
- the 17 song set demonstrates just what a superbly tight-knit live act
Soundgarden were. With little ado and virtually no stage banter, the band
charge through the set as if their lives depended on it. Well-known numbers
like 'Rusty Cage', 'Black Hole Sun' (here performed as a solo by Chris
Cornell) and a truly blistering rendition of the mammoth 'Jesus Christ
Pose', ride along side other killer tunes such as 'Spoonman', 'Outshined'
and an excellently creepy version of The Beatles' classic 'Helter Skelter'.
The only let down that can be said is the absence of anything from Louder
Than Love. Ah well.
Live on I5 brings home all the power and magnitude
of one of the most important bands to come out of the Seattle scene. For
some this will be a trip down memory lane, for others a chance to have
a taste of the magic that is alas long gone.
8 out of 10
From William Kherbek
of Alt
Sounds:
Here we go. It’s been a
long time since I’ve listened to a song by Soundgarden, I think Superunknown’s
ubiquity made it almost impossible for me to think of the band in the
same way I had when Badmotorfinger and Louder than Love came out, but
listening to the new live album, “Live on I-5” which collects some fiery
performances from several classic West Coast shows, I was reminded what
I had been missing. All the classics are here, “Spoon Man”, “Fell on Black
Days”, “Jesus Christ Pose”, maybe not so happily “Black Hole Sun” too.
There are plenty of tracks for true believers as well, a damn solid version
of “Burden in My Hand” which was much, much better than I remember it
being.
“Outshined,” routinely one of the best songs to hear them play live is
great here, the way it balances between the kind of thunderous heaviness
that makes you fear someone’s resurrected a dinosaur and the shiny brilliance
of the chorus. It all feels so liberatory, you can almost forget how ponderous
grunge ended up being most of the time.
Then there’s “Rusty Cage” which is completely
frantic in the best possible way. Rare is the rock song that makes you
ponder the implications it has for philosophy, but as I was listening
to the guys thrash their way through “Rusty Cage” I thought about how
the concept of Romanticism had evolved in 20th Century America. Gone was
the stultifying imperative to elevation so deeply ingrained in European
conceptions, Soundgarden seem to tap into a primal, American Romanticism
that owes very little to transcendentalism but more to the kind of indigenous
vision quests that colour American literary classics. Plus it rocks. Hard.
Lesser known tracks shouldn’t feel too Minnesota as they’re given space
to breathe too. “Slaves and Bulldozers” has a great sludgy viscosity,
and Kim Thayil’s guitar on “Boot Camp” goes from sensitive to vicious
in no time at all. If there’s a real star of the album it’s Thayil who
is one of the few guitarists who you feel deserves the right to use as
many pedals as he wants because, in his hands they realise their true
potential. If there’s a down side to the album, it is a bit long. Live
albums are notoriously bloated and Live on I-5 probably wouldn’t be ruined
by being a bit shorter but still it’s great to hear the Garden in full
bloom again.
Press reviews of Soundgarden's retrospective set Telephantasm:

When
Chris Cornell announced at the beginning of this year that Soundgarden
were to reform after a staggering 12 year break, you could almost hear
the celebration by fans the world over from behind their Twitter pages.
Since then the band have
not disappointed, by releasing this compilation (both through the recent
Guitar Hero: Warriors of Rock game and in stores), playing a secret reunion
show and headlining America’s prestigious Lollapalooza festival this summer.
Current offering, Telephantasm
is the epitome of what a good retrospective compilation should be … and
then some. With an impressive 24-song track listing that includes all
the original hits as well as previously unreleased songs and live versions,
the fun doesn’t just stop there. This also includes a DVD with bonus videos
on to boot. A great showcase of the band’s impeccable talent spanning
their 14year career until their untimely demise back in 1997.
From listening to Telephantasm,
there are no two ways about it; Chris Cornell is something of a genius.
This is just a small reminder of just how amazing Soundgarden were back
in their day. Songs such as ‘Black Hole Sun’, ‘Spoonman’, ‘Blow Up The
Outside World’ and (personal favourite) ‘Burden In My Hand’ may now sound
slightly dated and have more of a nostalgic sentiment attached to them
for the listener. The band may not pick up many new fans with this album,
but then again that doesn’t seem to be what this was released for. Soundgarden
have their loyal fans, and that’s all that matters to them.
Let’s hope they can continue
to churn out songs of this calibre and magnitude if and when they finally
get into the studio for a follow-up. Although, at the moment it seems
to be more a case of when than if. Just how it should be.
From Derric Miller
of Hardrock
Haven: 8.2/10
If for no other reason
than to own a copy of the obscenely hilarious track Big Dumb Sex,
you have to purchase a copy of Soundgardens era-spanning compilation
Telephantasm. Approximately 99 percent of these kinds of compilations
especially when coming from bands like Motley Crue or KISS or Bon
Jovi are purely marketing gimmicks. There is absolutely nothing
to gain from owning them. Conversely, Telephantasm brings you back to
the days when Soundgarden was at their most unpolished and rawest yet
flaunted the most potential out of any band on the Seattle scene,
and listening to an older song like Hands All Over next to
a hit like Black Hole Sun proves evolution actually exists,
no matter what Tea Party pundits argue.
Disc 1 is the better of the duo on this two CD-set,
mostly because it houses the lesser known tracks. Disc 2 is riddled with
classic compositions like Birth Ritual, Spoonman,
Black Hole Sun, Fell on Black Days, Pretty
Noose, and Blow Up the Outside World, but that wont
teach you anything new. Hearing where they came from into the legend they
are today is the draw of this compilation.
You get a simplistic punk vibe from the opener, All
Your Lies, and the male version of the banshee Chris Cornell
opens his maw and you hear talent just discovering itself. Repetition
was the name of the game for Soundgarden early on, especially when the
recurring All your fears are lies, line, and they do it to
comical levels on the aforementioned Big Dumb Sex. There is
a palpable corrosion to this composition, something they wrote specifically
to be jagged and unfriendly, but its somehow still catchy.
Hands All Over is the perfect example
of Soundgarden milling around in that radio-friendly gray area between
mainstream acceptance and sticking to their roots. The sexual drive of
the song, from the churning bass of Ben Shepherd to the quirky guitar
riff from Kim Thayil shows musical growth, but the lyrics step up into
a darker poetic and visual onslaught, and Cornell wails on lines like,
Got my arms around baby brother; put your hands away, youre
going to kill your mother! The less repetitive the band became,
the more creative songwriters they discovered within themselves.
Of course, Soundgarden is a live animal, and you will
get plenty of chances to feel their venom live. Get on the Snake
is the first one, sort of a wailing, plodding song that is mostly effective
as a sign of the times, although Cornells vocals show
a vaster flexibility than their ilk like Nirvana, obviously Pearl Jam,
Mudhoney, Screaming Trees, and basically every other band from that era.
Layne Staley was the only singer even close to meeting Cornells
talent, but didnt stick around long enough for the end game.
Black Rain is the unreleased song Telephantasm
brags about. Its a demo version, and rides that weird, chugging
rhythm Soundgarden trademarked back in the day. Soundgardens earlier
songs, like Full on Kevins Mom (not found on this compilation)
was pure chaos, and the vocal rhythms on Black Rain are shrieking
and nearly un-rhythmic; you dont know when they are cutting in for
sure. Thats not a negative by any stretch; Soundgarden is relevant
because of their ability to be musical innovators, and Black Rain
is one of those songs that if you never heard, youd know it was
Soundgarden after just a few introductory notes.
With 24 songs, some buried treasures and a bevy of
hits, Telephantasm is more than worth your time. If the band can still
funnel this freakishly sexual, ominous yet melodic concoction of Hard
Rock into new music today, they should do it. Only the entire planet would
be better off for it.
From AJ Ramirez of
Popmatters:
9/10
The story hasn't gotten
old now
When Soundgarden split up in 1997, the press didn’t
canonize the band like it did to fellow ‘90s grunge casualty Nirvana.
The group’s demise was merely mourned with sad platitudes, marked as yet
another nail in the coffin that was alternative rock’s declining mainstream
power at the end of the decade. Since then, it’s been easy to take the
band’s existence for granted, reserved for obligatory acknowledgment in
grunge histories and by the continued presence of select Soundgarden hits
on rock radio stations. However, steps are being taken to rectify that,
as earlier this year, the group’s classic quartet of Chris Cornell, Kim
Thayil, Ben Shepherd, and Matt Cameron has taken cues from other major
alt-rock bands that imploded around the lean years where nu-metal and
teen pop dominated popular music (Smashing Pumpkins, Alice in Chains,
Stone Temple Pilots, Blur, etc.) by reforming for a spate of touring.
To commemorate (or cash in on, depending on how cynical
you are) this development, A&M has issued a new deluxe-sized retrospective,
Telephantasm (a bare bones 12-track single-disc edition is also
available). The immediate question raised is whether or not there is actually
a need for a second Soundgarden compilation. After all, the 1998 singles
collection A-Sides issued following the group’s initial demise
hit pretty much all the high points one would expect a Soundgarden collection
to cover. Ah, but what people often forget when it comes to compilation
albums is that context is key. By stretching out, roping in key non-single
cuts, and providing a bonus DVD loaded with all the group’s videos, Telephantasm
not only supplants A-Sides as the definitive Soundgarden compilation,
but it emerges as one of the most thrilling, effective band retrospectives
to come out in years.
I like Soundgarden as much as any other rock fan probably
does (tracks from the band’s 1994 masterpiece Superunknown still
figure into my personal listening rotation), but what’s astounding about
Telephantasm is how its presentation of the band’s material makes
it compulsively listenable. Upon first receiving a copy of the album,
I popped the second disc into my computer merely to see if the live version
of “Jesus Christ Pose” included was really worthy of replacing its studio
counterpart (which, in my mind, is one of the most confounding, yet exhilarating,
singles ever released by a major record label) on the record’s running
order. Five or six tracks later, I had to forcefully pull myself away
in order to complete my errands for the day. Once this record starts,
you do not want to hit the stop button. Furthermore, the record never
lets up in regard to either infectiousness or visceral-ness: akin to my
first experience listening to the 1997 remix of the Stooges’ classic album
Raw Power, the thought that constantly ran through me during my
initial examination was “I think this album is actually trying to murder
me”.
The deluxe version of Telephantasm stretches
from “All Your Lies” from the seminal 1986 Deep Six compilation,
on through to the new single “Black Rain”, which is actually a previously
unreleased song recorded during sessions for Soundgarden’s 1991 breakthrough
Badmotorfinger. Early on, Soundgarden was already compelling, even
if a little too conventionally metal in places. Built out of spiraling
hypno-riffs, “All Your Lies” showcases a raw, sinewy Soundgarden featuring
vocals by a fresh-faced Cornell that surprisingly recall Judas Priest’s
Rob Halford. Although one of the founders of grunge in the mid 1980s,
Soundgarden was always more complicated than the conventional shorthand
description of the genre as a simple mash-up of punk and heavy metal:
aside from an audible Black Flag influence, the group evidenced more of
a desire to mix arty, dissonant post-punk (Bauhaus and Gang of Four) and
“pigfuck” noise rock (Sonic Youth, Butthole Surfers) than standard hardcore
with its ’70 metal riffing.
“All Your Lies” is a hell of a start, and Telephantasm
continues to impress over the course of the first disc as the group finds
its voice and hones its attack. Even as early as “Beyond the Wheel”, Soundgarden
was demonstrating how adept it was at delivering awe-inspiring apocalyptic
doom dirges. Another important development was the gradual introduction
of psychedelic influences, which added color to Soundgarden’s monochrome
angst. Relative weak spots like “Fopp” (wah-wah pedal heavy-funk that
only really clicks whenever it gets to the chorus) and “Big Dumb Sex”
(a crass pseudo-anthem that isn’t really good enough to make up for its
ham-fisted attempt at irony) do emerge, but these are minor concerns as
the disc is able to regain its momentum after each misstep, and the disc
ends stronger than it begins as it concludes with A-rate cuts from Badmotorfinger
like the downer-than-down rock radio staple “Outshined” and the appropriately-descriptive
“Slaves and Bulldozers”. While the initial major label positioning of
Soundgarden as the next Guns ‘N Roses seemed at odds with its roots in
the Sub Pop-dominated Seattle alt-rock scene, there is no such ideological
conflict contained in the music itself, which posits the group as a perfect
mixture of metal and alternative sensibilities, able to straddle both
genres as if they were one integrated whole.
If the first disc made the case that the band hit
the ground running creatively from the outset, by the second disc, Telephantasm
convincingly argues for the band’s place alongside metal icons Led Zeppelin
and Black Sabbath, the two bands it was most often compared to. Kicking
off with the phenomenal 1993 live rendition of “Jesus Christ Pose” (a
superheated cauldron of metal and alternative rock that constantly threatens
to scorch your face off, ending with over a minute of post-trauma guitar
feedback), the disc runs through the Singles soundtrack contribution
“Birth Ritual” before making its way through a hefty chunk of Superunknown.
When the band’s biggest hit, “Black Hole Sun”, finally shows up, the mood
is serene yet disconcerting, like being passed over by the eye of a devastating
hurricane. As the album reaches the cuts culled from the band’s final
album, Down on the Upside (1996), the group has finally shaken
off its remaining Zeppelisms (aside from Cornell’s eternally Robert Plant-flavored
wail) in favor of casting itself as a sort of grunge Beatles, all Lennonesque
melodies intertwined with Soundgarden’s customary detuned, odd-meter riffs.
It’s certainly more melodic than what have come before, but the intensity
remains. After all that, the newly-released “Black Rain” has a lot to
live up to. Refreshingly, the track is vintage Soundgarden, a perfectly
acceptable addition to the set even if its psychedelic Sabbath-isms become
a bit repetitive.
If that wasn’t enough, the bonus DVD rounds up every
Soundgarden promo video, including alternate and uncensored versions.
The visuals are less cohesive than the musical assemblage, as the rock
vid clichés of the Louder than Love promos (large spot-lit soundstages
and lots of hard rock posturing) stand at odds with the seemingly mandatory
surreal imagery of 1990s alternative rock videos that dominates the rest
of the clips. Nothing exemplifies this aesthetic shift better than how
Chris Cornell (grunge’s only true sex symbol) appears in full bare-chested
and long-haired glory up until the Superunknown era, where he opts
for a more post-Alternative Nation-friendly messy crop and t-shirts. If
you can forgive the dated computer special effects (particularly on the
“Superunknown” video included in the Bonus section), many of the videos
still hold up to a modern viewing.
What prevents Telephantasm from being absolutely
perfect is some rather boneheaded tracklist decisions. The biggest omission
is the harrowing Superunknown single “The Day I Tried to Live”,
truly one of the band’s bleakest and most powerful moments. Several tracks
see their studio incarnations replaced by previously-unreleased live renditions.
The material is certainly appreciated, but not at the expense of the regular
versions. While the live version of “Jesus Christ Pose” unequivocally
earns its keep, other substitutions don’t fare as well, being hampered
by poor recording quality (“Get on the Snake”), subpar performance (the
Saturday Night Live broadcast of “Pretty Noose”), or utter pointlessness
(why include the music video take of “Fell on Black Days” when the video
itself is included in the set?).
There’s so much exemplary material stuffed inside
the dodgy artwork that adorns Telephantasm (seriously, it looks
like something befitting a Creed album) that the overall picture that
emerges makes up for any smaller slights that can be found within. Here
is a compilation that moves from strength to strength, constantly ratcheting
up expectations and delivering on them. There are several points throughout
the set—be it “Beyond the Wheel” or “Rusty Cage” or “Birth Ritual” or
“Superunknown”—where it feels as if you have just heard the ultimate Soundgarden
song, and that the band couldn’t possibly produce anything that could
top what has come before. And then it does. Telephantasm is a profound
argument for Soundgarden’s mastery of writing heavy rock music, where
song structures are engagingly unconventional and every tune has at minimum
two classic riffs. Furthermore, Telephantasm is a potent reminder
that heavy music can be brutal yet intelligent, that music that’s dissonant
and gnarly can achieve mainstream acceptance, and that it’s been far,
far too long since most alternative/indie rock has rocked this hard so
well. Whatever the reformed Soundgarden is currently cooking up is ultimately
irrelevant, for Telephantasm is an astonishing document that effectively
summarizes the group’s past career and subsequently confirms its status
as a true legend in modern rock music.
From Michael Melchor of 411mania:
7.5/10
Reuniting with a greatest
hits set after previously releasing a greatest hits set? That takes some
guts.
For newer fans - or those that may have not have heard
a lot of the band until they got their copy of Telephantasm included with
the Guitar Hero: Warriors of Rock game, this is going to be real short
and sweet: consider Telephantasm your recommended Soundgarden 101 course.
If you like what you hear on the disc and the game - and if you like dirty,
no-nonsense rock and roll, it stands to reason theres no reason
you shouldnt - then proceed with picking up a copy of A-Sides and
enjoy your beginners course. After that, feel free to seek out the
2 CD/DVD edition for more before going through the catalog proper. Go
forth, discover, and have a nice day.
Now, for those left that
know and remember Soundgarden, any trepidation in picking up Telephantasm
can certainly be understood. After all, quite a few long-time fans of
Cornell, Thayil, Cameron, and Shapherd probably didnt need to pick
up A-Sides because they already had the best cuts from it. When the tracklisting
for Telephantasm was revealed, it seemed part-retread and part-letdown.
After all, A-Sides was the last release - in any form - from Soundgarden.
It is a pleasure to report, then, that Telephantasm
- in its expanded form, leastways - is much more than a retread of A-Sides.
Sure, much of the main tracks from the greatest hits set they released
last is still here, but theres quite a bit of bonus material that
wasnt there. The first four tracks alone - All Your Lies,
Hunted Down, Fopp, and Beyond The Wheel
- were all really early tracks that were absent from the A-Sides set.
The first one that was on it thats also on Telephantasm - Flower
- is on the new collection, but its a BBC Session recording.
The constant comparisons to A-Sides may be a little
infuriating. It even comes across that way as its being typed. Totally
understood. However, it seems necessary because its really difficult
to remember when the last time a band released a greatest hits
set as their final release, and then reunited with...a greatest
hits set. Its unclear whether or not Soundgarden is working
on newer material, and Cornell has made it pretty clear that the band
has no real designs on sticking to a schedule or going back to the usual
grind. Theyre set to do this on their own terms - admirable, but
frustrating for fans who would like to skip the nostalgia angle and get
straight to hearing the band get back to writing the sort of songs that
hammered their name in to music history in the first place.
Until such time, however, Telephantasm makes for a
good tie-over - even for a nostalgia package. The band went out of their
way to include some rarities, such as live versions of Get On The
Snake, Jesus Christ Pose, Pretty Noose,
and Blow Up The Outside World. One of these, however, may
have been a mistake; the reading of Pretty Noose from Saturday
Night Live is far from one of Cornells finer vocal moments.
In fact, it could be cited as the starting point for many noticing that
Cornells voice wasnt what it was back when Soundgarden was
at their bombastic peak.
For those desperate for new(ish) material, there is
one track here that hasnt been released in any form - Black
Rain. An unheard track from the Badmotorfinger sessions, the track
is very reminiscent of New Damage a song thats sorely
missed from Telephantasm, particularly the version featuring Queens
Brian May heard on the Alternative NRG collection. That being said, it
makes sense to leave off New Damage in favor of a similar-sounding
song thats never been heard before on a set such as this.
The 411: All in all, Telephantasm stands as a pretty
good introduction to Soundgarden (as included with the new Guitar Hero
game). The expanded edition, however, comes off as a condensed boxed-set.
Rarities, classics, live songs, warts and all...and with a cheaper price
tag. A pretty good deal, all in all, for fans of Soundgarden, Seattle
rock, and rock music as a whole.
From Scott Kara of the New
Zealand Herald: 4/5
In a world first, this Best Of compilation by reformed
Seattle arty grunge heavyweights Soundgarden initially came out with the
Guitar Hero: Warriors of Rock video game last week before its traditional
release on Monday. It takes in early songs like Beyond the Wheel
off grimey yet grand 1988 debut Ultra-Mega OK, through big songs Rusty
Cage and Black Hole Sun, and some alternate versions, including
a thundering and primitive live take of Jesus Christ Pose. While
some of the early songs are heavy going, and Dusty from last album
Down On the Upside is dodgy, with 24 tracks on two discs, a DVD of 20
videos, and a history booklet, fans can't go wrong.
From David Raposa of Pitchfork:
5/10
Unlike a fair number of their PacNW peers, Soundgarden
suffered through some growing pains. The problem wasn't so much that the
band was trying to find its own voice, but that Chris Cornell wasn't always
sure how to best utilize his. Cornell's apocalyptic shriek is the sort
of weapon of mass destruction that needs to be implemented with care and
precision. Letting it run free on the sludgy metal-punk of "All Your
Lies" or faking the funk on a cover of the Ohio Players' "Fopp"
were baby steps. And yet, getting to hear songs like these-- and, more
importantly, to hear the band hit its stride on "Hunted Down"
(from the Screaming Life EP) or "Beyond the Wheel" (from their
first full-length, Ultramega OK)-- alongside the alt-rock standards, is
a big part of the hook for Telephantasm.
This new career-spanning collection comes in a few
packages-- the woefully skint single-disc version that will be packaged
with copies of Guitar Hero: Warriors of Rock, the collector-baiting 2xCD/DVD/3xLP/book-and-pictures
version, and a 2xCD version that serves as a somewhat serviceable overview
of Soundgarden's career. For most people, the one to consider is the 2xCD
version, and if there's one thing it does better than its best-of predecessor
(1997's now-deleted A-Sides), it's acknowledging that the band released
a fair amount of music before signing with A&M Records.
The potential displayed in their early years, coupled
with the group's impeccable pedigree-- not many bands can say they released
records on both Sub Pop and SST-- made that major-label jump a foregone
conclusion. When Soundgarden did issue their A&M debut, 1989's Louder
Than Love, they were still trying to figure things out. A track like "Hands
All Over" has Cornell and friends striking the sort of po-faced martyrs'
pose they'd later mock mercilessly, while "Big Dumb Sex" (the
"I wanna fuck fuck fuck fuck you" song) seems to confuse being
a parody of overblown cock rock with being the real thing. Group those
two tracks with a half-decent live version of the half-decent "Get
on the Snake" (speaking of cock rock) and a sloppy pre-Badmotorfinger
take on "Room a Thousand Years Wide", and that's a third of
Telephantasm out of the way without much of note happening.
Thankfully, the Telephantasm compilers (mostly) get
out of their own way when picking what to include from 1991's Badmotorfinger--
they simply run with the album's first four tracks, and it's by far the
best stretch of music on Telephantasm's first disc. By now, Kim Thayil's
thick yet fluid guitar leads meet up with an equally heavy and flexible
rhythm section to create a menacing backdrop that's perfect for Cornell's
ungodly holler. Even better, Cornell's learned that the nuclear option
works just as well as an implied threat-- and that makes his shriek that
much more effective when it's let off the leash. On tracks like "Outshined"
and "Jesus Christ Pose", Soundgarden figured out how to balance
their messianic metallic tendencies with both a sizable helping of self-awareness
and a fondness for off-kilter time signatures. The addition of bassist
Ben Shepherd gave the group both a strong foundation and an off-kilter
songwriting voice to add to the mix.
Alas, Telephantasm aims to bait fans by including
a live version of "Jesus Christ Pose" instead of the album cut--
a pattern repeated too often on Disc Two, which (aside from the group's
contribution to the Singles soundtrack, "Birth Ritual") covers
Soundgarden's final two albums. 1994's Superunknown is, of course, the
record that transformed the group into alt-rock superstars, so of course
"Black Hole Sun" and "Spoonman" are here. Two of the
album's other singles, the surf-flavored "My Wave" and the fittingly
pessimistic "Fell on Black Days", are also in the mix, though
"Black Days" is represented by its lesser video-edit version.
Down on the Upside-- Superunknown's gentler and more unfocused sibling--
has both of its most notable singles ("Pretty Noose", "Blow
Up the Outside World") repped by live versions, the former represented
by its performance on "Saturday Night Live", a venue infamous
for making almost every musical performer that's graced its stage sound
like ass. Also here is the album version of "Burden in My Hand"
and "Dusty", an unremarkable album track that gave their final
record its title.
Finally, as with every career-spanning compilation
looking to make a buck, there's the rare or unreleased track: Where A-Sides
offered an import B-side ("Bleed Together"), Telephantasm unearths
a Badmotorfinger outtake, "Black Rain", which sounds exactly
like... a Badmotorfinger outtake.
Even if you're not specifically on one of the group's
many wavelengths, there's plenty to enjoy on Telephantasm-- fans whose
tastes lean towards heavier stuff might find something to like in the
Badmotorfinger tracks, while folks whose rock sensibilities are more melodic
can dip their toes in the Superunknown. That said, for one extra dollar,
curious iTunes shoppers can bypass the middle man and just buy copies
of Badmotorfinger and Superunknown-- those albums' deep cuts are much
better than most of the tunes on Telephantasm, and you'll get studio singles
rather than cut-rate bootlegs.
Telephantasm was an opportunity to redefine Soundgarden's
somewhat disparate career: to better illustrate the stylistic throughlines
that connect Screaming Life to Down on the Upside; to take cuts from their
neglected albums and place them in a more forgiving context; to breathe
new life into well-known singles. It's a trick the band itself managed
to turn with its first post-reunion gig. Performing as Nudedragons, the
group took the stage at the Showbox in Seattle this past April and played
a set that showed as much love to Louder Than Love and Ultramega OK as
any other album in their catalog, giving each portion of their career
equal respect without resorting to simply playing just the hits. Succeeding
at this sort of task is easier said than done, but it would've been nice
if Telephantasm at least tried.
From Stephen Thomas Erlewine of Allmusic.com:
4.5/5
Since so much of Soundgardens legacy lay in
the years before their superstardom, their major label-oriented 1997 A-Sides
compilation didnt quite do them justice. Although it contained cuts
from the years before they signed to A&M, A-Sides downplayed the first
act of their story, so the 2010 compilation Telephantasm is quite welcome,
at least in its double disc incarnation where theres enough room
to capture the entire arc of the groups career. Not only is there
a heavy dose of their SST and SubPop recordings but there is a strategic
deployment of live cuts, BBC sessions, single versions and rarities, including
the previously unreleased outtake Black Rain, all of which
capture the band at their heaviest, a shift thats particularly notable
toward the end of their career, with Pretty Noose and Blow
Up The Outside World present in rawer versions than their studio
incarnations. This may not satisfy a casual fan who wants to hear versions
played on the radio, but the entirety of Telephantasm winds up being something
better than a hits collection: it captures the essence of the band, why
they were important and why they still sound powerful some twenty years
later. [This deluxe set also includes a bonus DVD containing all of Soundgardens
music videos, including several alternate versions of familiar clips.]
From Chris Carle at IGN:
9/10
This jam-packed collection
offers all the hits, interesting alternate recordings and new music. What
more can Soundgarden fans ask for?
You know the winds of musical change have shifted
when a band's compilation CD is timed to the release of a new videogame.
That's exactly what has happened with Soundgarden's latest greatest hits
CD, Telephantasm. Released to coincide with Guitar Hero: Warriors of Rock,
Telephantasm also contains Soundgarden's newest cut "Black Rain"
(the single is also playable in-game).
"Black Rain" is the first Soundgarden track
in quite awhile and it fits comfortably in the pantheon of their music.
While it not be as vital or catchy as "Outshined," "Rusty
Cage" or "Fell on Black Days," it's a welcome gift to fans
who have missed the band.The rest of this set is a tour through the history
of Soundgarden's biggest hits, and a good sampling of music that casual
fans might not have explored. What stands out is how consistently amazing
the band has been through the years.
The early stuff is a little rough around the edges
(which is not necessarily a bad thing), but by Badmotorfinger, the band
was at the height of their powers. During the Nineties they were one of
the most impactful and hardest rocking bands around, and this collection
highlights the songs that led to their legacy. For the most part, it's
a sequential look at Soundgarden's essential catalog, beginning with selections
from 1988's Ultramega OK through Down on the Upside and concluding with
"Black Rain." With two discs' worth of music, there is ample
space to showcase the biggest and best, and everything from "Big
Dumb Sex" to "Spoonman" is included.
A majority of the tracks are recordings straight from
their discography, but there are some surprises as well. Instead of releasing
the album version of "Fell on Black Days," they opted for the
softer, more pensive video version. "Get On the Snake" and "Jesus
Christ Pose" offer live versions which are inferior to the disc recordings,
but give fans something different. There is also a BBC Session version
of "Flower" and the SNL performance of "Pretty Noose,"
both welcome additions.
It's likely that Soundgarden super fans will already
have a good deal of this music, with the exception of "Black Rain."
But this is the perfect compilation for casual fans who are looking to
round out their collection, or the nostalgic masses who knew and loved
Soundgarden during the grunge days. It stands as a testament to the band's
sustained awesomesness and is one of the better greatest hits offerings
of recent years.
From Steven Fanning at Subba-Cultcha:
9/10
Out of the Rusty Cage, Soundgarden
run...
The announcement last year that the Knights Of The Sound Table were to
ride again was met across the globe with universal excitement. In the
early nineties, when grunge ruled the airwaves, alongside Nirvana, Pearl
Jam, Screaming Trees and Alice In Chains, Soundgarden were one of the
biggest hitters to come out of the dominant Seattle scene, and in Badmotorfinger
and Superunknown recorded two of the periods defining albums, before
releasing the somewhat tepid Down On The Upside. Telephantasm is a career
retrospective, taking in the Soundgardens formative years right
through to their final work for A&M and consequent implosion.
Originally signing to Sub Pop in 1986, the bands
first two EPs were raw, skittish metal, notable for the heaviness
of Kim Thayils guitars and the screaming tunefulness of Chris Cornells
vocals. All Your Lies, Fopp and Hunted Down
all make the cut here, Hunted Down being currently notable
after its re-release on 7 vinyl for Record Shop Day. Ultramega OK,
Soundgardens first full album release, is generally overlooked in
their career, but the inclusion of Beyond The Wheel is fitting,
the session version of Flower maybe not so; its slow
and droning and is more a notional catalyst for what was to come rather
than a pivotal part in the story the space on the CD couldve
been better used.
From Hands All Over onwards we begin to
enter Soundgardens heyday. After signing a major label deal, the
Soundgarden we remember truly begin to take shape. Louder Than Love was
not, in its entirety, a great record, but it sketched out the Soundgarden
of the future through the quite sublime Hands All Over and
the beautifully raw, yet sadly overlooked for this collection, Gun.
A running theme throughout Telephantasm is the poor representation of
the band from their live recordings, and Get On The Snake
live here adds nothing that the original wouldnt have.
Then we come to Badmotorfinger and Soundgarden begin
to realise the promise their earlier work screamed of. Rusty Cage
and Outshined are flawless, and brilliant. Thayils guitar
work hints at the East yet delivers a sound that becomes so synonymous
and vital to its time in the West, its almost without compare, yet
without Cornells creativity and vocals, Camerons frenetic
drumming and Ben Shepherd, the final part in the Soundgarden jigsaw, completing
the set, we wouldnt be looking back on and lamenting a great band
that couldve been. Cornell alone has hardly set the world alight.
And so we come to Jesus Christ Pose. In
this one song, we hear the depths of despair augmented with deep, dark,
energising guitar and the simple notion of a perfectly crafted, vital
piece of grunge lore in the snappy, sharp vocals that Cornell lays down,
which unfortunately they never could capture live. Why they would choose
to use an unremarkable and hugely disappointing live recording of such
a crucial and pivotal part of the story on this retrospective is frankly
baffling. Beyond hawking this to the existing fanbase with something they
probably dont already own, the commercial aspect to Telephantasm
comes to the fore above that of really providing something for the fans.
And throughout Telephantasm this is a consistent complaint.
Superunknown was arguably their finest work, it was
the final breakthrough record and the purists will maybe argue that Black
Hole Sun and Fell On Black Days pandered more to the
MTV (as proved by the inclusion of the video version of FOBD)
world than the true fans Soundgarden had coveted throughout the years,
yet Superunknown will forever reign supreme as their most accomplished
work. The inclusion of the afore mentioned tracks alongside My Wave
and the title track Superunknown are all perfectly fine, but
there couldve been room for Limo Wreck or Kickstand
here to make it seem a little more considered.
As Superunknown gave way to Down On The Upside, Soundgarden
began to lose their way. They started to sound disconnected and ultimately
stagnant. Pretty Noose and Blow Up The Outside World
were never any more than simply passable, and the remainder of the album
nothing more than career filler. The subsequent split was no real surprise.
Telephantasm is an anthology of two parts; the sublime
and the not so. Soundgarden were, and are, a band of incredible reach
and talent, and their fans will always endure, and here the cynicism over
Telephantasm arises. This isnt something for the fans, its
something for the fans to buy. Theres nothing on here that you really
need apart from the previously unreleased, and quite brilliant, track
Black Rain, which captures the Badmotorfinger years perfectly.
It shows the band Soundgarden were, and are, quite succinctly, and stands
heads and shoulders above the latter era of their career together. To
truly experience Soundgarden, however, your money could be much better
spent simply buying Badmotorfinger and Superunknown, as these are two
almost perfect records. The less impressive junctures of their career
will always taint their greater achievements, but overall, you cant
really go wrong with this. On their day, there are fewer better bands,
and this is how theyll always be remembered. Soundgarden are an
undeniable 10/10 band, but the weaker, more cynical moments, of this comp
disappointingly cost them a point. Its great to have them back though,
heres hoping it sticks, there always was another great album in
them somewhere...
from Jack Foley at IndieLondon:
4/5
SOUNDGARDEN are one of the
great acts in American music history. Chris Cornell, Kim Thayil, Ben Shepherd
and Matt Cameron collectively redefined rock music for a whole generation
and had a revolutionary impact on the course of musical history. As
one of the first bands to release music on the venerated Sub Pop label,
and the first band to come out of the 90s Seattle music scene to
later sign to a major label, they have cemented a place in the record
books as one of the biggest rock acts of all time.
Their greatest hit, arguably, remains Black Hole Sun,
a seminal offering that actually marks a departure from their more trademark
sound
but also a highlight in a career that saw them emerge from
underground renegades to kings of the K-ROQ radio waves. Throughout their
history, whether preaching dirty sex or teen rebellion, they fitted into
scenes: whether surfing, grunge rock, the sound of the American summer
.
you name it. Its pretty safe to assume that whether you call yourself
a fan or not, one of their songs has touched you in some way, or been
part of your record collection.
Telephantasm is an all consuming career retrospective
that, in its own way, makes further history for the band. For, in addition
to releasing the LP in conventional formats (ie, record shops and download
sites), the band has also announced that they will be partnering with
innovative gaming publisher Activision Publishing, Inc. to release the
album simultaneously inside 1 million copies of the new videogame Guitar
Hero®: Warriors of Rock. Its a shrewd move that should guarantee
they reach out to a whole new army of fans.
For the purposes of this review, however, were
content to mull over their achievements thus far
and pick out the
best bits of what is, unquestionably, a great, multi-label spanning career
retrospective. Admittedly, the bands earliest stuff veers more towards
the Guns N Roses heavy rock sound than the Seattle scene that
would become their trademark. But even then, there were moments to savour,
with Fopp, Beyond The Wheel, Hands All Over and Big Dumb Sex standing
out on the first CD (of 2). A previously unreleased BBC Session version
of Flower also rates as a real buzz cut for Soundgarden fans coveting
something new to listen to, while a single version of Room A Thousand
Years Wide and a live rendition of Get On The Snake are two more picks
from the previously unheard material.
CD2 is where the band really come into their own,
however, with Black Hole Sun standing head and shoulders above them all
as the go to track for all-time classic status. Its as fresh, vibrant
and, yes, sing-along today as it was way back when
But My Wave is
a great surfing culture track, Spoonman reverberates with some absolutely
corking guitar riffs, the video version of Fell On Black Days a downbeat
grunge classic and Dusty a punchy mix of stop-start riffing and anthemic
choruses. Then come three moments to savour for the patient fans among
you: two previously unreleased live versions of Pretty Noose and Blow
Up The Outside World and a thrilling never-before-heard track, Black Rain,
which mixes thrilling, grunge guitar riffs with a set of vocals that really
scream with stadium filling fury.
If were being ultra honest, Soundgarden are
most definitely a band whose sound is rooted in American values and their
latter material far outshines their early work (circa Black Hole Sun onwards),
but this is still a great compilation package that does full justice to
the legacy of one of Americas greatest and most influential rock
acts. You gets your moneys worth!
From Petra Whiteley at Reflections
of Darkness:
SOUNDGARDEN was one of the
crucial bands on the Seattle grunge scene, at the same time it stood apart
from NIRVANA and PEARL JAM. Grunge as a genre itself is self-limiting,
one was bound to predict SOUNDGARDEN and ALICE IN CHAINS (AIC) as those
that can get on further and not strangle themselves in repetitiveness
as these two bands could straddle other styles, but in 1997 SOUNDGARDEN
called it a day due to internal conflicts and pressure whilst AIC due
to inactivity caused by drug addictions and death of their vocalist. Cornell
went off to play with AUDIOSLAVE, which he formed with members from RAGE
AGAINST THE MACHINE (RATM, minus Zack de la Rocha), whilst the other members
collaborated with various bands and fellow musicians such as DEAD KENNEDYS
singer Jello Biafra, Tonny Iommi, Dave Grohls side project, SMASHING
PUMKINS and PEARL JAM. ALICE IN CHAINS started again in 2006 and finally
in January this year SOUNDGARDEN reunited after 12 years too. Their comeback
album is Telephantasm, a retrospective spanning over 13 years
of their career; it includes their best as well as rare songs and also
one new track Black Rain. It comes out as 1-CD edition and
Double CD deluxe edition; this is the review of the later.
CD 1 is a trip through their earliest songs, when
they forged their sound from BLACK SABBATH and LED ZEPPELIN to BAUHAUS;
building their bridge between metal, hard rock and grunge, with their
trademark divergent time signatures and alternative tunings underlined
with Cornells wide ranging vocals. DOORS and JIMI HENDRIX also come
to mind when considering their starting directions and sounds. It is interesting
to note that whilst Big Dumb Sex with its repetition of Im
gonna fuck you presented a controversy to the moralising establishment
when it was released in 1989 whilst today it wouldnt ruffle hardly
as many feathers - not because moralising has died off but only moved
on elsewhere. Also it might be that the establishment collected some brain
cells and realised it was a parody of glam rocks pussy footing around
lyrically and obsessing on the subject of sex all the same. Rusty
Cage has a hard HENDRIX guitar sound, a bridge between metal and
grunge; it was also covered by JOHNNY CASH. Outshined is one
of their more typically grungy ones, one of their greatest songs. This
CD shows a wider diversity of sound and from that point of view makes
it as a better one of the two.
Second CD is a showcase of Cornells darker,
existentialist lyrics, the psychedelic tone is here still, although more
lucid, on the other hand the songs are more homogenous in overall sound.
Jesus Christ Pose reminds one of RATM, the sound quality of
the live song is poor, maybe it was untouched to give the listener feel
of those times. Its not a good idea - if one wants to revive memories,
one will go to the concert, on the CD itd have been better engineered.
Brave inclusion on the other hand considering it was perceived as anti-Christian,
it enraged some so much that the band started receiving death threats
at the time. Black Hole Sun - melodic, superb lyrics, although
grungy it transcends it. Finally, the new track closes the collection,
Black Rain - SOUNDGARDEN moves on in with progressive metal;
Cornells time playing with RATMs members also shows a mark
here regarding the guitar sound.
Some of their most loved songs are not at either edition
(single or double CD) - such as for example: Nothing To Say
on neither and The Day I Tried to Live on the Single CD-Version
though youll find that uncensored on the DVD, which would one lead
to think its not just best of, but also a bait to go back to the
catalogue. After all, the 1-CD edition is being released together with
new Guitar Hero game to spool even more listeners, be their new or roll
call for the old ones. Punk's not dead it just deserves to die when
it becomes another stale cartoon (DEAD KENNEDYS Chickenshit
Conformist, Bedtime for Democracy LP) - to me it doesnt only
apply to punk, but all the other music trends, so much of grunge came
to this so is SOUNDGARDEN an exception? If they keep on expanding their
sound, keep exploring the other music paths as they did, but more so -
yes.
Although the new song Black Rain
was not as promising as Cornells performance with James Bonds
Casino Royale theme song, You Know My Name, even with the
limitations of the films production it was a better song, so Im
still not absolutely sure whether SOUNDGARDEN can create a refreshing
new music and resurrect their career successfully, on the other hand I
think that they are more than capable of it. As a compilation Telephantasm
gives a good, comprehensive overview and is essential in order to see
the musical paths theyve followed through their founding to their
disbanding in late nineties.
From Steven Hurst at Glasswerk:
The reformation of one of the best grunge bands last
sees a continuing trend for bands of yesteryear getting back together
for live shows and the prospect of new material. Faith no More have been
touring to great acclaim, and now Soundgarden are back too.
Grunge fans rate these bands in varying order. True
grunge fans seem to agree that Nirvana is still the most over hyped of
the bunch that had the greatest success whilst the likes of Perl Jam had
the staying power to keep their music strong. Other bands have taken time
out including the likes of Alice in Chains and Soundgarden. Most if not
all bands have been plagued with stories of drugs and in some cases death.
What keeps us coming back is the quality of the music.
And it is in this release that we get to look back
on Soundgardens output with this mix of singles and rare track releases
along with a new single in the form of Black Rain.
Looking at the disc of familiar material we get some
live recordings of Jesus Christ pose, Pretty Noose and Blow Up the Outside
World. Its nice to chart how quickly and confidently Chris Cornells
voice has matured. Its no wonder he sought to do other things with
his voice. Yes not all of these have been successful but they are worthwhile
ventures for a voice that needs no restraint.
But of course Soundgarden are three other guys as
well and together they are arguably the better of the grunge bands. Quite
simply cause they never offered up an album that sucked. Their last effort
"Down On The Upside" brought us some tremendous singles. Perhaps
the album was jam-packed full of some other filler material, but overall
it was still a worthy effort. But the argument to this day seems to be
whether the greatest effort by them was their early effort "Badmotorfinger"
or the largely commercial hit "Superunknown". Personally I dont
think they got better than the latter as it is an album that can demand
hard work. It took me a while before I fully appreciated everything about
it so it was almost like hard work paying off in a big bad way.
Take note: this is not the same as being forced to listen to something
until you start to like it its more a case of discovering
new things each time you listen and uncovering layers. The earlier album
though has more purity to it and sees them walking the fine line between
the rough beginnings and the refined popularity.
Get back to Telephantasm: I dont know if this
release is a marketing ploy to see if there is still interest in the band.
Which considering that all these other bands from the same era are doing
so well wouldnt make much sense. But its a long two disc trawl
through the very early material on the first disc where you can see the
genius roots of the band that could literally have taken off in a very
different direction. There are hints of the psychedelic, a large portion
of punk with a lot less restraint as raw early records tend to have.
But by the time we are going through the still phenomenally
great Superunknown, Spoonman, Burden In My Hand we are ready for something
new. A live rendition of Blow Up the Outside World demonstrates Cornells
power as a live performer, but then halfway through something goes terribly
wrong and the disc refuses to play anymore! This is highly irritating
as its a great song and we have yet to hear the last track on the
album, the new song! Black Rain. But it is not to be on this occasion
as after the disc is popped there is the discovery of two white round
grazes on the disc which is clearly the problem! So it is not to be this
time round, left to ponder what might have been, but still happy that
one of the better rock acts that ever was is back with the possibility
of a future.
Its been a busy couple of years, but now that
we have Soundgarden, Faith No More, Stone Temple Pilots, Guns n
Roses and Alice In Chains back, Perhaps they can reflect on why they felt
the need to go in the first place.
From Mike Diver at the BBC:
Superb 24-track best-of from the reformed Seattle
hard-rockers
With the Knights of the Soundtable
riding once more after 13 years apart, the time is right for an in-depth
retrospective of one of the grunge eras best-loved bands. Soundgarden,
Seattle natives at the epicentre of the early 1990s plaid-and-flannel
rock scene, already have one best-of to their name, 1997s A-Sides.
But Telephantasm goes further, spreading itself across 24 tracks and two
discs, including excellent live performances alongside commercially released
singles.
Favourites from these two-dozen numbers are sure to
be selected according to listener age. As someone (just) in their early
30s, the Badmotorfinger and Superunknown cuts are instant reminders of
my early explorations into what most parents would, at the time, have
considered an unlistenable racket. These two long-players the bands
third and fourth, from 1991 and 1994 respectively are widely acknowledged
to be the bands best collections, and with good reason: plot a graph
of their MTV-assisted mainstream fortunes and itll peak between
the pair, primarily due to the plethora of brilliant singles from the
period. From Badmotorfinger, Outshined and Rusty Cage enjoyed minor success
in the UK; from Superunknown, Black Hole Sun reached number 12 in the
UK and topped the chart in the US, while Spoonman and Fell on Black Days
were also stateside top ten hits.
This can be seen as something of a surprise, as while
association with the scene that spawned the globe-conquering Nirvana didnt
harm Soundgardens chances of breaking through, their sound owed
much more to Led Zeppelin and Black Sabbath battleship-sized basslines,
belt-it-out vocals than it did the scrappy punk outfits that appealed
to Cobain and company. Soundgarden were old back when they were new, meaning
that much of Telephantasm doesnt sound horribly dated. Its raw charms
may have aged, but theyre sharper than same-era cuts from fellow
Seattleites Pearl Jam and Alice in Chains.
The earliest songs here, from 1988 debut Ultramega
OK (Flower, Beyond the Wheel) and the following years Louder Than
Love (Big Dumb Sex, Hands All Over), lack the production punch of later
fare. But the songwriting craft exhibited by frontman Chris Cornell and
ex-bassist Hiro Yamamoto (replaced by Ben Shepherd in 1990) is already
showing plenty of promise. Cornell would follow Soundgardens final
LP, 1996s thoroughly decent Down on the Upside (Burden in My Hand,
Pretty Noose), with a string of less-appealing projects which culminated
in a truly awful third solo LP, 2009s Scream. But his various lows
can be forgiven by just a single listen to this compilations numerous
nose-bleeding highs, closed out by a previously unreleased and suitably
low-end-centric treat, Black Rain, from the Badmotorfinger sessions.
From Zorro of Sonic
Shocks: 9/10
Let me first start by saying
how much I love Soundgarden. Chris Cornell has been one of my favourite
vocalists from the period and knowing that he can still cut it makes me
genuinely excited to be listening to the new release by Soundgarden. Scanning
down the track listing, I see a couple of new entries to the mix, alongside
classic songs which the guys are famed for. Beginning with All your
lies, you are given a chance to rekindle your love for the band;
where Cornell screams with intent and musical content is on point - combining
high pitched, quirky screams and deep riffs. I always enjoyed Hunted
Down from the Screaming Life EP and I loved the dirty, grungy and
gritty underpinning that runs throughout. Its really cool that Soundgarden
have opted to include tracks which many people may not have heard before
(especially if they only purchased Superunknown). What this collection
of songs has given me the opportunity to do is hear songs which I may
previously have scanned over whilst listening to full length albums; such
as Hands all over which Ive always like, but never gone
out of my way to play over some of the other classics. But, as suggested,
with Telephantasm, you can just let the album run, safe in the knowledge
that every track is a winner.
Hearing the previously unreleased Room a thousand
years wide makes you question how groups choose which of their plethora
of work to let loose on the public. Needless to say, that was a great
track and justifies its airing on this album. Rolling immediately into
Rusty Cage, the Telephantasm steps up a gear into a new dimension.
Damn, I love Soundgarden. One thing I MUST do is see them live
its something I have always wanted to, but never had the opportunity.
Jesus Chris Pose LIVE YES sir! Sounds phenononononononmenal!
100% solid gold. In fact, it was at this point that I went upstairs and
rooted out all my Soundgarden vinyl and filled my stop gap with a heavy
vinyl session. Which incidentally sounds ever better with age.
My Wave, Spoonman, Black Hole Sun, Fell on Black days....
need I say more? This album is a total MUST HAVE for any music fan. If
you are ever slightly inclined to enjoy this style of music, then you
should definitely treat yourself to this album.
From Catherine Yates of Classic Rock: 7/10
With the proliferation of illegal downloading pushing
the recording industry towards an ever more uncertain future, so the once
straightforward notion of album distribution has seen some creative variations
of late: Slash, for example, sexed up te release of his solo album earlier
this year by packaging it with a special edition of this very magazine.
But what if it's not new material you're selling?
Considering most Soundgarden fans will be more excited
about the recent reunion shows in April this year than in a collection
of tracks they already own (either in album form or on 1997's "A
Sises" best-of) the band have come up with a novel solution: the
Seattle quartet are 'bundling' new career retrospective Telephantasm
with the new Guitar Hero instalment, as an audio CD and also
as downloadable content for the game itself. Which is some cunning marketing:
long-time lovers of their alchemical reshaping of the Sabbath/Zeppelin
back cats (that clawed at the heavens whuile Nirvana stayed in the everyday)
get to try (and retry) their hand at the teeth-rattling metal judder of
'Outshined' or the doomed might of 'Black Hole Sun'; the younger, unitiated
can get acquainted thriough repeat exposure, no doubt eventualy concluding
that seismic enviro-anthem 'Hands All Over' hasthe best bass line known
to man.
For videogame haters and diehard collectors, there's
an expanded two-disc and two-DVD special, and also an ultra-mega deluxe
edition that throws three LPs and a bunch of collectables into the mix.
Each version also contains 'Black Rain', an unl;reeased terack from the
1991 Badmotorfinger sessions - fine by Soundgarden standards, but you
wish there was something on this compilation that pointed to where the
band might yet go as well as to where they've been.
Still, if it encourages back-catalogue research into
all things Soundgarden via iPod, stereo or games console, then Telephantasm
has done its ob. Listen to the elementtal sludge might of 'Slaves and
Bulldozers' (included in the two-disc version) and then try to forgive
Chris Cornell for Scream. Shudder.
[Webmaster: the gibe at Scream is odd considering
the same magazine gave it 8/10 on release...hmm, maybe simply listening
to it wasn't good enough and they needed to be re-educated by other critics
as to the error of their ways..?]
From Austin Tasseltine of The
Skinny: 3/5
Serving as something of a commercial first, this career
retrospective from Seattle's ageing quartet will be bundled with the next
Guitar Hero games package. With Soundgarden steadily acquiring one of
the most heinously un-cool reputations in rock - thanks largely to Chris
Cornell's narcissistic solo efforts and the clunky, dunderheided Zeppelinery
of Audioslave - presumably the hope is that some vitality might return
to their recently-risen corpse.
Whilst the multi-disc, limited edition version of
the set contains a number of worthy rarities, this single disc boasts
a nicely remastered version of their debut Sub Pop single and a powerful
unreleased Badmotorfinger outtake (Black Rain) yet is rendered otherwise
peripheral by 1997's more comprehensive A-Sides.
Though comprised of some fundamentally great songs,
Telephantasm inexplicably omits bona fide classics like The Day I Tried
To Live. Combined with the fact that there is no better introduction to
Soundgarden than their insurmountably impressive 1994 opus Superunknown,
the exercise feels a little redundant.
From Kevin Zimmerman of Gather.com:
"Guitar Heaven generally suffers from a serious
case of over-production, with layers of percussion and rhythm guitar cluttering
up the soundscape when all the listener really wants to hear is the combination
of Santanas leads and the guest vocalist on each tune. Thus the
opening salvo of Zeppelins Whole Lotta Love, despite
a rip-roaring vocal by Soundgardens Chris Cornell, fails to achieve
the awe-inspiring heights its clearly aiming for; its not
dull, exactly, but its not appreciably better than what your average
bar band could deliver."
From Jed Gottlieb of the Boston
Herald:
"OK, this release - the guitarists first
since 2005 - of 12 covers with 12 different guest singers has a few interesting
moments. Chris Cornells return to Rusty Cage-shape on
Led Zeppelins Whole Lotta Love ahead of the Soundgarden
reunion will get grunge fans psyched; discovering AC/DCs Back
in Black is perfect for hip-hop posturing is cool (thanks Nas).
Nearly every other song is a letdown or an epic failure....download Whole
Lotta Love, but dont get too hopeful."
From Chris Steffen of Rolling
Stone:
"Two big highlights: Surprisingly heavy renditions
of AC/DCs Back in Black, featuring Nas and Janelle Monáe,
and Led Zeppelins Whole Lotta Love, punctuated by Chris
Cornell screaming his head off. "
From Melinda Newman of Hitfix:
"Hands down, our favorite (and, remember, this
is based on one listen through club speakers) was Santanas hard-churning
take on Led Zeppelins Whole Lotta Love, with Soundgardens
Chris Cornell on vocals. Cornell is one of the few artists who can take
on Robert Plants pliant pipes and Benson did a great job producing
him here."
From Darryl Sterdan of Canoe
- Jam!
"Davis plays eight cuts from Guitar Heaven --
including covers of Zep's Whole Lotta Love (sung by Chris Cornell), AC/DC's
Back in Black (featuring rapper Nas), and Van Halen's Dance the Night
Away (co-starring Train's Pat Monahan). While the tracks are generally
faithful to the originals, most are revamped with Santana's usual Latin
grooves and heavy percussion -- plus his distinctive solos, of course."
From Raquel Penzo of XI
Magazine
"This review would not be worth its salt without
mentioning that Chris Cornell and his sexy blue eyes turned Led Zeppelins
Whole Lotta Love into his own song. He was the absolute perfect
choice for this cover. His voice
I have no words
"
Press reviews of the song "Promise" (co-written
and sung by Chris Cornell) from Slash's solo album:
Chris was great. "Promise"
was probably the most unorthodox piece of music that Id written,
it was very different. It was one of those things, I dont know why
I thought of him for that song more than any of the others, but I sent
it to him and within 48 hours he sent me this great lyric and we were
off and running. it was as simple as that. Everybody seems to like this
one. - Slash, MusicRadar.com
interview 2010
"It's a song that you
would write to either a young friend or one of your children, giving them
advice of "don't let the world get you down because it's going to
try." It's the nature of youth to have a rosy outlook and feel like
you're going to be able to charge through life with a machete and make
your own way. But the reality is that a lot of unexpected things are going
to crash on you, and the song deals with that." - Chris Cornell,
Classic Rock interview 2010

From Wayne Madden of Daily
Music Guide:
"The strongest material on this album comes from
the established vocalists, such as Chris Cornell's powerful 'Promise'
and Kid Rock's 'I Hold On'."
From Michael Dickinson of Clink
Music Magazine:
"Promise (featuring. Chris Cornell): Slashs
little flourishes are also starting to come together nicely, driving the
song rather than interrupting them. The track has a good epic feel to
it. Cornells voice seems to get smokier and heavier as he gets older
(hopefully at some point he will sound like Al Pacino) but by gum can
he hit those notes."
From J.P. Stroman of the Cavalier
Daily:
"As an Alter Bridge fanatic, I thought I would
be most impressed with the songs that feature Myles Kennedy, but I actually
liked Promise the best, which features former Soundgarden
and Audioslave frontman Chris Cornell. The main riff is somewhat atypical
for most of Slashs material but still works very well. It has a
groovy feel, and Cornells vocal line fits the guitar part perfectly.
The song should please fans of Cornell that were upset by his foray into
the pop world with his album Scream."
From Nick Freed of Consequence
Of Sound:
Chris Cornells vocals on Promise
and Ian Astburys on Ghost are also some of the highlights
of the album along with Stockdale and Delucas... Cornells
performance on Promise is solid, and the song itself is a
pretty good rock song. I think if Cornell were to tour as vocalist for
this album rather than Alter Bridges Myles Kennedy (who is the only
one to sing on two songs on the album: Back From Cali and
Starlight), it would be a far better project.
From Jim Farber of the New
York Daily News:
"...Chris Cornell's erotic snarl pairs so well
with the star's chunky riffs in "Promise," it suggests he might
have started a worthy group with Slash had he not already agreed to reform
his classic band, Soundgarden, this summer."
From Paul Colgan of The
Punch:
"You get to the fifth track, Promise, featuring
Chris Cornell from Soundgarden. By now youve basically heard a GnR
song, a Black Sabbath-esque tune, a bit of pop-funk rock, and a grungy
number in Back from Cali with Myles Kennedy.
And with Promise you get something that sounds like
Soundgarden after everyone has had a nice cup of tea and is singing a
song in front of a mates mother. It could be, say, the Manic Street
Preachers or Franz Ferdinand. This is a potential frat-house anthem, with
its chorus line: Promise me you wont let them put out your
fire.
None of which is to say its a poor song. Hands-down,
its one of the best tunes on there its shamelessly
written for the masses and I enthusiastically endorse the shameless affront
to rock purists who roll their eyes at the hint of a foot-tapping, jangling
guitar line."
From Greg Victor of ParcBench:
Promise Chris Cornell (of Soundgarden
and Audioslave fame) captures the press-the-repeat-button
award for his contribution to this song. Starting out like a song that
Lou Reed forgot to write, it explodes into an infectious rock march that
has just enough grunge to keep it interesting."
From Dustin Schoof of LeHigh
Valley Live:
"The song "Promise" is more Marvin
Gaye than grunge. Chris Cornell's smoky vocals float along a bluesy, rustic
melody that harks back to Cornell's 2007 solo album, "Carry On."
From Sergio Pereira of Music
Review:
"...the decisive moment of the album has to be
Promise, which features a heart-warming collaboration with
Chris Cornell. Cornell belts his trademark passion-spiked octaves over
Slashs melancholic axe-work, as tears soak my eyes like a pregnant
woman in a size 0 clothing store. Now why cant Chris do this sort
of stuff instead of that dreadful last solo album, Scream, with Timbaland?"
From Aaron Titan of 411mania:
"The Chris Cornell and Adam Levine tracks, Promise
and Gotten respectively, while cool and interesting collaborations
in theory, just dont work and end up sounding like anything else
on rock radio, which is where this album will undoubtedly find some decent
success."
From Brian Glass of Working
Author:
"...Singer/songwriter Chris Cornell from Audioslave
and Soundgarden lends his distinctive voice to one of the albums
standout tracks. Set against a rhythmical, syncopated beat, Cornell sings
with a restraint missing from much of his other work. The result is an
understated, powerful performance and one of the catchiest songs on the
album."
From Rocket of The
Metal Den:
"...Its worth mentioning track fives
Promise. This gem finds SOUNDGARDEN great Chris Cornell cranking
out one of the truly great rock vocal performances in modern history."
From John of Addictive
Thoughts:
"...The albums peak might be the resurrection
of Chris Cornell, grunges fallen rock god (thanks, Timbaland), who
seems to have finally embraced the laidback, soulful vibe he teased us
with a decade ago on Euphoria Morning. His Promise, a song
ostensibly written from the perspective of a father to his child, has
a great chorus and a wonderful performance by the singer that makes one
wonder what a collaboration between these two men in their prime might
have sounded like."
From Allison Stewart of the Washington
Post:
"... Cornell's role as frontman of the hair-metal-killing
grunge behemoths Soundgarden would have made this sludgy semi-ballad/superpower
summit unthinkable a decade ago. Otherwise, it's amiable but unremarkable."
[oops, even the Washington Post can't get the staff. Um, Allison, a
decade ago he was touring solo album Euphoria Morning - webmaster]
From Tim Grierson of About.com:
"...Interestingly, Chris Cornell is one of the
spotlighted vocalists, and in a way Slash is much like Cornells
2009 collaboration with hip-hop producer Timbaland, Scream, in that it
transplants a known rock commodity into the mainstream pop world."
From Chris DeLine of Culture
Bully:
"...Oddly enough, at times [Myles] Kennedy ends
up sounding more like Chris Cornell than Cornell himself, who follows
with the jagged Promise.
From Jeff Miers of The
Buffalo News:
"Most of this plays out exactly like youd
figure it wouldSlash summons his finest GnR/Aerosmith
riffs, some of hard rocks greatest singers do their thing, the man
solos with real fire on his trusty Les Paul, and all is right in the universe
for a while....Cornell takes the cake with his contribution, though. He
remains one of the greatest hard rock singers to ever grab ahold of a
microphone. This comes across as far more cohesive than one mightve
supposed it would. Slash seems to be right where he belongs, at long last.
Nice."
From Talia Soghomonian of MusicOMH:
"...Promise generates more interest as
it features Chris Cornell, one of the greatest voices in rock. This melancholic
rock ballad is one of a couple on the album..."
from two French freelances who attended an advance
listening party:
Promise (avec Chris Cornell) 4'41
Ca commence par un arpège saturé bien mélodique.
C'est beau, c'est riche et ça sonne mais ce n'est pas vraiment
dans le style qu'on connait de Slash. Chris Cornell est tellement fidèle
à lui-même qu'on ne peut s'empêcher de se demander
si ce morceau n'aurait pas pu figurer sur un album de Soundgarden. Le
solo est très bien senti et les textures réellement riches.
Malgré tous ces éléments, la mayonnaise ne prend
pas vraiment à la première écoute. On s'ennuie presque
tellement Slash est finalement effacé.
Promise (Chris Cornell)
Une intro calme, un solo harmonisé en guitares, une ambiance pop
rock, une voix juste sublime, nous sommes bien dans l'univers de Chris
Cornell en solo....un super boulot sur les voix, toujours de petits riffs
sympa de Slash qui fera le plus grand plaisir aux guitaristes notamment
cette façon d'imiter une harpe par moments; un solo bluesy, un
pont "poppy" pour une chanson qui ressemble fortement un à
titre solo de Chris Cornell. Un titre parfait pour les radios US.
Petite déception, c'est trop calme !
Pro reviews of Chris Cornell's Scream ...

From Scotland's Glasgow
Sunday Post:
Having made a name for himself as a grunge/rock star
with the likes of Soundgarden, this album has shocked a lot of Chris's
diehard fans because it's a joint venture with top R&B producer Timbaland
and sees him combining great rock vocals with a mixture of rock and R&B
arrangements.
Conceived as a continuous piece with each track blending
into the nest, it's quite simply superb. Occasionally reminiscent of Gnarls
Barkely, with stunning songs such as these this is one of the best albums
you'll hear all year.
From the UK's Hull
Daily Mail:
Chris Cornell: Scream
This is the singer's third solo outing and it's a
brave one. The grunge god has teamed up with top R&B producer Timbaland.
True, this is not hardcore rock, but what you do get really grows on you.
Best tracks are the Eastern-inspired Take Me Alive and Enemy.
From the UK's Classic
Rock [April 2009, p.86]:
8/10
Chris Cornell: Scream (Polydor)
Cornell gets his groove on in collaboration with
the king of R&B knob-twiddling
The singer who broke up Soundgarden when they were
a bigger commercial proposition than they'd ever been, and then turned
his back on Audioslave before they'd even had the chance to tour their
final hurrah, 2006's Revelations, has once again pulled himself
out of his comfort zone and then some.
For this third solo album (following 1999's elegiac
and criminally underrated Euphoria Morning and 2007's disappointing
Carry On), Cornell has aligned himself to a producer as much a
renegade and figure of notoriety in the hip-hop and pop worlds as Cornell
is in his. Timbaland's numerous credits include Justin Timberlake, Madonna
and Bjork, though his being considered a visionary among his contemporaries
doesn't automatically make him a safe bet for an artist like Cornell:
a man still revered in some circles as the cleverest and most consistent
of grunge's plaid-draped pioneers. Cornell has referred to this album
as the highlight of his career while the while the equally upbeat Timbaland
thinks that it'll make Cornell "the first rock star in the club".
So, over the the hubbub of mutual backslaps, just what is the sound that
a Seattle archetype and a man who used to DJ under the name Tiny Tim combine
to make?
Timbaland's sublime bells and whistles (not literally,
it doesn't sound like Cornell's taken the train) are apparent from the
off. "Climbing Up the Walls" might depict lives in crumbling
disarray - familiar turf for the former Soundgarden singer - but Timbaland's
bubbling, electro rumblings might make an unsuspecting listener flinch
like a startled meerkat spooked by the shadow of a bird. Persist and you'll
find Cornell in towering form: his voice after years spent growling and
screaming at Soundgarden's behest is now finely tuned. Warm, although
never quite fuzzy, it bristles even as he croons. Loops and beats run
through the undercurrent of pretty much every song and the pace is more
sedate than anything he did with either of his former bands, but there
are moments of reflection: the tingle-inducing "Long Gone" and
the brilliantly haunting "Take Me Alive" could both have found
a home on the Temple Of The Dog album, if it had been an electronica
record. His ire's evident on the vitriolic yet effervescent-sounding "Part
Of Me", while the driving "Other Side Of Town" dabbles
in his drink and drug past. Cornell's on a new path now, and you'd be
a fool not to follow him. - Philip Wilding
From Germany's Alternative
Nation: 8/10
Chris Cornell
Scream
Keine Frage, dieses Album ist ein Politikum. Jeder
Musikliebhaber, der hier Stellungnahme bezieht, positioniert sich zwangsläufig
zwischen verhärteten Fronten. Geniestreich oder Selbstdemontage? Verrat
oder Neuerfindung? Fakt ist, dass sich seit der Mitte des neuen Jahrzehnts
ein infektiöser Elektrohype-Virus konsequent in der Rock/Alternative
Szene ausbreitet. Die avantgardistische Bewegung war anfänglich noch
ein spannendes Spielfeld für Bands wie die Infadels
(auch wenn diese sicher nicht die Vorläufer des Genres waren), die ihre
treibenden Beats elektronisch unterfütterten und somit eine neue massentaugliche
Spielform etablierten. Die Grenzen verschwammen. Wie es dann meistens
passiert, schwappte die Welle in den Mainstream über und flutet jetzt
unseren Musikmarkt. Die Klang gewordene Pervertierung in Liedform Allein,
Allein sowie die gesamte darauf zurückzuführende Band müssen wir
jetzt ebenso ausbaden wie Auswüchse à la Human, etc.
Und jetzt kommt Scream. Chris Cornells
Album ist der Schlusspunkt in Form eines dicken Ausrufezeichens. Eine
Antwort auf alle offenen Fragen und der letzte große Knall. Es greift
noch mal alles auf was einst möglich schien und perfektioniert es. Nach
Scream wird sich die Indieszene ein neues Spielfeld suchen
müssen. Elektro - heute vollendet im Pop, morgen tot. Sicherlich, von
Elektro an sich zu sprechen wird dem Album nicht gerecht. Und ganz klar,
der Sound aus Timbalands großer Beatwiederverwertungsschale
ist auch nicht immer so ganz exklusiv. Dennoch war es eine nicht zu
unterschätzende Milleniumsleistung von dem großen Produzenten, die Popmusik
mit ihrem natürlichen Umfeld zu fusionieren und sie somit Zukunftstauglich
zu machen. RnB, Hip Hop und jetzt sogar Rock werden unter einen Beat
gepresst und gnadenlos annektiert. Nur dem Rock, dem tut's langfristig
nicht gut. Das Cornell auf seinem Cover gerade eine
Gitarre zerschlägt ist dabei genauso bezeichnend wie Justin
Timberlake der eine Discokugel zertritt. Die Marschrichtung
ist völlig klar: raus aus den Genregrenzen. Die tradierten Hörgewohnheiten
in Frage stellen und neu überdenken. Das klingt jetzt allerdings revolutionärer
als es ist. Denn es wird nicht lange dauern bis sich der Rock wieder
auf die Gitarre besinnt. Wie eingangs erwähnt ist nach Scream
nicht mehr viel möglich.
Das Album ist eine klare Ansage, ein einheitlicher
Guss. Mögen vereinzelte Rezensenten schimpfen wie sie wollen, handwerklich
ist es ein Geniestreich. Der Titeltrack greift sofort, pointiert gleitet
der Beat in ein atmosphärisches Arrangement. Ab und an werden zwar schon
mal Gitarrenarrangements zu Riffsamples degradiert, aber was solls?
Auch wenn der Opener Part Of Me mit seinen schwachen Lyrics
etwas altbacken herkommt, spätestens bei Time verdichtet sich
das Album zu einer atmosphärisch brillianten Gesamtkomposition. Zu Höchstform
läuft das Album bei beatbetonten Clubreissern wie Enemy an.
Scream lässt keine Fragen mehr offen. Dieses Album ist purer
Sex. Es ist Bewegung und ganz großer Moment. Scream ist der
große, laute Knall, der die Musiklandschaft vor neue Herausforderungen
stellen wird. Scream ist die logische musikalische Konsequenz
eines Mannes der sich nicht mehr zu rechtfertigen braucht. Scream
bleibt eine Zäsur, die den treibenden Beat eines neuen Jahrzehntes vorgeben
wird. - Dennis Sand
From US publication Bullzeye:
4/5
See the guitar that Chris Cornell is wielding on the
front of his new album? If you flip over to the back cover, you’ll see
that the guitar has been destroyed. This is probably intended to represent
his decision to leave hard rock behind in favor of a new Timbaland-produced
sound. It’s just as possible, however, that the instrument was damaged
as Cornell tried to protect himself from the angry hordes of Soundgarden
and Audioslave fans who were trying to beat the living shit out of him.
Scream is the sort of musical reinvention that causes
an artist’s fans’ jaws to drop to record depths, only rising again in
order to allow them to start screaming, "Sellout!" But it’s an epithet
that emerges only because they can’t rationalize any other excuse for
their hero to have changed their sound so dramatically. In truth, very
few chart conquerors have begun their to-do lists by writing, "Step #1:
Alienate all existing fans of my previous work." As such, your best bet
is to approach the record with the presumption that Cornell just said,
"Fuck it, it’s time for a fresh start."
It’s no wonder that many critics are shredding the
record to within an inch of its life, however, since one can scarcely
imagine a listener already familiar with Cornell who would put on Scream
and, with a single spin, say, "Okay, you’ve sold me." Hearing his voice
within such a different musical context definitely takes some getting
used to. In the album opener, "Part of Me," he sounds as though he’s putting
in a bid to be declared the Justin Timberlake of the grunge generation;
it’s such an absurd concept that you may actually burst into laughter
when you hear him sing, "She was so friendly / I had one too many / And
I let her tempt me / She was rubbing up against me."
But damned if the music doesn’t sound great. Of the
emphasis tracks, the title song has a dark sparkle to it, "Ground Zero"
manages to be bluesy and danceable at the same time, and "Long Gone" has
some surprisingly soulful moments. There are some phenomenal choruses
here, too, including "Never Far Away" and "Enemy," both of which would
readily fill most dance floors with little remixing required. Timbaland’s
production isn’t always as successful as the resulting sales of the albums
bearing his credit would have you believe, but in this case, he’s very
much at the top of his game, helping Cornell completely reinvent himself
and sound great doing it. (Still, you do have to wonder if there’s a single
moment on the record that hasn’t been tweaked in some fashion; it might
not be sterile, but it certainly isn’t what you’d call organic, either.)
If you manage to survive the Scream experience all
the way to the bitter end but still remain a nonbeliever, have faith:
although the last listed song ("Watch Out") technically ends at the 4:00
mark, it’s followed by a minute of silence which leads into "Two Drink
Minimum," a bluesy rock song where Cornell moans that he’s "no more than
two drinks away from crying." Is it an admission of the tears he expects
to shed when the album inevitably proves to be a commercial failure –
because, really, creative success or not, who the hell is gonna buy this
thing? – or is it simply intended as a last-second musical assurance that
the album to which you’ve just been listening isn’t a permanent change
in sound?
Whichever proves to be the case, one thing’s for certain:
Scream is a record that is destined to develop a rabid cult following.
Obviously, their numbers won’t come anywhere near reaching the amount
of people who’ll loathe it with every fiber of their being, but if you
can get behind Cornell’s change in musical direction and aren’t scared
of hearing his voice surrounded by an almost entirely inorganic sound,
then you’ll quickly find that it’s a very easy album to embrace. - Will
Harris
From the international Blogcritics
Magazine:
When Chris Cornell announced that this, his third
solo outing, was to be a collaboration with R&B wunderkind Timbaland,
he was met with a mixture of pessimistic trepidation and outright indignation.
It seems that, to many fans, the singer’s move away from the signature
wail of Soundgarden and Audioslave is to be regarded as nothing short
of blasphemy.
Many critics too have dismissed Scream’s brand
of watered down grunge-hop as a sort of musical mid-life crisis with no
real purpose other than to perhaps act as a cathartic exercise, allowing
Cornell to exorcise his R&B demons. However, to view this record through
the eyes of a rock purist is to miss the point of what the singer is trying
to achieve, as well as depriving oneself of a rewarding listening experience
that delivers more with each revisit.
Although the album opens with an irritatingly obnoxious
horn introduction that would sound more at home over the opening credits
of a low-budget George Lucas movie, and a worryingly stylised synth voice-over
heralding "the Chris Cornell experience..." it soon settles into its stride
with first single "Part Of Me" immediately showing off Timbaland’s trademarks
— heavy bass-lines, synthesized samples, and dance-floor rhythms, with
guitars way down in the mix. The segue into "Time" feels a little forced,
as do many of the segue sections that come as part of this concept album
premise, but the vocal delivery and catchy chorus ultimately make it more
memorable than the opener.
Timbaland’s influence rears its ugly head again in
the appalling use of Autotune vocals in "Sweet Revenge" where, instead
of capitalizing on one of the finest voices the rock genre has to offer,
the producer reduces Cornell’s bark to a robotic drone. Through the album’s
finest moments, such as the dynamic, September 11-inspired "Ground Zero,"
the soaring "Never Far Away," the spacey U2-esque title track, and the
closing smoky blues of "Two Drink Minimum," Cornell’s vocals shine through,
and even on the weaker numbers remain characteristically strong.
However, the thing that lets this album down is in
fact its "unique selling point," and the very factor that had Cornell’s
fans all riled up in the first place — Timbaland. The hip-hop super-producer
seems to be entirely out of his depth here, and whilst a few numbers possess
interesting and full arrangements, for the most part his production is
bland, unimaginative, and does very little to compliment either singer
or songs. Whilst the tricks of the trade that he constantly reuses may
work to great effect in the more electronic based genres of pop, hip-hop
and R&B, here alongside Cornell’s edgy rock voice they sound corny,
out-dated, and extremely forced. It is also worthy to note that the poetic
integrity associated with Cornell over the years is somewhat tarnished
by placing him in this most misogynistic of genres, with the usual ethereal
images and heartfelt sentimentality somewhat replaced with posturing gibberish.
That said, Scream is not without merit
and has a number of extremely rewarding moments amongst the more lacklustre
work. This album was never going to equal the heights of Cornell’s glory
days but it is at least encouraging, in a time where so many of our ‘pop’
stars find their ‘sound’ and stick to it with a terrified steadfastness,
to see such a seasoned artist stepping out of his comfort zone and trying
something more left field. Moreover when viewed without pre-conceptions,
Scream in fact stands tall within the modern R&B canon. - Rhys
Williams
From London's Evening Standard:
Chris Cornell: Scream
Now, this is a strange one. Cornell's is the big,
tough voice that fronted Soundgarden and Audioslave. Timbaland is one
of the most feted of hip-hop producers. They have - it gets stranger -
teamed up to produce an album that owes its inspiration to Pink Floyd's
The Wall. It has 13 songs which, thankfully, do not appear to constitute
a concept album, rather an experiment in pop-rock underpinned with electro-synth
and drumpatterns from the dance world. The record has taken some stick
(Trent Reznor described it as "embarassing") but it has some
sweet melodies lurking among the electronics. The main problem is that
a lot of the material is seriously repetitive and outstays its welcome.
A brave effort, nevertheless. - Pete Clark
From the UK's Mizz magazine:
Scream: Chris Cornell
Mega-producer Timbaland works his magic on this dark
and brooding album - it was Chris's version of Billie Jean that Austin
sang on the X Factor last year. Perfect for when you've had a rubbish
day.
From Scotland's The
Glaswegian: 5/5
Album of the week: John Martyn, Delta Spirit and
Chris Cornell
Chris Cornell: Scream
This is the third solo outing from the ex-Sound garden
and Audioslave singer. The grunge god wanted to do "something different"
and has teamed up with top R&B producer Timbaland to produce an album
that's already had fans accusing him of selling out. Best tracks are the
Eastern-inspired Take Me Alive, Enemy and Climbing The Walls.
From the UK's Mojo:
3/5
Chris Cornell: Scream
Erstwhile rocker goes urban at the suggestion
of pal Rick Rubin
Volte-face do not come much more radical than
this: Chris Cornell, formerly of Soundgarden and Audioslave, here teamed
up with Timbaland and Jerome 'J-Roc' Harmon, the production talents behind
Pussycat Dolls, Ashlee Simpson and more. Written and recorded in siux
weeks, the resulting album is a complex and expensive-sounding undertaking,
its exuberant, R&B tropes sometimes conjuring Michael Jackson trying
to re-invent Bad for the Z generation. Surefire radio hit "Long
Gone" succeeds by reining in some of the production/arrangemens excesses
that can make Scream sound unwieldy, and with Justin Timberlake
guesting on the eastern-flavoured "Take Me Alive", Cornell's
stab at mainstream pop success is clearly signposted. At 44, he may have
left it too late, and the Cher "Believe"-like vocal tweaks employed
on "Sweet Revenge" won't thrill every grunger. But Scream
has balls, Cornell vacating his comfort zone with admirable readiness.
- James McNair
From the UK's Mail
On Sunday (Live Magazine)
In Demand: The Album
Scream
Chris Cornell shrugs off the black cape of his rock
music past and sprays himself gold with the pop flavour of Timbaland for
Scream. Fans of his grunge output during the Nineties may wish
to hide inside their Kurt Cobain shrines, but there's a lot to like here.
From Men's
Health:
Album of the week: Scream
A different musical direction for Chris Cornell
Chris Cornell – you know his name: bare-chested, oddly-bearded howler
from grunge titans Soundgarden and, more recently, rock super group
Audioslave. He also did the theme tune for Casino Royale, which
was surprised a lot of his die-hard fans. Well, they’re in for an even
bigger shock with his third solo album Scream, produced as
it is by dance-colossus Timbaland and featuring the kind of R&B
pop we’ve come to expect from Justin Timberlake and Nelly Furtado.
To his credit it’s a bold move and one the former Seattle grunger executes
with great gusto - and unintentionally hilarious results. “That bitch
ain’t a part of me!” he yelps on opening track, Part Of Me,
while Sweet Revenge finds him puffing away like a dad at a
disco, vocodered vocals and string samples mocking his attempts to get
down with the kids. Even better – or worse, depending on your point
of view – is Get Up, where over a skeletal hip-hop beat our
Chris exhorts us to “Get off the floor.” You first, Mr Cornell, you
first.
At times it sounds as if Cornell is a guest vocalist on his own album
but I guess that’s what happens when you outsource your creativity.
However, after a few listens a handful of songs shine through the heavy-handed
production. On Time and Never Far Away the combination
of Cornell’s rock stylings and Timbaland’s beats creates something completely
original and Long Gone is one of the best tunes Cornell’s solo
years have so far produced.
But there’s a lot of filler, including unnecessary musical interludes
that link every track – they’re supposed to thematically segue the album,
but Scream is a concept album in search of a concept. They
only serve to give the songs an ending when they run out of steam, which
in the case of Crawling [I think he means "climbing"
- webmaster] Up The Walls and Other Side Of Town,
is pretty quickly.
So kudos for trying something new, but the album’s title may well be
the noise most of his fans will make on hearing it.
From the UK's Daily Mail:
Chris Cornell: Scream
Former Soundgarden frontman Cornell hails this futuristic
link-up with super-producer Timbaland as "the best thing I've ever
done". It is certainly an ambitious piece of music, pitching Cornell's
impassioned vocals against the producer's cool but masterful beats.
With its 13 tracks flowing into one another, the duo claim that Scream
was inspired by Pink Floyd's The Wall, although its widescreen fusion
of rock and dance owes rather more to Gnarls Barkley - AT
From the UK's Liverpool
Echo:
Chris Cornell - Scream
There’s something oddly endearing about the ex-Soundgarden
and Audioslave singer.
The grunge god wanted to do “something different”
and has teamed up with top R&B producer Timbaland.
True, this is not the hardcore rock his fans might
expect and it’s an ironic title as there’s very little screaming, but
the results are definitely worth a listen. - Jade Wright
From the UK's Music
Magazine:
Chris Cornell: Scream
Ever wondered what it would have been like if Michael
Jackson had formed Audioslave? OK not quite, but it was the first line
that came to mind on the first listen and it stuck. The idea of rock God
Chris Cornell and rapper/producer Timbaland teaming up for a new album
should make even the most open-minded fan of either run for the hills.
Sometimes the meeting of two great minds results in a total mess (Spielberg+Kubrick=AI
anyone?) but occasionally it works. And thankfully, and against all the
odds, Scream is one of those times.
If anything, opener Part Of Me is a very subdued introduction.
Any song (let alone a lead-off album track) that starts with a fanfare,
followed by demonic vocals pronouncing your arrival, makes you stand up
and take notice. But what emerges is a controlled, well thought-out slice
of modern bouncy electro-pop (none of this retro 80s nonsense). The combination
of rock voice and dance production, coupled with a slightly misogynistic
chorus, is not quite the song we were expecting. At over five minutes
it rolls along into a messy outro… until you realise that we have now
slid effortlessly into the next song: Time. One of the perfect things
(and a simple yet sometimes overused idea) is to connect all the songs
together into one glorious mix. Scream is a perfect example of how to
do it well.
This first part of the album builds to a magnificent
central point. Sweet Revenge has a wonderful R&B swagger without sounding
soulless even if it does overuse the vocoder, and then all gets a bit
old fashioned - the only time Scream ever does. Get Up plods along like
it’s being played at half-speed and never gets moving, until we enter
the squeaky political stomp of Ground Zero. The arrangement is absurdly
weird, adding to the intrigue. The link into Never Far Away is like falling
into madness before the real style begins and things start to settle down.
This is one of the best songs on Scream - shimmering with electronic wonder
and evolving in the last minute and half as grinding guitars come in to
announce an interlude.
A trilogy of songs continue the sublime run of form.
To begin, Take Me Alive is dark and mysterious, Cornell recalling the
tale: “there’s nowhere for me to go / I’m a long way away from home
/ I won’t go without a fight / you’ll never take me alive!”. Into
Long Gone and things get even more chilled with another soaring chorus
and some wonderful guitars - the late break forming an instant highlight.
Like the previous song, the last thirty seconds builds into the next song;
the title track stutters uneasily into life before taking shape. OK so
the chorus “Hey! Why you keep screaming at the top of your head”
doesn’t work, and the voice-over is a little cheesy, but this is one of
those forgivable moments. Even the repetitive last few minutes glide by
into a bizarrely dark outro - bringing things full circle…
…Into Enemy which quickly picks up the pace - diving
between quiet verses into thumping circular chorus. Lyrically, Cornell
just about gets away with “taking my time to untangle the wires and
stare into my sanity / dropping the hammer and pulling the trigger / I
know now the bullet is me” thanks to a slick serious delivery. Even
the military drum break ending, sliding neatly into Other Side Of Town
has enough variation to keep your interest. The song marks a brief lull,
and one of the only times the album descends into a too comfortable going-through-the-motions
emptiness. Just as it gets predictable, another great hook and chorus
drags you back into the fray and the overwhelming embrace engulfs you
again. This time it is the excellent Climbing Up The Walls with another
repetitive echoing chorus and shining guitars.
Into the last (official) song and Watch Out brings
together Justin Timberlake inanity with head banging foot-stomping vocals.
The end is sudden and after a minute or so of silence (the classic hidden
track link), the album ends with Two Drink Minimum - sounding more like
Mark Lanegan, this is a wonderful slice of dance-free no nonsense blues.
It is a strangely normal way to end such an insanely fused and entertaining
ride.
What Timbaland has done is created a dance album…
that is really a rock album. Even though it has been mucked around with
profusely, Cornell’s voice is still at the heart of this. And that is
the key. It is not soaked with rap as it could well be and Timbaland is
on his best behaviour. Rock purists will hate the constant loops and beats
(a good thing as there are far too many of them and they can just go away
and listen to Def Leppard and keep wishing it was still 1987) but more
importantly this will alienate hardcore Timbaland fans. There is always
a trade-off but no manner of over-production can destroy Cornell’s wonderful
vocals. They shine with the kind of energy Akon is searching for but never
finds.
It would be great to say that this is the sound of
the future; progression if you will. But it’s not that simple. This has
been done before for a start. What is clear is that this is one of those
times when it works. Scream is a thoroughly enjoyable ride, from subdued
start to strong finish, and those that are saying that the fusion of rock
and dance has diluted the qualities of both have not given Scream enough
time or respect. In a year when bands like U2 are trying to recapture
a past glory, here are two musicians moving forward, taking a risk, reaching
out… call it what you will. Trent Reznor should recognise a fellow musician
making the same giant steps he has recently and stop feeling embarrassed.
Against all expectations, Scream is a triumph. - Chris Sheerin
From The
Guardian: 2/5
Chris Cornell: Scream (Polydor)
The controversy surrounding Chris Cornell's decision
to collaborate with uber-producer Timbaland has set the rock world's teeth
on edge. But what's really shocking is how lazy, bland and humourless
Cornell's third solo album is. Timbaland, who has sprinkled his hip-hop
fairy dust on weaker voices, rinses away Cornell's inherent dirt and power,
and compresses the godfather of grunge until he squawks. Part of Me is
old-fashioned and repetitive; tired synths and strings wash over the uninspiring
Time and Ground Zero. Guitars are all too rare, and when they do emerge,
they're far too polite to fight against Timbaland's box of neo-soul tricks
and arbitrary rhythms. Cornell wrestles back control with Enemy and the
cosy pop of Other Side of Town. Never Far Away, meanwhile, ironically
recalls Aerosmith's Dream On, sampled so succinctly on Eminem's Sing for
the Moment, where hip-hop and rock nourished each other. Here, they both
starve.
From ArtistDirect:
3/5
Album Reviews: Scream by Chris Cornell
Considering Chris Cornell's songwriting leaps
during the Soundgarden years, his move to the real big time with
Audioslave, and the creative detours of his solo albums, most would not
expect the guy's third solo effort to be a return to his heavy roots.
But few would have expected it to be a pop album done in collaboration
with Timbaland.
We’re talking smooth electronic beats and Timbaland's
bleeps, bloops, samples, and sonic creations. The difference maker is
Cornell's golden throat, which can often make a mediocre song powerful.
On Scream, Cornell's voice is convincingly soulful, if occasionally
a tad askew in the context of the prototypical pop songwriting (Justin
Timberlake even makes an appearance!). The album does stay true–at
least to some extent—to Cornell's vision for an album, rather than
a mere collection of songs. That doesn't make it Pink Floyd's The
Wall though, and "single" surely wasn't a word banned during the recording
process. The ready-for-remix soulster "Part of Me" (and its memorable
refrain) is one of a handful of songs with minor hit potential. The style
is just not a perfect fit for Cornell, and Scream is not
a perfect album, but the risk pays off more times than not. —Scott
Alisoglu
From the UK's Shortlist
Magazine:
Chris Cornell: Scream
Unusual partnership of the week goes to the ex-lungs
of hard-rock titans Soundgarden and Audioslave and his beaty, bleepy makeover
at the hands of R&B super-producer Timbaland. It's an intriguing,
if surreal mix (Justin Timberlake even pops up on one track, which should
upset the grunge fraternity), but it somehow manages to tread the fine
line, between easy on the ear and experimental, successfully.
From The
New York Times:
CHRIS CORNELL
“Scream”
(Mosley Music/Interscope)
Rockers feeling stale can always jump genres. Darius
Rucker of Hootie and the Blowfish went country last year; now the rocker
Chris Cornell introduces electrogrunge on “Scream,” his third solo album.
Mr. Cornell, a grunge pioneer with Soundgarden in the 1980s and 1990s,
wrote all the songs on “Scream,” but most of the music sets aside big
guitar chords to embrace the synthetic pulse and programmed hooks produced
by the hip-hop and R&B hit maker Tim Mosley, a k a Timbaland.
“Scream” is Mr. Cornell’s assertive move out of his
old niche and toward the sound of the current Top 10. Goodbye, Pearl Jam,
and hello, Justin Timberlake (who adds backup vocals in one song, “Take
Me Alive”).
Singing about lovers’ quarrels and deeper anger and
self-doubt Mr. Cornell remains as sullen as he was in his rock songs for
Soundgarden and then Audioslave. In “Get Up” he intones: “You got a losing
hand. You built a house of cards. On a hill of sand.”
He still sings with the chesty intensity that lets
him project angst without weakness. But his complaints and confessions
now arrive in clipped melody lines punctuated by automated arpeggios and
snappy beats, as well as Timbaland trademarks like quick, sampled shouts.
Converging on pop from two different directions Mr.
Cornell and Timbaland often end up sounding, oddly enough, like Michael
Jackson in his semirockers (“Billie Jean,” “Dirty Diana”) or like Gnarls
Barkley placing a gutsy voice in an artificial matrix.
Timbaland reframes Mr. Cornell. The first five songs
on “Scream” pump along like a club D.J. set, staying at virtually the
same tempo. And the whole album segues; each track ends with a transition
to the next.
But only half the album aims for dance floors.
Some of Mr. Cornell’s best older songs, like Soundgarden’s “Black Hole
Sun,” were desolate ballads, and Timbaland would never disdain a dramatically
ascending chorus. It’s easy to imagine songs like “Take Me Alive,” “Long
Gone,” “Never Far Away” and “Scream” itself in smoldering rock arrangements
rather than Timbaland’s Bollywood exotica (“Take Me Alive”), layered chorales
(“Long Gone” and “Never Far Away”) and chattering double-time beats (“Scream”).
The new environment rejuvenates Mr. Cornell for good and bad: he sounds
shallower than he was before but pithier too.
JON PARELES
From Entertainment
Weekly:
Turns out that cover of Michael Jackson's ''Billie
Jean'' on Chris Cornell's last solo album was prophetic; the former Soundgarden/Audioslave
frontman's controversial new CD seems like nothing so much as an attempt
to create his very own Thriller. What's more surprising than Scream's
R&B bells and whistles (provided by überproducer Timbaland) is that Cornell
almost succeeds at that goal without tarnishing his hard-rawkin' legacy.
Expansive ballads like ''Never Far Away'' and ''Long Gone'' sound like
dance-floor cousins to ''Black Hole Sun,'' and ''Time'' is perhaps the
funkiest song to bear that title since Sly Stone's. Talk about being alive
in the superunknown. B+ - Tom Sinclair
From Spin:
2.5/5
Produced with a heavy hand by Timbaland, the third
solo album from ex-Soundgarden and Audioslave singer Chris Cornell is
strangely appealing in its elaborately empty efficiency. Gleaming ballads
like "Long Gone" and the title track wring mild drama from a combination
of Cornell's husky crooning and stacks of portentous Phil Collins–derived
synths. As Akon knockoffs go, some of this stuff isn't bad, but the fast
numbers ("Time," "Get Up"), with Cornell's angsty rock-god vocals ricocheting
off Timbo's skittering beats, are fresher and more enjoyable, at least
in a monkey-riding-a-tricycle sort of way. - David Marchese
From The Boston
Globe:
Chris Cornell Scream
ESSENTIAL "Take Me Alive"
In theory, this seems like an intriguing experiment:
Chris Cornell (above), the golden throat of grunge, teaming up with Timbaland,
the maestro producer of au courant dance pop.
In execution, it is an intriguing muddle.
The credit - or blame, depending on the song - lies
mostly with Timbaland, who simply plops the former Soundgarden frontman's
voice into the sea of burping synths, celestial choirs, and fuzz that
are the producer's undeniably funky signature. He rarely stretches more
than a little toward Cornell's rock aesthetic, so it feels much more like
"Timbaland featuring Chris Cornell" than the reverse. (The exception is
a satisfyingly straight-up and lowdown blues rocker lurking as a hidden
track.)
This forces the singer-songwriter to find a way to
plug his poetic musings into a nightclub wall of sound, a framework that
worked better for previous Timbo collaborators such as Nelly Furtado and
Justin Timberlake. (The latter shows up to add backing vocals to the album's
most compelling track, the sinuous Eastern-tinged groove "Take Me Alive").
Unfortunately, Cornell doesn't always come up with poetry, especially
in opener "Part of Me," in which he endlessly repeats the unappealing
phrase "that [unflattering word for woman] ain't a part of me."
Timbaland's beguilingly left-field vocal arrangements
work well, however, particularly on the galloping "Time," as does Cornell's
always impressive voice. He nimbly exploits his mesmerizing lower register
and soars in the stacked harmonies of "Get Up" and the title track.
The resulting dynamic is two distinct flowers from
the sound garden that produce an only occasionally sweet-smelling bouquet.
- Sarah Rodman
From The
Huffington Post:
CHRIS CORNELL - SCREAM
Considering the amount of changes in musical direction
Chris Cornell has undertaken during his tour of duty with Soundgarden,
Temple Of The Dog, Audioslave, and his three diverse solo albums, you
get the feeling the dude gets bored easily. It's almost as if his creative
drive is based on mixing things up at the slightest hint of "comfortable,"
like some sort of artistic survival response. With every new solo album--such
as 1999's Euphoria Morning (his "mature" album), 2007's Carry
On (his more aggressive, commercial Rick Rubin rock project complete
with strings and Dylanesque album cover), and now the proggy, r&b-driven
Scream--there comes a further departure from not only the last
release, but from what one would expect from this college radio god. Yes,
we've been prepped on Scream for eons, whether it be in months
of well-timed press releases, artist statements and interviews, downloadable
tracks, or the Alan Furguson-directed title track video. But not everyone
has been re-educated, and boy, do you have a surprise coming if you haven't
caught any of these appetizers, considering just how far Cornell's pet
project pushes pre-conceived parameters.
This time out, it's all about the Timbaland. Sure,
throw-in co-producer Jerome Harmon, mixing engineer (and Nelly Furtado
hubby) Demacio "Demo" Castellon, and vocal seer and overseer, Jim Beanz...but
it's Timbaland's court. All have guided Scream's and Chris Cornell's
sonics through a world of elegant but simple drum loops, banks of beautiful-to-wanky
samples, a scratch or two here and there, and a jungle of sounds that
conjures a visual like the old "Don't Cross The Street In The Middle Of
The Block" PSAs of the sixties. Cornell sounds great navigating this cacophony,
and Justin Timberlake and Timbaland merely accent the tracks on which
they appear, never competing for artist title.
However, this is such a new adventure for Cornell
that no matter how comfortable you get with Scream's interlude-laced,
rock-soul approach, if you're a long-time fan, you're going to wonder
which console fader jammed when it came to the guitar mixes. Yeah, they're
in the stereo spread, but only occasionally poke their heads through the
layers of lush keyboards, percussion and processed effects. But does it
matter? Nope, not at all. Remember, this album--that Cornell suggests
we listen to like Dark Side Of The Moon (Pink Floyd) or A
Night At The Opera (Queen)--is supposed to blow your mind, especially
though headphones. Plus this is a successful melange of concepts initiated
on Introducing The Hardline According To Terence Trent D'Arby
with some Gnarls Barkley served as a side dish.
Though the style has changed, we still get good ol'
engaging Cornell lyrics, and some really bite (in the good sense), like
those on the hook-laden, semi-rocker album opener, "Part Of Me," that
begins after a cute faux movie-studio logo prelude. Floating amidst block
vocals and minor key synth sounds that Rick Wakeman and The Tubes would
envy is the line "No, that bitch ain't a part of me." It's repeated so
often and matter-of-factly that it ends up being a misogynous anthem that's,
thankfully, delivered without a ridiculous cookie-monster voice (a trend
that needs to die quickly). The song's aggressive tone sets up the rest
of the project, an exploration of stressed or failed relationships (including
global).
"Time" features the smart lyrics, "The perfect present...is
no longer the future," but an unexpected channeling of Don Henley's "Dirty
Laundry" in the bridge section gets more of your attention through bouncing
phrases such as, "Make a little love, make a little war" and "have a little
laugh, have a little cry, each moment gets us closer to saying goodbye."
"Sweet Revenge" discusses just what the title implies, despite its melody
clipping a wee bit of Michael Jackson in the verses (nothing to see here
folks, it's quite appropriate on an album like this, move along). "Get
Up"'s chorus teaches us how "You need a backbone to roll with the world,
you need one to run with the bulls," and "Ground Zero" asks, "When it
all falls down and laws don't count...where in the world you gonna go?"
This track, with its seventies-ish string arrangement, top and bottom
interludes, subject matter, and soulful melody, seems to have been inspired
by Marvin Gaye's What's Going On album. (Again, that's a good
thing.)
After a much needed tempo change, the beautiful alty-gospel
"Never Far Away" appears, and rock guitars finally assert themselves in
the end sections. Cornell sings, "Give me definition for the words I know"
as the melody suggests The Thomspon Twins have stopped by for beers. Sitar
and a moody caravan tempo permeate verses of "Take Me Alive" (with guest
Justin Timberlake), while the chorus evokes Matthew Sweet's Altered
Beast-era vocal arrangements that bring home this tight sarcophagus
that is wrapped in middle-east trappings. And though it sounds quite contemporary,
"Long Gone"--if it had a monsterously fat, reverberated snair (and no
audible Timbaland)--would be the power ballad most eighties hair bands
would have traded their souls for had it been incarnated in that decade.
And that brings us to the title track, "Scream." With
Mars Lazar meets Yes synths and drum machines this side of Hall &
Oates' "I Can't Go For That (No Can Do)," Cornell's hook-filled meditation
on composure asks the girl, "Why you keep screaming at the top of your
head?" But you almost want to ask if the relationship is that damaged,
why aren't you screaming too? The dysfunction continues with the line,
"Throwing out the blame when you know it ain't my fault," but something
hits home by the end of the song when Cornell sings, "I used to think
that silence was golden." The lyrics question the surface meaning of all
that preceded it, and that might be confirmed in the song's video that
starts with relationship anger that eventually leads to everyone brawling.
So is the message that "screaming" is what is contagious and damaging
or possibly the ignoring of it--Cornell's first coping device in the vid?
This equation continues through the rest of the album,
finally reaching "Watch Out," just a great classic rock piece whose arrangement
and vocals are like a "Shout Out" to David Coverdale (no, Cornell's still
not screaming). The song cleverly ends with what sounds like a tape reel
spooling off of a Studer recorder, but don't be fooled, Cornell fans.
We're served one more round in his hidden bluesy co-write with John Mayer
titled "Two Drink Minimum," an after hours slow burn with smoldering harmonica
and, presumably, Hammond B-3. (Note to John Mayer: Don't even think about
a Timbaland collaboration.)
Overall, Scream is one of those albums in
which you really lose yourself in the environment without questioning
who it is you're listening to or the artist's history. Mission accomplished,
that was the creator's intention...and that you listen to it top-to-bottom
like the great concept albums of yore. But given his rock history, it
is surprising that Cornell is not really doing a lot of screaming here
except for within the lyrics. And all of his co-writing with Timbaland
and posse has forced his music to leave behind a street of raucous, in-your-face
stickball and hockey for one where he now has to gain a different kind
of cred. Pretty brave, and it's nice that Timbaland has his back. But
as good as Scream is--and let's wish it well--it would be a shame
if the Chris Cornell we followed over all these years decides not to rock
again because of its success. Now THAT would be a reason to scream. -
Mike Racogna
From Rochester
City Newspaper:
When Weezer's last album opened with a dig on rockers
who work with Timbaland, it probably wasn't intended for Chris Cornell
-- but does the shoe fit? To their credit, Cornell and the celebrated
hip-hop producer could have just tossed off a few flashy singles, but
they both insisted on making a bona-fide album. Cornell had been veering
dangerously close to pop-lite territory anyway, so only stood to benefit
from Timbaland's visionary sonic touch. As expected, the producer provides
sparkling, beat-driven soundscapes, but his master stroke comes in his
ability to extract positively addicting hooks out of the least obvious
of instruments. He also capitalizes on the latent R&B tendencies Cornell
has shown from day one. Cornell's days as a brooding alt-rocker with a
sharp poetic edge may be long gone, but at least he's found the nerve
to show a completely new side of himself. - Saby Reyes-Kulkarni
From Rolling
Stone: 2/5
Hip–hop production god Timbaland oversaw Chris Cornell's
third solo album, which begs a question: Can digital–age beats party successfully
with rock–god howling? The answer: Only if good tunes are invited. Scream
veers between drab–sleek and rock–dude soulful; Cornell's yowl never sounds
at home — especially on the "bitch ain't a part of me!" chorus on the
lead track. Timbo lays it on thick - piles of guitars, dramatic synths
and percussion that at their best achieve a meticulous heaviness. With
the exception of the taut "Ground Zero," Scream feels like it belongs
in a time capsule, a strange mutation that could only have been born this
decade — Christian Hoard
From Billboard:
Scream
The oft-delayed blend of Chris Cornell's trademark
grunge-soul growl and Timbaland's percolating computer grooves, "Scream"
is no less bizarre than its team-up suggests. Sometimes it's good bizarre:
"Never Far Away" throbs with a dark drama not unlike the kind Cornell
brought to his 2007 cover of Michael Jackson's "Billie Jean." Other times
it's bad bizarre: With its layered harmony vocals and chintzy Middle Eastern
trimmings, "Take Me Alive" sounds like it should be credited to the Pussycat
Dudes. Throughout "Scream," though, you have to admire Cornell's and Timbaland's
conviction: This music never gives off the whiff of desperation, even
when it probably should. — Mikael Wood
From Ireland's Hot
Press: 4/5
Chris Cornell: Scream
Unlikely But Rewarding Hook-Up Between Grunge Anti-Hero
and Justin Timberlake Guru
Chris Cornell is the dusty-lunged belter from Soundgarden
and Audioslave. Timbland steered R 'n'B's progression towards glitched-up
minimalism. Lock them together in a studio and you get a very expensive
bus-wreck, right?
You'll be surprised to hear the answer is mostly "no".
Though this hook-up frequently pushes at the boundaries of plausibility,
there's lots about Scream that makes perfect sense.
Exhibit A is the single 'Ground Zero', a bluesy chiller
that dispenses with high-end trickery and pairs Cornell's growl with a
spare drum-tap. Elsewhere, 'Sweet Revenge' slices and dices Cornell's
vocals and juxtaposes a yammering synth line so that it sounds as if he's
struggling to be heard over the death-squawks of a chorus of quietly malfunctioning
robots. Alas, there are momennts when the innovation spills over into
indulgence: 'Never Far Away' is unabashed stadium pap which not even a
tumult of Timbalnd FX can save from sounding like an out-take from Bon
Jovi's country phase. - Ed Power
Key Track: Ground Zero
A preview from Ultimate
Guitar:
Fans of Chris Cornell’s Soundgarden days may be
in for the shock of their lives with the singer’s new solo release, Scream.
Sound: For
those of us who grew up with the early, grunge-fueled days of Soundgarden,
you’re about to be in for a shock. Many of us know that Cornell has been
branching out toward a more radio-friendly sound since splitting with
Audioslave back in 2007, but the singer’s latest effort is a huge leap
into unfamiliar territory: dance music. Scream, Cornell’s 3rd solo studio
album, is rooted heavily in synth, sampling, and dance grooves. It’s a
logical result, considering that Cornell chose Timbaland (the man behind
many Justin Timberlake and Nelly Furtado songs) to act as one of the main
producers of the album. Long story short, the best way to go into listening
to Scream is with a completely open mind.
Listening to the 1st track on the record, I seriously thought I had put
in the wrong CD. There were no crunchy guitars, or even acoustics for
that matter. The song “Part of Me” begins with majestic horns (or at least
samples) and soon after a crazy and indecipherable voice that sounds like
a cross between a robot and a demon. It’s not really the way you expect
a Cornell album to kick off, and it’s not necessarily a bad thing – just
extremely unexpected. After the elaborate intro, “Part of Me” morphs into
what is essentially a dance song. Drum beats and samples drive the song,
and it is actually infectious in a clubgoer sort of way.
The dance/R&B vibe stays consistent throughout, and Timbaland certainly
has a way with creating some unusual mixes. Between the Middle Eastern
vibe and rich vocal harmonies of “Take Me Alive” to the computer-like
synth solo of “Sweet Revenge,” the creativity isn’t lacking. “Scream,”
which has a title that begs for some musical insanity (possibly of the
metal kind), is actually one of the most laid-back songs on the album.
Once again, Cornell knows how to raise a few eyebrows.
In the latter part of the album things tend to get a little repetitive.
Granted, club/techno hits often rely on choruses that repeat the same
line over and over again, and given the content on Scream, that’s probably
what Timbaland and Cornell were going for. If you’re a fan of a more stripped-down
sound that gets back to the basics, you’ll have to wait until the final
track. “Two Drink Minimum” is a bluesy little number co-written by John
Mayer, and while it’s still a far cry from “Pretty Noose” or “Loud Love,”
it’s nice to hear instruments in their raw form come through the mix.
// 7
Lyrics
and Singing:
When you compare the lyrics on Scream to Cornell’s past works,
it definitely seems like many of them been written to fit the dance genre.
“Part of Me” is a prime example with lines such as, “I love the girl,
I'm lovin' the dress she wears; She's got a hold, got a hold of me neck,
oh yeah.” Not every tracks is as quite as superficial, and there are
a few that are more emotionally driven. In “Long Gone” Cornell sings,
“I used to watch your flowers grow; Now it's raining and all your petals
turns to stone; I've been praying; I turn around and see my rose.”
The lyrical content may not be quite as strong as what we’ve heard in
some Soundgarden songs, but in comparison to the music it’s nothing too
out of the ordinary. // 8
Impression:
The cover photo for Scream couldn’t be more fitting: Chris
appears to look as if he’s about to smash the living crap out of his guitar.
I may be reading too much into it, but it certainly does seem to relay
a message that you don’t always need a guitar as the centerpiece to create
a quality song. If you don’t like the idea of dance music fueled by funky
samples and drum machines, you may be quite angry with the direction that
Cornell has chosen. When compared with his last release Carry On, you
do have to give him credit for being more innovative. Having Timbaland
as a producer could guarantee him success with a whole new audience, and
those listeners will likely be the most receptive to Cornell’s new club-driven
repertoire. For those who are still mad that he went to a softer style
of rock in Audioslave, Scream might be the final straw.
An
album preview from LA's Buzzine:
Many of Timbaland’s couplings initially raise some
eyebrows, as is the nature of those who are truly avant-garde and visionary.
Scream, however, is raising a lot more than eyebrows.
It’s raising angry voices. Many Soundgarden and Audioslave fans, and those
who hark back to the raw roots of rock, are showing reactions that range
from devastation to disappointment, to disgust. Some are even regarding
Chris Cornell as one of the biggest sell-outs of this era. Wherever your
loyalties, preconceptions, or grudges lie, the fact remains that this
album is going to be chock-full of good music.
Perhaps the fact that I’m a sucker for both alternative
rock and heavy, electronic beats makes me a little bit biased. Maybe the
promise that this album will have a “psychedelic,” ambient feel strikes
my fancy. Still, I honestly believe that Timbaland and Chris Cornell each
bring what the other is lacking to the table. Timbaland produced a long
string of singles, but I can’t say I know the name of even one of his
albums. Scream, in part inspired by Pink Floyd’s The Wall, is said to
be a comprehensive piece that will wrap listeners up in an entire experience.
Chris Cornell, on the other hand, evidently could not go on with the same
old sound any longer, and nothing forces inspiration to the surface like
a change of pace.
The album is set for a March 9th release, and I’m
willing to bet that the resulting Scream will be one of approval instead
of one of rejection.
From a
German article reviewing the Part Of Me video and previewing
the album: here, Scream is called a "masterpiece".
Mit der Singleauskopplung „Part Of Me“ zieht Chris
Cornell den Hörer direkt hinein in das Gipfeltreffen der Ikonen und präsentiert
ein erstes, alle Sinne berauschendes und energiegeladenes Soundfeuerwerk.
„Part Of Me“ erzählt von der sexuellen Anziehungskraft, dem inneren Kampf,
sich zu einer Frau immer noch hingezogen zu fühlen, aber genau zu wissen,
dass es ein Fehler ist. Diese Zerrissenheit zwischen dem Wunsch, ihr ganz
nahe sein zu wollen, und dem alarmierenden Gedanken, dass sie immer noch
die Falsche ist, erzählt Cornell mit bittersüßer Erkenntnis: „That bitch
ain’t a part of me“. Chris Cornells markante Stimme brennt die Hook des
Songs direkt in alle Sinne und vereint sich mit Timbalands Soundwelten
zu einem einzigartigen Highlight, das eines ganz deutlich macht: Mit „Scream“
rollt ein Meisterwerk auf uns zu….!
A
review of Part Of Me, released as a single (with club remixes)
in Germany:
Chris Cornell - Part Of Me [Interscope] New on the
circuit and put out as 10" promo via Interscope is Chris Cornell's Timbaland-produced
tune "Part Of Me" taken from his album "Scream". Fusing solid rock-influenced
song writing on top of slow, electronic beats on the edge of House and
Minimal Techno this one will work for mainstream radio as well as for
club DJ's - especially the Instrumental cut will be loved by all those
jocks spinning (Neo) Disco and Cosmic these days. Check.
An early album preview from The
New York Times:
Some Chartmakers to Be: Metal Gods and Idols Past
CHRIS CORNELL Bye-bye, grunge — well, almost. Mr.
Cornell, a grunge pioneer as the lead singer of Soundgarden, worked with
the producer Timbaland for his third solo album, “Scream,” and their collaboration
places his brooding voice amid Timbaland’s synthesizers and samples. The
computerized tracks end up somewhere between Justin Timberlake and Gnarls
Barkley, but his lyrics and his voice still hold that sullen grunge resentment.
From Rolling Stone's Fall
Music Preview:
Scream
Chris Cornell's previous solo album Carry On was on
its way to being a footnote until it was rescued from obscurity by American
Idol champ David Cook, who performed Cornell's version of Michael Jackson's
"Billie Jean" to great acclaim on the show. That melding of rock and R&B
informs the onetime Audioslave frontman's new Timbaland-produced album,
which was cut in a rapid-fire six-week studio run. "He's somebody who's
a musical genius and records in very unorthodox ways," Timbaland has said
of his latest collaborator's sessions, which resulted in songs that sound
more like Gnarls Barkley than Temple of the Dog.
Chris Cornell is so much better off alone. Really.
Take, for example, his first go-around with Seattle
grunge-rock mainstays Soundgarden in 1984. While riding the coattails
of what turned out to be just another fad in the ever-so-frivolous world
of music, Cornell’s first band was enshrined in the mundane world of plaid-rock
with such memorable sleepers as “Black Hole Sun” and “Spoonman”.
Then came the all-star gala that was Temple of the
Dog. While this project combined the limited talents of Cornell, Eddie
Vedder, Matt Cameron, and Stone Gossard (any Seattle kid’s wet dream),
it never found its way out of obscurity and into any teenager’s empty
heart, or record collection for that matter.
And finally, there’s Audioslave. Again, something
of a modern-rock supergroup forming in 2001, though it looked awfully
good on paper, the combination of Cornell’s crooning and the Machine’s
talents never quite lived up to what every alternative rock-music-listening
junkie ever hoped for.
Really. Chris Cornell is better off alone.
Even his first solo release, 1999’s Euphoria Morning,
peeked at hints of greatness and actual intrigue at times. Songs like
Temple’s “Hunger Strike” and Soundgarden’s “Pretty Noose” couldn’t hold
half of a candle to Morning lead single “Can’t Change Me”’s eerie feel
and odd time signature. The performance itself simply felt much more liberating
than anything any of his other projects have ever produced.
Which is perhaps why he opted to leave the world o’
modern rock group again with his second official full-length solo release
in almost a decade, Carry On. Here, Cornell shines brighter than ever
by ditching the watered-down sound of modern rock and giving the nod to
something a little more accessible, and a lot more interesting.
“She’ll Never Be Your Man” is a pleasantly confusing
love-torn tale that proves to be indicative of Cornell’s choice to pop
things up throughout his latest effort. As the acoustic guitars and tambourines
color in the backdrop, the almost-kind of twang-y hook and Cornell’s half-snarl
suggest that a tiny bit of southern rock probably influenced this track,
if not the entire record.
Then, songs like “Finally Forever” and “Killing Birds”
prove to be how good everyone wanted Soundgarden to be. Two of only four
tracks on Carry On that feel like they could have fit on a Soundgarden
release, these two songs showcase the man’s powerful vocal ability in
front of the lackadaisical guitar work that made Cornell’s first band
so popular.
But Carry On is at its absolute best when Cornell
visibly sheds any aforementioned desire to continue as a hard-rock artist.
“Arms Around Your Love”, the best piece of songwriting Cornell has ever
been a part of, is a three-and-a-half minute pop-rock single that needs
to be everybody’s favorite guilty pleasure. The blatant pop-rock acoustic
guitar backdrop and catchy electric hook make this song a damn good play
for pop-radio domination. While he has never seemed any more generic,
he has never sounded any better.
The only blemish throughout this colorful painting
comes when Cornell tries something he obviously wasn’t sure he should
do in the first place: A crack at Michael Jackson’s super-duper-mega-hit
“Billie Jean”. While the performance itself feels forced and stiff, Cornell’s
arrangement is sobering at best. It simply never picks up, making the
song a harsh reminder that, yes, he can still be humdrum.
But one slip-up out of 14 opportunities really isn’t
bad. Even songs like the predictable “Safe and Sound” and the Audioslave
throw-away “Poison Eye” aren’t just not bad, but really kind of good.
Before “Safe and Sound”’s balladry qualities become watered down, Cornell
surprisingly takes a hold of the performance and commands attention with
what turns out to be a shockingly soulful performance (the horn section
helps too). “Poison Eye”, a song that may have fit better on his latest
band’s second release, is more than tolerable and certainly more advanced
than what Rage Against the Garden was ever going for. It keeps Cornell’s
aggressive side intact enough to not override the idiosyncratic maneuvers
his band displays.
And maybe that’s his secret. The common denominator
in all of Cornell’s solo ventures lies within the limitations he puts
on his insistent qualities, and that’s a good thing. Because with Carry
On, an effort that shows exactly how simple and light Cornell can go,
he proves that sometimes being alone isn’t all that bad.
- Colin Maguire, Pop
Matters
For those familiar with the rock genre, Chris Cornell's
name carries a lot of weight. Cornell is most famous as the frontman for
the bands Soundgarden and Audioslave. On the heels of his recently announced
departure from Audioslave comes "Carry On," Cornell's second solo album
following 1999's "Euphoria Morning."
In the song "Ghosts," Cornell uses moving to a new
house as a metaphor for a person growing, changing, moving forward with
his life and leaving others behind. That seems to be a recurring theme
throughout the album, representing his growing and maturing as an artist.
While most of his earlier work is fast-paced and edgier,
this album is much more mellow and laid-back--and much easier to digest.
Songs like "Finally Forever" and "Safe and Sound" benefit from Cornell's
sensitivity as a vocalist. It would be easy for him just to uncork a huge
scream like he has in the past, but he demonstrates proper restraint and
showcases his versatility. Several of the songs have a distinct Beatles
influence, most clearly the bouncy-yet-electric beat of "Poison Eye."
Cornell can still rock, however, as he proves on the
first and last tracks: "No Such Thing" and "You Know My Name." If I didn't
know any better, I'd have thought those songs were off an Audioslave record.
Their hard-driving guitar riffs and passionate vocals make them my favorite
songs on the album.
In short, approach this record with an open mind.
Don't pick it up expecting the same style you're used to hearing with
Cornell. Give each track a fair listen, and, like me, you'll probably
be impressed.
- J P Stroman, Freelance
Star
The mediocre reviews of Chris Cornell's new effort,
Carry On, have been premature. Perhaps his rock-god good looks have blinded
me but with Cornell's second solo outing, the grunge pioneer seems to
have truly unleashed his creative juices, creating an adventurous romp
that finds Cornell's trademark wails tempered by a less angry, and more
soulful release. Influenced by his days with Soundgarden and Temple of
the Dog, Cornell drew from a more organic place with these bands than
with his last group, Audioslave, whose political, anthem-like style made
for an unnatural fit. While Cornell rocks with the same passion on Carry
On, his lyrics showcase a true romantic at heart, often speaking of love,
both lost and found.
One such gem, "Arms Around Your Love," has to be one
of Cornell's finest moments to date, as he speaks of what can happened
when love is taken for granted, singing in pained fashion, "With his arms
around your girl/He'll do all of the things/You didn't do before/You had
every chance." Here is a perfect, hard-edged rock ballad that showcases
Cornell's best qualities and sometimes recalls Soundgarden's outstanding,
"Fell On Black Days." Cornell mixes in a horn section on the gospel-inflected
track, "Safe And Sound," with a vocal approach of a true soul singer.
That style continues on the more rocked-up "She'll Never Be Your Man,"
while Cornell's vox is in especially good form on "Ghosts," segueing from
falsetto to alto with utter ease. On initial word of a surprise cover
of Michael Jackson's "Billie Jean," fans may wonder "why?," but Cornell's
slow, bluesy version of the track not only leads to kudos for him making
the selection, but also somehow gives Jackson a much needed boost of musical
credibility.
The former shirtless, boot-stomping leader of champion
rock outfits may have softened on his more recent musical approach, but
Chris Cornell's authentic artistic appeal is still in full view here.
- Michelle Picardo, Freetime
Magazine
Carry On is Chris Cornell's first release since the
dissolution of Audioslave.
Many of this album's songs possess a vein of neo-southern
rock, which might best be heard on the track "Safe and Sound". The songs
are more melodic and laid-back when compared with his previous body of
work.
The shift in bearing can be somewhat surprising at
times, especially during a dawdling rendition of "Billie Jean". This is
a solid effort, but may not be considered his best.
- j.p, 75
Or Less
Great vocals, great riffs and a great style would
surely produce a great album so why did Carry On leave me so unsure?
The ex-Soundgarden front man has combined powerful
rock, country blues and a few slow, but sometimes dull, ballads. It has
the soundtrack to Casino Royale‚ You Know My Name, and a very dubious
cover of Michael Jackson’s Billie Jean.
Having said that, after the last track had finished,
Carry On does entice you to play it again. I may have to have just one
more listen.
- Cpl Ray Kalaker, RETDU(B), Soldier
Magazine (the magazine of the British Army)
Lead track No Such Thing, with its sludgy guitars,
frenetic pulse and that familiar bellow may just be the best song Chris
Cornell’s recorded since departing Soundgarden 10 years ago. It’s no Superunknown
or Jesus Christ Pose but it’s harder than anything Cornell’s put out in
the last decade, and that includes all the stuff cut with Audioslave.
Even the lyrics – “But my finger’s on the trigger
that will turn off the world” – rage with the old fire. The next cut,
Poison Eye, is less spectacular but still impressive. It’s psycho funk
with an alt-metal bite.
Now, if only the remaining 13 tracks were as good
as that opening double salvo, this would have been one of the records
of the year. If only.
The problem with Cornell is that while he knows that
you know he can do bombastic rock in his sleep, there’s a desire to prove
that there’s more to him than meets the eye (or ear). This is the reason
behind wimpy ballads like Hover and Finally Forever and the soul-tinged
Safe and Sound that makes him sound like ... shudder ... Michael Bolton!
Even worse is that excruciating cover of Billie Jean.
Yes, you read right! I do get the fact that Cornell is now in his 40s
and probably no longer inclined to tear off his shirt and dive into the
audience. But like it or not, that voice of his was built to rock. Hard.
– Edward Gomez, The
Star Online
Chris Cornell is arguably one of the best rock singers
of the past 50 years. He has an impressive CV: lead singer of one the
best '90s grunge groups (Soundgarden), early '90s super-grunge group (Temple
of the Dog) and more recently, rocking conglomerate Audioslave.
Now he is back with his second solo record since 1999's
Euphoria Morning . There seems to be a bit of a trend going on; at the
start of this year, Audioslave called it a day and a few months later
we have Carry On . His first solo album came out following the 1997 break
of Soundgarden - a bit of musical therapy perhaps?
Carry On is a sort of a neither-here-nor-there album.
The 16 songs are more laid back and rock 'n' roll than the grungy vibe
we are used to. An up-beat, almost positive feel resonates through this
album on songs such as 'Poison Eye', 'Ghosts', 'Today' and 'Finally Forever'.
Standouts are the awesome 'You Know My Name', which
featured in Casino Royale , and a darker, bluesy, rock version of Michael
Jackson's 'Billie Jean'.
7.5/10
Luke D., Tsunami
Carry On is the second solo album from former Audioslave
and Soundgarden front man Chris Cornell. The popular 90's grunge singer
steps into the spotlight and sheds his former grunge roots with an album
that is filled with melodic ballads that have a reggae, soulful appeal.
Earlier this year, Chris departed Audioslave due to
musical differences. On Carry On, Chris never loses his powerful, soulful
edge of reaching his audience with his heartfelt, poignant lyrics and
hypnotic vocals. Carry On features an artist who is clearly writing for
himself, and not trying to fit into the same grunge genre that has long
been passé. Although there are a few tracks that do capture that classic
Chris Cornell-Audioslave/Soundgarden grunge sound that he is known for,
the majority of the fourteen tracks on the album features a more, melodic
Cornell who sings about subjects that he holds true to his heart.
The opening track, ”No Such Thing", features slithering,
hard driving guitars, and vibrant vocals that put Cornell at the top of
his game in the 90's. Chris generates the anger and passion that is reminiscent
of his Soundgarden days. Definitely, one of my favorite tracks on the
new release.
Another highlight includes the beautiful ballad, ”Arms
Around Your Love". This song features great acoustic guitar work, and
lyrics that make you want to fall in love. Chris hasn't lost his touch
for taking you into his world and making you feel the intensity of his
music.
Next up, the song, ”Safe and Sound", Chris recently
said in concert was a song he wanted to write all his life. It is a song
that is rich in melody, and acoustic guitar work that deals with violence
in this ever-changing world.
"She'll Never Be Your Man", has an Eric Clapton bluesy
kind of appeal with sauntering guitar and percussion rhythms, and blues
inspired vocals. It sort of takes you down to the Blues and Jazz clubs
of New Orleans, where blues is the music by choice, and the artist feels
the pain in every chorus. Catchy guitar rhythms and up-tempo vocals are
among the qualities that rule this track.
One of the most surprising songs on the album is the
remake of the Michael Jackson hit, "Billie Jean". For a moment, I almost
didn't recognize the tune, as Chris does a 180-degree turnaround, and
turns the previous funky groove of the 80's hit into a compelling, sensual
love ballad. Cornell's voice whispers, ”she was more like a beauty queen
from a movie screen”, illustrating a real depth and rich quality to his
voice, with a vibrant reggae appeal. Chris also pays tribute to all of
the lives lost around the world to war and other violence in the politically-oriented
song, ”Silence The Voices".
Carry On ends with a song that was in the James Bond
movie, Casino Royale called, ”You Know My Name". Fans of the Soundgarden
years will enjoy this song. I had the opportunity to hear "No Such Thing",
"Arms Around Your Love", and "Safe and Safe", in his recent concert in
Boston. I was really impressed how these songs stand up lyrically and
musically.
On Carry On, Chris Cornell takes on the challenge
of a solo artist, and uses his distinctive, warm melodic voice as his
weapon. His vocals are reminiscent of a soulful Bob Marley, painfully
honest and real.
- Debby Rao, knac.com
Sound: 7 /10
Ask 5 different people’s opinions about Chris Cornell
and you’ll likely get 5 very unique perspectives. Whether you loved him
in Soundgarden and hated him in Audioslave -- or vice versa -- Cornell
has made some incredible songs that have spanned almost 2 decades. His
latest release Carry On marks his 2nd record as a solo artist, and in
similar fashion to his more recent efforts, the results are mixed.
The tracks on Carry On are another huge leap away
from his music in Soundgarden and Audioslave, which will probably have
some people furious off the bat. While there are guitar riffs here and
there that are reminiscent of mellower Soundgarden songs, they are still
subtle. The opening song “No Such Thing” is one of the true rock songs
on the album, which features a nice guitar line that is carried through
much of the song. If you have heard the James Bond theme song “You Know
My Name” that Cornell performed for Casino Royale, then you’ll have a
good indication what “No Such Thing” sounds like. They have a similar
feel and tempo, and are fairly solid pop-rock tracks.
Cornell is actually most impressive when he really
slows the tempo down surprisingly enough. “Safe And Sound,” a 1960’s flavored
soul song, and his version of Michael Jackson’s “Billie Jean” are a few
of the best tracks. Cornell’s vocals just seem more passionate when placed
against a slower rhythm. There will be rock purists who despise both of
the tracks, but if you can get past your adoration for Soundgarden (this
reviewer is a big Kim Thayil fan, too) then you’ll discover that Cornell
can still be effective at performing a soul song.
A few tracks like “Arms Around Your Love” and “Your
Soul Today” just feel like generic rock tracks and seem a bit hollow without
guitar backing from Tom Morello or Kim Thayil that often times carried
the tunes. This doesn’t necessarily mean the whole CD is full of generic
material. The CD contains 14 tracks and there are still some memorable
moments like the Beatles-esque intro in “Finally Forever.”
Lyrics: 9/10
Cornell’s lyrics cover a lot of ground on Carry On,
particularly considering he’s got everything from a soul ballad to a James
Bond theme on the CD. “You Know My Name” does fit the Bond persona pretty
well, and it even throws in some nice lines that allude to the gambling
in the movie. Cornell sings, “If you take a life, do you know what you'll
give; Odds are, you won't like what it is; When the storm arrives, would
you be seen with me; By the merciless eyes I've deceived.” Considering
he did have boundaries to work within, he did a pretty solid job.
He gets a bit more introspective in “Safe And Sound,”
but still manages to not ever get hokey. He sings. “You'll open your eyes;
Reading your paper, a drink from your cup; No one was burning down time;
While you were sleeping.” Cornell can always pull out an interesting lyric
here and there, and that is one of his strengths.
Impression: 7/10
Cornell still has some incredible vocal chops and
that’s something that hasn’t faded over the years. Even when he is singing
a laid-back track like “Safe And Sound,” he still has a very effective
bluesy delivery. Strong vocals are aplenty on the latest record, but underneath
the voice are songs that are primarily basic rock tunes that feel a bit
lacking. The hardest part for most listeners will be not to reminisce
too much about the sound of Soundgarden when listening to Carry On. There
was a very unique quality about Soundgarden and some early Audioslave
that just outmatches Cornell’s latest material. While there are those
who adore anything Cornell performs, there is still something missing
on the latest record. There’s nothing wrong with going in another musical
direction by any means, but the songs just don’t feel as memorable as
his earlier work.
- Ultimate
Guitar team review
Let's get one thing out of the way to begin with.
If you've come tomeet this album with a certain bias toward Soundgarden
or a certain bias toward Audioslave, then shed it and come clean.
You have to remember that Chris Cornell is his own
person, and fair enough will always be bringing things to his table that
will be partially derivative of his old bands, but let's also remind ourselves
that Chris Cornell wasn't the lead guitarist in Soundgarden.
The whole album exudes that sense of a musical vision
in its wholly initial stages - you know, those moments where you think
"Oh! And then we could do this!", and the brilliant thing is that it has
been followed through for the whole album, and hasn't fizzled out to the
over-produced and perfectionist attitudes of good ideas like these or
just ended up turning out shit.
The album covers an amazing amound of ground, from
seriously blazing 'bang your head, motherfucker' riffage, to a gritty,
jazz/garage-rock-ballad cover of Michael Jackson's Billie Jean.
Aside from his obvious vocal talents, his riff-writing
and chord progressions are something of wonder (whether or not he actually
wrote them), and keep a listener guessing by making connections and movements
that are completely altered as to the expected movement.
Overall, the album hits a home run of pretty much
every criteria - and engineering is fairly progressive, with the mixing
and production stepping into refreshingly new territory at times - but
the standout is definitely Chris Cornell's lyricism, concocting tales
of sincerely forgotten souls and underhandedly spiked burns, just as in
She'll Never Be Your Man. "She can be your friend/She can be your vision
of a mother...but she'll never be your man".
Carry On is in a league of its own, and is the absolute
perfect vehicle for Chris Cornell to advocate and carry his individual
musical vision outward, away from his weighted past commitments.
- Atticus Bastow, Inpress, Melbourne
A NEW CHRIS POSE: By
now, bringing up Chris Cornell should require a background primer of just
two words: Soundgarden and Audioslave. Now divested of the latter, Mr.
Cornell is fully his own artist for the second time after fronting a popular
band. The first attempt, 1999's post-Soundgarden release Euphoria Morning,
was a quivering flop. Does Carry On defy its title and prove a better
solo springboard?
CARRYING THE LOAD: Oh, yes. The first single and track,
"No Such Thing," is easily the hardest rocker, but the Caribbean tinge
of its guitar during the verses hints at the obvious reverence for heartland
jazz, acoustic blues and roots rock that Mr. Cornell has learned how to
channel. With an award-class production job by Steve Lillywhite (U2, Dave
Matthews Band), Carry On's organic content consistently soothes and enthuses
beyond Mr. Cornell's still-prodigal vocals. His instincts are assured
and entertaining, from the high-revving harmonics of "Poison Eye" and
the upright-bass- and horn-assisted gospel cheering on "Safe and Sound"
to the underwater slides of "Scar on the Sky" and even on iffy cuts such
as "Finally Forever," which resembles Michael Bolton warming up to cover
"Black Hole Sun" in places. But perhaps the best example is a cover of
Michael Jackson's "Billie Jean," which is chopped and screwed into a ghostly
ballad straight out of a rain-sopped spaghetti Western's dénouement.
BOTTOM LINE: Bluesy, passionate and remarkably sweeping,
Carry On makes Euphoria Morning seem like a pre-pro demo. Few of its doleful
and restrained songs will be hits, but as a unit, this is a watershed
work for one of this generation's most hallowed rock voices.
Grade: B+
- Mike Daniel, Dallas
Morning News
Who does Chris Cornell think he is? Does he even know?
When listening to his new solo album, any sense of Cornell's personal
identity is lost. He's arguably the best pure vocalist from the grunge-era
bands, and this album definitely showcases that, but it's really hard
to care.
The first time through, it all sounds great. There's
a nice surprise with a cover of Michael Jackson's "Billie Jean" and the
inclusion of his Casino Royale number, "You Know My Name," but nothing
else stands out.
Listening to it again, the questions about Cornell's
identity as a solo act return. At times he sounds like Bowie did on Heathen,
and at others he sounds like...Michael Bolton. As a result, every track
is akin to a cover song. (Speaking of covers, doesn't this one look familiar?)
The rest of the liner notes crib designs from various periods of music
history, only furthering the confusion.
We may remember your name, but the rest of your album
is very forgettable.
- T.J. TRANCHELL, Seattle
Weekly
After six years and three albums with Audioslave,
the former vocalist of Soundgarden releases his second solo effort, following
1999’s ‘Euphoria Morning’. Having officially called it quits with the
‘Cochise’ band (the remaining members have reformed Rage Against The Machine
with Zack de la Rocha), Chris Cornell’s profile has been heightened by
his selection to provide the theme tune to the 2006 James Bond movie,
‘Casino Royale’.
Even from opening track ‘No Such Thing’ it is easy
to hear why Cornell has decided to pursue a solo career, with a heavy
metal riff being mixed with a Latino-style acoustic guitar to give more
variation than it possible to imagine Audioslave utilising. Indeed, what
follows displays an appreciation for many genres, with ‘Poison Eye’ edging
toward funk (and featuring a jagged solo that could have come from Tom
Morello), ‘Safe And Sound’ leaning toward blues and ‘Finally Forever’
having a folk vibe. Less experimental is ‘Your Soul Today’ which romps
along in classic rock style and ‘She’ll Never Be Your Man’, which has
a power chord-charged chorus and a fantastically twisted solo which unfortunately
ends too soon.
Two songs stand out from the rest on ‘Carry On’, not
because the others are bad, but because the duo is stunning. ‘Arms Around
The World’ is a mellow track with some wonderful guitar melodies that
back a fantastic vocal performance – it’s easy to appreciate why it was
selected to be a single. The other track is one that is often the best
of the 1980’s, Michael Jackson’s ‘Billie Jean’. Wisely a reworking as
opposed to a simple cover, Chris Cornell turns it into a sombre, acoustic
tune that taps into the mournful nature of the lyrics. With more emotion
than the original ever possessed, it is certainly worth hearing, even
if it will never be as popular as the original. It is a measure of the
man’s talent and confidence to successfully take a legendary song in a
completely new direction and backs up his decision to go it alone.
- Alex Lai, ContactMusic.com
All metal singers should age as gracefully as Chris
Cornell. The former frontman for Seattle grunge band Soundgarden is a
few years north of 40, and rather than exult in rock-and-roll's promise
of eternal youth, he imbues his songs with a welcome note of restraint.
That's not to say that the man who once opened for
Danzig on tour has gone soft. A few of the songs on Mr. Cornell's second
solo album snarl and fume as much as anything on the mega-selling Soundgarden
album "Superunknown."
More than anything, "Carry On" is a showcase for Mr.
Cornell's prodigious, agile voice. It is the lead instrument on every
track. He combines astonishing range with rich timbre that he can vary
on the fly. On the soulful "Safe and Sound," Mr. Cornell plays off the
guitar with a touch of ragged tremolo, rising octaves above the melody
to hit high notes here and there. On the opening track "No Such Thing,"
he accentuates the driving metal chords and agitated guitar fills with
a loud, smooth vocal line.
"You Know my Name" was the signature song for the
most recent James Bond film, "Casino Royale." Lyrically, Mr. Cornell offers
exactly the mixture of earnestness and camp that the aging film franchise
demands, opening with a typical Bondian non sequitur: "If you take a life,
do you know what you give? Odds are you won't like what it is when the
storm arrives."
He gives a gritty, understated vocal performance that
meshes well with the hyper-driving drum line. His voice is perfectly suited
to the demands of the Bond song, able to rise and fall effortlessly; to
snarl at one moment and purr the next.
Mr. Cornell brings a weird intensity to his cover
of Michael Jackson's "Billie Jean." Slowing the song down to half-time,
Mr. Cornell assays the hit rhythm and blues number with the kind of manic
passion that Eric Burden brought to "House of the Rising Sun." The arrangement
is quite beautiful, with stray acoustic bass notes creeping out mid-measure,
against an eerie whistle of synth and a gently plucked guitar, all building
to a rumbling, raucous chorus. The tone and mood of the songs range from
the arena rockish "Poison Eye" to the plaintive, twangy "Finally Forever"
to the alterna-pop of "She'll Never be Your Man." Despite the varied genres
and changing instrumentation, "Carry On" has a singular feel, thanks to
the constant presence of Mr. Cornell's durable singing voice.
- Washington
Times
Chris Cornell: Carry On
Second solo album from ex-Soundgarden/Audioslave
singer and 007 hitmaker
Post-grunge supergroup Audioslave was a marketing
department's dream - the voice of Soundgarden backed by the musicians
from Rage Against The Machine - that ultimately proved anti-climactic.
Now that Tom Morello, Tim Commerford and Brad Wilk
have been reunited with RATM's firebrand frontman Zack de la Rocha, Cornell
has found a hype-free context for his impressively manly pipes.
Produced by Steve Lillywhite and featuring late period
Captain Beefheart guitarist Gary Lucas (albeit in AOR mode), Carry On
is a livelier set than 1999's Euphoria Morning. Sprightly radio rocker
No Such Thing and the sweetly melodic Arms Around Your Love should follow
Casino Royale theme You Know My Name into the charts, even without the
Bond factor.
Points deducted, though, for the lumbering cover of
Billie Jean.
3 stars out of 5
- Manish Agarwal, Mojo
This is the second solo album from Chris Cornell,
formally of Soundgarden and Audioslave. Cornell announced his decision
to leave Audioslave back in February and has since sung the theme tune
for Bond film Casino Royale and written this album.
Carry On is actually a confused album, there are songs
that could be from any of Cornell's previous bands and range from sweet
and soulful to dirty and grungy.
It's a collection which manages to be both catchy
and dreary at the same time. It can go from rocky with a hint of country,
to retro with a hint of folk, particularly in tracks like Your Soul Today
and Today.
Standout tracks include current single Arms Around
Your Love, Safe And Sound and even a cover version of Michael Jackson's
Billie Jean.
Carry On is occasionally good, sometimes bad, but
mostly just plain average.
Cornell seems to have lost his rage and his enthusiasm
for making good rock songs and appears happy just to be making music.
If you're a fan of Chris Cornell you'll enjoy it,
if you're a fan of either Soundgarden or Audioslave, avoid it.
BR, Redditch
Advertiser
Chris Cornell may have never become the rock god some
predicted, but to assert him as anything short of one of the great American
rock vocalists of our time is sacrilege. Equipped with the similar larger
than life range of David Lee Roth, accompanied with the same embittered
soul of Eddie Vedder, Cornell always finds a way to carry on, tackling
music the best way he knows how--his way.
Some are writing off Carry On, the Soundgarden and
Audioslave frontman’s second solo effort since 1999’s sexily titled Euphoria
Morning, as a misfire of rock, fused with blues, fused with soul. While
this may not be an album of jaw-dropping brilliance, it’s a positive step
for an artist who has a lot to say and invites us along for the ride as
he searches for his best way of saying it.
The curtain opens with “No Such Thing,” a track that
feels as though it could have appeared on an Audioslave record. Its heavy
riffs and blazing vocals are reminiscent of “Show Me How To Live,” and
it exists here as the lone rock heavy melody.
“Poison Eye” doesn’t sound so catchy on the first
listen, until you find yourself humming it minutes later. This could very
well mean the album should be listened to more than once. Patience is
always the key, folks.
Cornell nuzzles us into his spiritual side, a side
he shows on a few of these songs, on “Safe And Sound”: “Think of a time
when a morning will come and you will wake up without the feeling half
the world has gone insane/I’ve never seen but I believe in a promised
land.” This is the best track on the album, a true testament of his lyrical
and vocal graces.
Cornell’s spiritual ponderings continue in impeccable
fashion with “You Know My Name,” an affronted reflection on murder. “If
you take a life/Do you know what you’ll give?/Odds are you won’t like
what it is/I’ve seen angels fall from blinding heights/but you yourself
are nothing so divine/Just next in line.”
Not to be outdone, “Silence The Voices” adds a sharp,
raw edge to the ever persisting theme: “Where are the songs from the sane
minds?/And where are the words from the sound mouths?/I can’t understand
how they silence the voices.” This certifies Carry On as a relevant album
of rock and soul caliber.
Carry On does, however, offer a minor assortment of
filler songs, such as the quirky “She’ll Never Be Your Man” (in love with
a tranny?), “Disappearing Act,” “Finally Forever” and “Scar On The Sky.”
But the missteps can be forgiven due to the majority of correct steps
taken.
Apart from future reunions with Soundgarden and Audioslave,
all that can be requested of Cornell is that for his next solo piece,
he should try and refine it into a more steadfast, solid ensemble of tunes.
His voice has always been more suited for pure rock anyway, yet his propensity
toward the soulful is welcome. Carry On, while not a perfect release,
further establishes him as a man of unique talent and fury.
- Brendan Butler, CB
Music
Post-Audioslave, Cornell offers a wobbly mish-mash
that ranges from Billie Jean to Nashville-pop.
Yet when he clicks on rockers like Poison Eye or the
syncopated funk of She'll Never Be Your Man, his emotion-packed vocals
still shine.
Download: She'll Never Be Your Man
Rating: 2 1/2
- By Dan Aquilante, New York Post
My best friend Patrick, the one who lives in Seattle
– where I hope Chris Cornell's name is commonly exalted in pubs and clubs
– is the only other person I know who has listened to the only other album
to sport the mighty vocalist's name on its cover, "Euphoria Morning."
I sometimes wonder just how many people at Interscope ever heard it. It
came out eight years ago now, while Cornell was searching for a way to
build a solo career in the wake of Soundgarden's lamentable but apparently
necessarily demise. But nobody was really buying it – the album or the
idea of Cornell being his own rock entity, especially one who (on that
album, anyway) sounded so slick, the way Garbage-y rock kinda sounded
back in '99.
How little did the disc get noticed? I remember seeing
Cornell at the Fonda when it came out, when the Fonda still had seats
and was showing a staging of "Hedwig and the Angry Inch" from time to
time. And there were enough empty seats for me to have had every member
of my extended family (and Patrick's) alongside me.
Naturally, Patrick (who at this point may rank a tie
with Paul Rodgers as his most favorite vocalist) and I cherish "Euphoria
Morning," which sports some of Cornell's most instantly listenable songs:
"Can't Change Me," "Follow My Way," "Wave Goodbye," the bluesy build of
"When I'm Down." It's an album well worth digging up, in light of Cornell's
return with the simply titled "Carry On." Carry on indeed – this solid
hodgepodge not only picks up where he melodically (if not lyrically) left
off with Audioslave, it also takes him back to the mainstream-ready approachability
(not entirely a bad thing) he set out to achieve with "Euphoria." It doesn't
end with his recent James Bond theme for nothing.
It also isn't as light as its solo predecessor; he
didn't spend all that time with Audioslave for nothing, either. And he
comes out hitting hard, with "No Such Thing," which gallops on an STP-infused
riff but leaves spaces to dynamically duck into passages straight out
of Bowie in the '70s. He also lets you know heavy isn't just for sprinkling:
"Poison Eye" may sound a bit like Van Hagar crossed with Gang of Four,
which just fits uncomfortably together, but it never stops rocking.
Nor does a bold but ill-advised remake of "Billie
Jean" – yes, that "Billie Jean." Overhauling it into a slow waltz might
have worked if Jeff Buckley were alive to give it passion in the proper
register. Cornell's roar tends to obliterate the song; at times it's so
hyper-strained I almost start laughing. But at least it's got bite, thanks
in part to a beefy four-man band featuring guitarists Gary Lucas (who
worked with Buckley) and Cameron Greider.
Yet what really makes "Carry On" worth hearing – more
tenderly rendered pieces like "Safe and Sound" (like Amos Lee joining
early Aerosmith) and "Killing Birds" (with traces of the Postal Service)
and "Hover" (sweet psychedelia at sundown) – is precisely what may sink
it with some people. That's a doubly sad possibility given the quickness
to dismiss Cornell in the mad excitement surrounding Rage Against the
Machine's return. Cornell deserves better than to be treated like a footnote,
and though Audioslave was never the cherry bomb that Rage will apparently
always be, its three albums will come to stand among the better hard-rock
fare this decade produced.
If nothing else, Cornell's contribution should be
valued as a means to hold the skeleton of Rage in place while its flesh
fell away. He was a part-time savior, and with luck he benefited, too:
If there were any justice, a whole new segment of younger fans that only
discovered him with Audioslave will now be game to hear him wail romantically
and self-reflectively on detours like "Your Soul Today" and "Finally Forever."
You'd think, in a year in which Daughtry is the biggest
seller, that an originator like Cornell would get his due. But I get the
feeling, Patrick, that this one just won't seem cool enough, or maybe
it'll leave 'em too divided – too hard in spots for some, too soft in
others for, uh, others. You and I are gonna be the only ones fanning this
one's flame for a while, I bet. I'll start spreading the word down here.
Grade: B
- Ben Wener, Orange
County Register
Ex-guitar and lead singer of Soundgarden, Chris
Cornell’s second solo album, Carry On, is a look inside this inscrutable
artist who has gone through several life changes since Soundgarden split
up in 1997.
Carry On is R&B, blues and rock all rolled into one
superb package. Yet, Cornell’s voice still has its haunting melody that
keeps fans clamoring for more.
On “No Such Thing,” there is fast guitar work from
Cornell, Gary Lucas, Brian Ray, Cameron Greider and Dimitri Coats, and
pounding drum play from Nir Z. Cornell emotes on how certain aspects of
life just don’t exist and how he has tried to shield himself from the
fallout, with such lines as, “It was beautiful, but the rain set in and
ruined it all. Then I tried to be invisible but it was impossible even
for me.” His voice has a hidden pain that will hit listeners’ way down
deep.
“Poison Eye” has a profound rock feel to it
as Cornell talks about seeing things in a distorted way, with such lines
as, “I saw the light. I heard you singing, I know the song. It’s my turn
to write, I put this hook inside…I got the radar and I can see so far
with my poison eye.”
With “Arms Around Your Love,” there is keyboard work
from Jamie Muhoberac, along with slower guitar work by Cornell, Lucas,
Ray, Greider and Coats. Cornell muses about a relationship that doesn’t
sound healthy, with such lines as, “With his arms around your love oh
no here comes the pain that you can’t ignore…He’ll do all of the things…You
had every chance but you closed the door, now you’re just gonna have to
take it. Cuz he’s gonna make you pay for it. You’re just gonna have to
take it with his arms around your love.” Cornell’s hypnotic timbre is
seductive as he croons about love that can strangle you.
“Billie Jean” is of course Cornell’s twist
on the Michael Jackson classic. This version is much slower and more spellbinding
with Cornell’s evocative vocals and lingering guitar work by him, Lucas,
Greider, Ray and Coats. The danceable nature of this song invoked by Jackson
is turned on its ear by Cornell who gives the song a creepy vibe.
Carry On, from Chris Cornell, is an album filled with
unforgettable songs and introspective lyrics from an artist whose voice
will touch and sear listeners’ souls.
8.5 out of 10
- Sari N. Kent, Celebrity
Cafe.com
Few will refute the simple exclamation that Chris
Cornell has one of the most intense and recognizable voices in all of
rock music, at least during the past two decades. He's also been one of
the most prolific songsmiths, first with Soundgarden, then Temple of the
Dog, and most recently Audioslave. He's gone from underground legend (Soundgarden)
and cult hero (Temple) to arena rock superstar (later SG and Audioslave)
and he even managed to toss off a solo album in the midst of all that.
After his recent departure from Audioslave and the
high profile (though ultimately lackluster) title song for Casino Royale,
it should come as no surprise that Mr. Cornell would dip back into the
solo pool. This time around sounding a lot less like his early career
comparisons to Robert Plant and more like a gentler voiced Ozzy, Cornell
delivers up an extremely mixed platter of rock ambiguity.
It's not that Carry On is crappy, it's just that the
musicality shifting, lurching, and rolling behind Cornell's patented vocal
careen isn't particularly spectacular. Actually it's more schizophrenic
or perhaps more accurately it's suffering from a serious case of sonic
personality disorder. On the one hand Cornell's band of the moment dishes
out pretty standard, paint-by-numbers barroom-turned-arena rock. A lot
of it ripples with after effects of late '80s LA metal crossed with a
much slicker and less jammy interpretation of Southern Rock thematics.
On the other hand it seems to shift without a moment's notice from style
to style, often multiple times in a single song and every so often in
a single measure. The end result is that Cornell's steady, confident vocals
lose their foothold on the loose gravel music beds. Some might applaud
such diversity, but in the end it merely serves to create a less streamlined
listening experience.
"No Such Thing" kicks down the gates with crunching
guitar amplitude that is a cross-breed of Soundgarden and Audioslave,
then it morphs unexpectedly into a light samba shuffle of acoustic guitar
over which Cornell croons. WTF? Just as you settle into the mellowness
the chorus kicks in like some forgotten Ozzy refrain. Each element is
captivating, to be true, but smashed together they are just a bit to disparate
to actually create a cohesive vision.
Meanwhile "Poison Eye" brings the rage and skirl and
sounds not unlike some of the final days music of SG. But ultimately it
sounds a bit off, like it's missing that extra je ne sais quoi, you know?
Meanwhile "Arms Around Your Love" is a maudlin (for Cornell) song that
has a chorus which sounds suspiciously like something Third Eye Blind
would whip out on one of their numerous hits. Then it's into contemporary
pop terrain, complete with lilting moments of Al Green falsetto on "Safe
and Sound," a track that sounds nothing like Chris Cornell (i.e. if you
weren't aware it was him you'd never guess it was). It's strangely compelling,
but also soft. Granted even the hardest of rockers have a hidden mellow
side, but this is bordering on Rob Thomas meets vintage R&B territory.
By far and large "She'll Never Be Your Man" is the
strangest tune on the album, lyrically speaking. If I didn't know better
it almost sounds like Cornell is outing himself. Or maybe I'm reading
too much into lines like "she can be your lover/she can be your friend/she
can be your vision of your mother, like the one you never had/she will
know your troubles better than I can/but she'll never be your man…" Of
course it could just be an Iron John/male bonding/Budweiser drinking/pool
playing ode. I'll leave the interpretation up to others at hand.
Raggedly twangy and rusted guitar leads into the shimmering
acoustic sheen of "Ghosts," yet another track showcasing the more tender
side of Cornell. When he ain't growling and yelping he actually has a
pretty beautiful voice, but it's at such odds with his created persona
of the raging, howling frontman that it takes some getting used to. That
and the fact that the musical backdrop isn't anything that stands out
from the rest of the pack of mature crooners (Rob Thomas, John Mayer,
and the like) out there today. As much as it sounds like I'm hating on
this track, the more you listen to it, the more it will grow on you, mostly
because Cornell and the music actually mesh. It's the most consistent
track on the album, for better or worse.
The album's real kicker, though, is "Killing Birds."
Starting out with snippeted synth syncopation it allows Cornell's penetrating
voice to command the track. Lyrically, it's on par with the rest of the
album, delivering words that yearn for further dissection, unless of course
you absolutely know what "as I'm standing here right in front of you killing
birds" means. I certainly don't, but the combination of the liltingly
scratching music and Cornell's impassioned plea make for a hypnotic blend.
The album's genuine head cracker, at least in terms
of source material, sheds its skin in the form of a Michael Jackson cover.
"Billie Jean" as read by Cornell becomes a dusted lament, a sad song of
desperation and post-modern country melancholy. Jacko and Cornell make
strange bedfellows, that's for sure, but kudos to CC for actually taking
a much beloved hit and turning it into his own emotionally wracked masterpiece
of slow burning turpitude.
"Hover" [he means "Scar On the Sky" - webmaster]
is another quiet number that reverberates with strange, grating country
mannerisms. Cornell's voice more or less does what the title suggests,
hovering beautifully over the fairly standard slow crawl barroom backing.
Yet as streamlined as the two are it's ultimately forgettable. In fact
that's a major flaw in much of the music on this endeavor: it's strong
and aggressive as well as sweet and emotional, but it's fleeting and fades
quickly from memory. The melodies and grooves are there, delivered with
competence, but lacking that extra special sauce that makes music memorable
and perversely invasive.
A slightly funky, crunching boogie-woogie slant is
instilled on "Your Soul Today," the guitars cranking and slinking with
blues intoned wrangle. It's Cornell and company's version of mutant blues
and it almost works, though the chorus, which kicks back into mock country
terrain seems to be pushing and pulling against the rest of the track
itself. It's only when Cornell delivers angst dripping reiterations of
the title "your soul today…" that the song captures the majesty it was
striving for.
Mellowness returns on "Finally Forever," another slow
jam in which the smoother side of Cornell again rears its sleepy head.
The steel guitar wavering throughout the track bears slight shades of
"Blackhole Sun," lending the track a clouded sense of déjà vu. Again,
Cornell's vocals mesh brilliantly with the music, but neither has that
special something to make it a bona fide classic. There's an overwhelming
desire of torch song malevolence and grandiose posturing on "Silence,"
which features a militaristic snare cadence and an epic stance that's
slightly over-the-top. It actually feels epic for epic's sake, if that
makes sense at all. It also feels out of time and space, something that
might have worked better three decades in the past as opposed to the here
and now. Yet just like "Ghosts" it has a hypnotic refrain that works its
way under your skin no matter how cheesy your cerebellum tells you it
is.
The album wraps up with the acoustic "Disappearing
Act," a wonderfully nondescript slice of Cornell crooning with passion
over guitar, tambourine, and cello. Then there's the final swan song,
"You Know My Name," a track most will recall as being the theme song to
Casino Royale. As with many of the more recent Bond themes, it's fairly
forgettable. Also, one has to wonder why Cornell included it here. For
an artist as prolific as he is one would have figured he'd have other
tracks he could have slipped onto the disc rather than re-hashing one
that was sold as a single back at the tail end of 2006.
Carry On is a confusing collection of songs that never
really seem to gel together as a singular whole. The album never actually
feels like an album, yet it contains a few stellar moments of passion
and fire that solidify Cornell's place in rock history. Yet these moments
are few and far between and even at their brightest they fail to live
up to his Soundgarden and Temple of the Dog legacies, falling more in
line with the work he did with Audioslave: it's decent but not epic by
a long shot. With Carry On Cornell seems to be somewhat aimless, searching
for his voice and style like a lost sonic wanderer; this is a journeyman
album where a gifted tradesman is trying to pinpoint the perfect intersection
of art and emotion that will bring his talents to the forefront and make
the most of them. This is an album that you desperately wish to love from
start to finish, yet every time you stumble upon a little element that
you adore there's another element that you'll despise. This push/pull,
heaven/hell, good/bad struggle lingers throughout the 14 tracks and in
the end creates a sonic experience that is more exasperating than exhilarating.
7.2 out of 10
- Spence D., IGN.com
Much like Audioslave’s three forgettable releases,
Chris Cornell’s second solo album starts off by completely misleading
the listener. Its conceit is that the singer has finally heard a copy
of Badmotorfinger after all these years and has gone back to writing the
riffs and wails that made him famous.
After "Arms Around," the third track and first of
many, many ballads, you realize that this just isn't the case. The sad
truth is that the Corn is in his forties now, and he’s making the kind
of mellowed-out music you’d expect a guy his age to make. It’s still a
few steps above the dreck that guys like Rob Thomas spew out, but each
song follows the grandiose easy-listening style of last year’s James Bond
theme, "You Know My Name," which is also included here.
After hearing the truly baffling cover of Michael
Jackson’s "Billie Jean," you'll realize Cornell’s moved on from his past,
and maybe you should too.
- Shehzaad Jiwani, Chart
Attack
It's been 10 years since the breakup of Soundgarden,
an iconic Seattle band of the grunge era that reached its zenith with
"Superunknown," an album that sold more than 3 million copies and earned
the group two Grammy Awards.
With a powerful voice that is part banshee wail and
part raspy, soulful croon, lead singer Chris Cornell used his rock star
credentials to launch all-star band Audioslave, which he walked away from
earlier this year. Cornell's new solo album, "Carry On," provides a foundation
for a solo career that failed to materialize with his 1999 solo debut,
"Euphoria Morning."
Produced by Steve Lillywhite (who has worked with
the Rolling Stones, Dave Matthews Band and U2, among others), "Carry On"
is an impressive, if uneven, collection of soulful, sometimes bluesy rockers
that demonstrates Cornell's willingness to experiment.
"No Such Thing," the first single, opens with somber
soulfulness before exploding into a full-throttle, guitar-crunching song
that should please longtime Soundgarden fans. The song's range of emotions,
styles and tempos is representative of a collection of songs exploring
varied themes such as heartbreak, redemption and world peace.
Among the more interesting tracks is Cornell's subdued
version of Michael Jackson's dance-floor anthem, "Billie Jean." The 1980s
classic comes across as a dark, lugubrious tale of troubled romance.
"She'll Never Be Your Man" is tinged with R&B influences,
and "Scar on the Sky" has an unexpected country flavor. "Disappearing
Act," originally an acoustic song that played during the credits of the
horror movie "Bug," receives the full-band treatment on "Carry On." The
album closes with "You Know My Name," the song Cornell wrote and recorded
with composer David Arnold for the James Bond movie "Casino Royale." But
it lacks punch and makes for a tepid final track.
DOWNLOAD: "Silence the Voices"
-- Gene Stout, Seattle
Post-Intelligencer
Context does make the rock star. In Soundgarden, Chris
Cornell was a '90s rock god of wailing, grungy heaviosity, equal parts
punk and Zeppelin. With Audioslave, he led the remnants of Rage Against
the Machine for three albums marked more by dependable hard-rock craftsmanship
than real inspiration. All by himself, and on his second solo album (in
stores today), Cornell is neither, turning down the volume just enough
to find a comfort zone of melody and bristling emotion.
More crooner than shouter now, Cornell can still
uncork a raging vocal when the mood is right, but that isn't often. He
sets a high standard with the album's opening track, "No Such Thing,"
erupting with furious electric guitar before slipping into a solemn, romantic
vocal melody that is blatantly McCartney-esque and a long, long way from
"Black Hole Sun." Later, "Safe and Sound" is the kind of manly, soulful
ballad Clapton traded in during the mid-'70s, a sound hinting of romantic
loss and desperation. There's also a bit of James Bond melodrama on "You
Know My Name," recorded originally for the soundtrack of "Casino Royale"
with film composer David Arnold.
Not everything here is so fully formed or satisfying.
"Poison Eye" begins with a nice Stonesy riff and then goes nowhere. But
a grim, spooky take on Michael Jackson's "Billie Jean" is amusing enough,
even if it sounds a lot more like Metallica's "Nothing Else Matters."
Jacko's mega hit survives the stunt translation. So does Cornell, his
days as a righteous hard-rocker may be behind him now, but he remains
a singer searing and distinctive, once more feeling his way into a new
sound and setting.
2.5 out of 4 stars
— Steve Appleford, Los
Angeles Times
Soundgarden fell apart, and Audioslave crumbled under
creative differences, so it's fitting that Chris Cornell's long overdue
second solo disc is entitled ''Carry On.''
The enigmatic singer-songwriter's first solo effort,
1999's experimental ''Euphoria Morning,'' was celebrated by critics and
won him a Grammy, but fans didn't appreciate that it sounded nothing like
Soundgarden.
As before, those who disregard his past will see
Cornell's latest introspective adventure for the joyously eclectic journey
it is.
He brings a light touch but loses none of his intensity,
and the disc does rock hard in several places - the versatile ''No Such
Thing,'' ''Poison Eye'' and a fantastic ''Your Soul Today'' will please
even the harshest critic.
However, he shines brightest on the low-key, personal
moments, particularly the bluesy lament ''Safe and Sound'' and colorful
acoustic tracks like ''Ghosts,'' ''Finally Forever'' and ''Disappearing
Act.''
Cornell's most powerful instrument remains his voice
- passionate and commanding but also soft and emotive. His grinding cover
of Michael Jackson's ''Billie Jean'' would have seemed an amusing aside
in lesser hands, but is sung with such straight-faced conviction it's
oddly contagious.
''Carry On'' proves Chris Cornell remains a vital
voice. Let's hope he stays on his own for a few more creative outbursts.
CHECK THIS OUT: For a taste of Cornell's softer side
look no further than the lush ''Arms Around Your Love,'' with a slick
and minimal guitar lead which floats over one of the catchiest hooks he's
ever written.
By JOHN KOSIK, Associated
Press Writer
The cover art on Cornell's second solo album suggests
a folk record from the early '60s (and the title suggests a Kansas cover
lurking about somewhere).
But the music inside is strictly crunchy, dare-we-say-grungy
rock straight out of the '90s Cornell helped shape with Soundgarden. "Ghosts"
sports a nostalgically Seattle-ish minor-chord riff and appropriately
soaring chorus; "No Such Thing" out-Velvet Revolvers Scott Weiland; and
meaty-sounding ballads "Disappearing Act" and "Silence" end the record
in unusually strong fashion.
Elsewhere, the headline-grabbing cover of "Billie
Jean" is well-intentioned but still a little silly, although it boasts
a crazy, Eddie Van Halen-sounding solo.
The best thing here is "You Know My Name" from last
fall's "Casino Royale," but that makes sense: This is some of Cornell's
most uncomplicated and accessible music to date.
—Jeff Vrabel, Billboard
Apparently, Chris Cornell spent his grunge glory days
wishing that her were in Stone Temple Pilots.
On his second solo outing, the former Soundgarden
and Audioslave frontman dresses down the faux-Zeppelin balladry of 1999's
Euphoria Morning with heaps of fuzz and cock-rock posturing that
suspiciously recall a certain much-maligned San Diego quartet.
The opener sounds like a rip of radio smash "Sex Type
Thing" and is even called "No Such Thing". Maybe this is what living in
France does to you.
- Kyle Anderson, Spin (thanks JoAnne)
Former Soundgarden and Audioslave frontman Chris Cornell
steps into the solo spotlight with his second solo album Carry On. Cornell's
debut album Euphoria Morning was released in 1999 and despite garnering
critical acclaim wasn't a huge commercial success. It should be different
this time around as Carry On comes hot on the heels of Cornell's smash-hit
Bond theme You Know My Name, which is included on the album.
Carry On is a pretty lengthy album, coming in at 16
tracks long. Across the 16 tracks, Cornell gets the chance to showcase
the different sides to his personality and music as well as hint at the
direction he may follow on his solo path. It's to his credit that Cornell
has decided to take a varied approach to his solo work and take a few
chances
. The first thing you always notice about Cornell
is his incredible voice. There is no other singer out there like him and
his voice is so distinctive it actually sends shivers down your spine.
His voice gets a good work out on Carry On. Opening track No Such Thing
is one of the heavier songs on the album and allows Cornell to let rip
in his usual way. Throughout the rest of the album he gets to show he
is capable of a more restrained and melodic vocal.
Carry On touches upon a variety of musical genres.
Arms Around Your Love is a mainstream pop song, Safe and Sound has a bluesy
sound to it and Scar On The Sky has a hint of country in the mix. Those
who hoped, or expected, Cornell to stick to the heavier rock material
he usually performs may be disappointed. The rest of us will relish hearing
one of the world's best male vocalists turning his hand to every style
of music he can.
The oddest, but not altogether unpleasant, moment
on the album is Cornell's cover of the Michael Jackson clasic Billie Jean.
He strips the song away from it's R&B pop roots and reimagines it as a
gently building guitar ballad. It's an interesting interpretation and
bound to upset the many MJ fans out there but it's a pretty damn good
cover.
Highlights on the set include Casino Royale theme
You Know My Name, the beautifully haunting Disappearing Act and the punchy
acoustic number Today which features a falsetto vocal from Cornell.
Carry On is a new start for Cornell. He has moved
away from the dark, moody material of his solo debut and progresses from
the all-out rock of his previous bands. He emerges from Carry On as an
impressive songwriter and a promising solo artist. I for one can't wait
to see him tour the album.
- Philip Ellwood, Entertainment
Focus UK
Chris Cornell is gifted. Soundgarden declared this.
Countless collaborations and songwriting credits confirmed it. Audioslave
may have forced some to question Cornell's taste--but never his skills.
Carry On carries Cornell's weathered croon and sphere-scraping
falsettos on to even firmer grounds--though his taste is still in question.
"Disappearing Act" invokes the spirit of fallen friend
Jeff Buckley as it swells from humble acoustics to symphony-backed anthem.
"No Such Thing" is an honest rock jam that'll dust off many a Temple of
the Dog record.
But then comes a cover of Michael Jackson's "Billie
Jean." Why?
Three out of five stars
- Dan Fletcher, The
Daily Utah Chronicle
Chris Cornell's first solo album Euphoria Morning
was released just after Cornell had shaken the shackles of Soundgarden
and he was making a definitive break from their heavy heavy sound by indulging
in bucolic singer/songwriter clichés.
It went nowhere commercially but led him toward Audioslave,
where he spent three albums pushing and pulling against the core of Rage
Against the Machine.
If Euphoria Morning was breaking from the past, Carry
On is about reconnecting to it, returning Cornell to music that feels
more comfortable than Tom Morello's staccato riffs. Right from the beginning,
he pushes out arena-filling riffs that feel more at home on a Soundgarden
record -- not as heavy and certainly not as tortured, but something more
mature and more recognizably of Cornell's lineage than much of Audioslave.
It sets the stage for a record that's seems like a
rare hard rock maturation, but soon Cornell returns to the singer/songwriter
mannerisms that seemed appropriate on his first debut -- he was stretching
his legs after Soundgarden, after all -- but now feel anemic, particularly
because they're executed with quivering sensitivity and a near belligerent
tunelessness.
These are the songs that feel forced -- as affected
as his coffeehouse cover of "Billie Jean" -- but when Cornell loosens
up and gives the music backbone (and a backbeat), he not only comes alive
as a performer but the writing is sharper and better, pointing a way toward
an artistic middle age that's richer and more compelling than what's heard
on the bulk of Carry On.
- Stephen Thomas Erlewine, AllMusic
Guide
Carry On offers one brief flash of the old roar from
the singer's Soundgarden days, then lowers the volume for the rest of
the ride.
For people of a certain age and era, Chris Cornell's
status is iconic: the wild-haired howler who made Soundgarden more than
a metal thing, or a grunge thing, or even just a '90s thing.
After a decent but ultimately underwhelming run with
Audioslave, that now-vintage Cornell is back on ''No Such Thing,'' the
incendiary opener of Carry On, his second solo release.
And then...it goes away again. There is nothing wrong
with a calmer, mellower Chris — after all, he's now a sober, forty-something
dad. But it's hard not to pine for the old fire.
Grade: B
- Leah Greenblatt, Entertainment
Weekly
If you're mourning the demise of Audioslave, at least
console yourself with the fact that Chris Cornell isn't. Whilen his former
bandmates revisit old times as Rage Against The Machine, Cornell moves
forward.
Carry On, his second solo album, is a peach, a rich
and vibrant collection that manages to be both powerful and soulful. There
isn't a bad song here, and there are a number that may prove to be great.
This perhaps shouldn't be a surprise; after all, Chris
Cornell isn't new to this. But these 16 tracks show that you don't have
to burn out OR fade away, and that while fashion is temporary, class is
permanent.
4 out of 5
- Ian Winwood, Kerrang
Chris Cornell's Audioslave union with Tom Morello
and Co was tenuous and occasionally fractious. Cornell is the former Soundgarden
frontman with one of the grunge era's most potent set of pipes. In recent
times, he has battled drug addiction, fallen in love and married, moved
to Paris and set up a restaurant.
That's not to say Audioslave was a total waste of
time: their three albums comprise a handful of excellent tracks (and some
flotsam, too). Fresh from that band's break up, Cornell returns with his
second solo album and it's a mixed bag.
Carry On is mostly an old-fashioned singer/songwriter-type
effort replete with earnest mid-tempo rock'n'roll introspection. The fast-paced,
hard-rocking opening salvo No Such Thing is a deceptive indicator for
the rest of the record. Actually the Morello-aping guitar programming
on the first couple of tracks only serves to remind us of Cornell's former
bandmates' musical proficiencies.
However, there are too many plodding moments. Some
mawkish lyrics are saved only by Cornell's compelling vocals. And what
of the bizarre, stripped-back cover of Michael Jackson's Billie Jean?
Like the album itself, it almost works.
3 stars out of five
- Andrew Murfett, Melbourne Age (thanks Mel)
Welcome back to another episode of the long-running
series Chris Cornell: What Happened?
Last time, we learned that it took only one Rage Against
the Machine reunion gig to turn Audioslave's whole existence into a Van
Hagar joke.
Now, we tune in to the tasteful pop songs Cornell
is singing (and of course songwriting) on Carry On. Shrieking to Kim Thayil's
guitar, Cornell was an instrument of awesome. (Listened to Superunknown
lately? Even better than you remember. "My Wave," holy crap.)
But his talent is for mindless wailing, hitting money
notes in the high-grunge style, and he has no knack at all for the subtle
sound he's trying now.
Groaning "Billie Jean" or ponderous originals like
"Scar on the Sky," he's nothing without the dumb grunge overkill he's
been trying to put behind him since Soundgarden broke up. Hair? Short.
Shirt? On. What happened?
- ROB SHEFFIELD, Rolling
Stone
2.5 stars out of 5
Chris Cornell's reputation as a rock-band front man
is a justifiably lauded one — his glassy voice helped propel both Soundgarden's
cerebral metal in the '90s and Audioslave's space-age classic-rock in
the '00s.
His initial step as a solo artist, 1999's Euphoria
Morning, didn't enjoy quite the commercial success those bands did,
though, maybe because fans weaned on his muscle-flexing felt too little
of that, and too much of the haunting atmospherics that shivered through
Soundgarden's Superunknown.
Still, while Euphoria wasn't terribly aggro,
those atmospherics were plenty pretty and the songs were plenty affecting,
given Cornell's flaming arrow of a voice.
Having recently left Audioslave, Cornell is back to
the solo-guy approach, and early tastes of his upcoming Carry On
sound like he's found a brawn-to-sensitivity balance that'll grab tighter
hold of his band-won fanbase. "She'll Never Be Your Man" is a taut but
wriggly post-grunge soul stomp, "No Such Thing" a combination molar-crunching
'90s-Seattle throwback and strummy folk-pop serenade.
—Nicole Keiper, The
Tennessean
It's becoming an all-too-familiar pattern. First,
Chris Cornell rocks out with a killer band for a few years, sells a bunch
of records and gets all the fanboys yammering about how he's the greatest
frontman in history. Then he gets tired of all that loud music. Or he
wants to prove himself as a songwriter. Or he just wants things his own
way. Or whatever -- honestly, we have no idea what he's thinking.
In any case, he leaves his successful, acclaimed rock
band to make a solo album. And it bites.
OK, maybe that's a little harsh. But let's be honest:
Cornell's second solo CD Carry On -- much like its predecessor, 1999's
Euphoria Morning -- most assuredly does not rock out.
Instead, it once again finds the gravelly Soundgarden
/ Audioslave belter foolishly ditching his sweaty leather pants and donning
a bland, ill-fitting ensemble of poppier melodies, softer rhythms and
more power ballads than a Celine Dion-Michael Bolton double bill.
Before all you fanboys start your e-mail engines,
yeah, he's still got some great pipes. But on the vast majority of these
14 samey-sounding cuts, he simply does not put them to very good use.
Unless you happen to think acoustic-guitar covers of Michael Jackson are
a swell idea, that is.
But there is good news: If Cornell stays true to form,
he'll be fronting another A-list rock band in a couple of years. And last
time we checked, Van Halen still had an opening.
No Such Thing 3:44 Cornell knows what the kids want.
So this opening single is the token rocker, with a hard-driving beat,
a chugging low-neck riff and some searing licks on the margins. But the
acoustic guitars that carry the verses should be a tip-off of what's to
come. Still, when he opens up and cuts loose on the big chorus, all is
momentarily forgiven.
Poison Eye 3:57 It doesn't rock quite as hard as No
Such Thing, but it does have a decently chunky, clanging guitar line that
leaves room for some nimble bass work. If the whole album were like this,
it would be OK. But it's not.
Arms Around Your Love 3:34 The first sign of trouble:
We're already mellowing out. Admittedly, this jangly midtempo cut isn't
quite as wimpy as its title implies -- but still, not a good sign.
Safe and Sound 4:16 This is precisely what we were
talking about -- the disc is barely 10 minutes old, and Cornell is already
into full-on power-ballad mode. The Memphis horns are a nice touch, but
the rest of this song is tailor-made for American Idol.
She'll Never be Your Man 3:24 Another mellow midtempo
groove. Another strummy acoustic guitar. And another smoky vocal. The
bluesy slide lick and gender-bending lyrics help -- but only a bit.
Ghosts 3:51 What a surprise -- it's a midtempo, acoustic-guitar
number. This one's got more of a folk-rock feel, but even so, enough already.
Our finger involuntarily twitches toward the skip button.
Killing Birds 3:38 Yet another downtempo track --
this time powered by an insistent drum machine, topped with some twangy
guitars and a tense bassline. You wait for it to explode into a big chorus
-- but it never does. "It makes no sense to me," wails Chris. Us neither,
buddy.
Billie Jean 4:41 Yes, that Billie Jean. Apparently,
Cornell thought it would be a good idea to transform Jacko's paternity-suit
pop into a smouldering acoustic-guitar waltz. He was wrong. This is just
awful.
Hover 3:40 [Webmaster's note: he means Scar On
The Sky - this was an earlier title] Again with the acoustic guitar,
the downbeat tempo and the Michael Bolton wailing. The swooping-seagull
solo keeps us briefly interested.
Your Soul Today 3:27 Hey, what's that? It's an electric
guitar -- and not a moment too soon. Cornell finally picks up the pace
with this chunky Stonesy rocker. It's no Spoonman -- but at this point,
we'll take what we can get.
Finally Forever 3:37 That bit of momentum he built
up with the last song? It's gone -- and we are back in the coffeehouse
of plodding power balladry. We would pay someone to smash that freakin'
acoustic guitar.
Silence 4:27 [Webmaster's note: he means Silence
The Voices] This is some sort of anti-war cut that starts off with
big ringing chords and some martial snares, and then gradually evolves
into yet another overblown power-ballad. Silence? We wish.
Disappearing Act 4:33 At least the acoustic guitars
are sorta bluesy and folksy on this one. We are trying to stay positive
-- but seldom have we wanted an album to end as desperately as this one.
You Know My Name 4:00 Frankly, when you resort to
tacking your six-month-old James Bond theme onto the end of your CD --
and when it's one of the three heaviest tunes on the thing -- you know
you have done something very wrong.
By Darryl Sterdan - Winnipeg
Sun/Sun Media
Back in February, Chris Cornell announced his decision
to leave Audioslave on account of ‘personality conflicts’ and ‘musical
differences’.
Three months on, he’s releasing his second solo album.
Any chance those conflicts and differences could have been down to the
rest of the band deciding not to record Chris’ songs?
A listen to Carry On would make you understand why
if it was. Let’s get one thing straight from the start: it is possibly
the most confused album you’ll come across all year.
Stuck somewhere between Cornell’s initial incarnation
in Soundgarden and a curious entry to American Idol, it is a collection
that is both catchy and dreary at the same time, shown perfectly in the
opening trio of ''No Such Thing''’s grown-up grunge, the MOR stadium rock
of ''Arms Around Your Love'', and in the middle, ''Poison Eye'''s schizophrenic
meanderings between the two.
The problem is Cornell’s voice. As distinctive as
the sound it helped invent back in the 90s, when he stretches away from
that grating grunge and rock, it shows an unexpectedly dull edge that
lacks an ability to convey emotion. It’s a nuisance that weighs down the
lumpen Bond theme, ''You Know My Name''.
Away from that, weirdness rules the roost, from a
peculiarly unsettling version of Michael Jackson’s ''Billie Jean'' to
the cover artwork, made to resemble the sleeve art of the likes of Miles
Davis and Marvin Gaye.
If that weren’t enough, there’s a frankly disturbing
ditty about your missus running off with another woman called '‘She’ll
Never Be Your Man'’. Anyone who doesn’t shudder at lines like 'she can
be your vision of a mother, like the one you never had' needs as much
therapy as Cornell appears to himself.
And yet, when the last bars of the soft rock ballad
finale, ''Roads We Choose'', rattle to a close, you feel compelled to
have another listen. It’s like a drug you can’t kick. No wonder he’s faced
some personality conflicts. Carry On causes enough in the listener to
last anyone a lifetime.
- Chris Long, BBC
Music
With his mane of jet black curls and distinctive rock
voice, Soundgarden frontman Chris Cornell was, despite not having quite
the wider profile of Vedder or Cobain, the coolest figure in the Seattle
grunge scene of the early '90s.
But since those glory days his career has arguably
been steady rather than stellar – though Audioslave fans may disagree
with this contention. The hair’s a lot shorter now too.
Reviewing the album’s decent but unspectacular second
single ‘Arms Around Your Love’ last week, I expressed hope that the album
might be a worthy showcase for Cornell’s undoubted vocal talent. And it’s
pleasing to report that there is much to like here.
Opener No Such Thing raises hopes with an effective
slow-building combination of quiet verses and rock out choruses led by
Cornell’s rarely matched voice, while Poison Eye threatens to similarly
hit the heights only to be let down at the crunch by a criminally tuneless
guitar solo, unusual on an album where the musical backing is otherwise
consistently strong.
She’ll Never Be Your Man is an uptempo bluesy workout
with duelling piano and slide guitar and album standout Killing Birds
is a mellow yet threatening song driven along by a chugging bassline and
vocals which recall Cornell’s work on the incredible Temple Of The Dog
album fifteen or so years ago.
And in a bold attempt to cover the almost-uncoverable,
Cornell takes on Michael Jackson’s Billie Jean and turns it into a Nick
Cave style murder ballad, slow and doom-ridden. The result is strangely
powerful, and though it doesn’t manage to banish thoughts of the original
in the listener’s mind it’s still a worthy try.
Carry On is a diverse affair between the rock histrionics
of Cornell’s Soundgarden and Audioslave days and the mellower grooves
of his work in Temple Of The Dog and previous solo album Euphoria Morning,
while also throwing blues and soul influences into the mix for good measure.
Possibly as a consequence of this diversity, the quality
of the songs dips here and there across the album’s 62 minutes. But rock
music has had relatively few singers who can bear comparison to Cornell.
For me, the closest I can come to summing up his sonorous, heartfelt delivery
is to describe him as the American Robert Plant.
High praise indeed, and probably blasphemy for some,
but that is what holds Carry On together, and he has rarely sounded better.
3 out of 5 stars
- Nick Thompson, Manchester
Evening News
The second solo album from former Soundgarden man
Chris Cornell is a really mixed offering. Occasionally good, sometimes
bad and frequently just plain average, it’s a frustrating affair that
never really ignites as it should.
In the 10 years since Soundgarden’s much lamented
split, Cornell has moved to France, sobered up, put out a critically-acclaimed
solo album and formed the supergroup Audioslave.
But he continues to be something of an enigma musically
– a distinct presence (especially vocally) who continually struggles to
realise his early potential. Carry On offers 16 tracks that veer from
the harder edge of No Such Thing and Poison Eye to the blues of Safe And
Sound via the cinematic scope of You Know My Name and the much talked
about cover version of Michael Jackson’s Billie Jean.
But as that list suggests, it’s a very mixed bag.
Billie Jean, in particular, stands out like a sore thumb. It’s a gritty
take that strips away the dancefloor beats in favour of a slower build,
almost ballad-style of lovelorn delivery.
You have to take notice of it – but you tend to scratch
your head afterwards in bewilderment.
Cornell’s Bond theme, You Know My Name is also a strange
offering and much maligned at the time of the release of Casino Royale.
I’m all for trying something different but it needed to be harder.
Carry On is on much surer footing when it keeps things
heavier. Album opener No Such Thing taps into the harder, more exhilarating
edge of his Soundgarden and Audioslave days, featuring some crunching
guitars and an equally emphatic set of vocals.
While Poison Eye continues the trend and suggests
the album might be a blistering return to form. It’s steeped in the type
of classic American rock values of bands like Pearl Jam. But the tender,
more commercial nods put things on the back foot, with Arms Around Your
Love a surprisingly drippy offering that’s way too sentimental. The melodies
seem to be reaching for a Californian sunshine vibe but there’s something
about the “lovely” chorus that grates. It’s just not in keeping with the
Cornell sound.
The blues guitar of Safe And Sound is a more interesting
offering that seems to be taking its cue from contemporary Eric Clapton,
while making its impassioned plea for world peace. It works – just. As
does She’ll Never Be Your Man, which hints at some R&B flavouring and
heralds another interesting shift.
Skip the average Ghosts and you reach Killing Birds,
another interesting experiment in alt-rock that finds Cornell resembling
Eddie Vedder. It’s a slow-builder of epic scope that gets better with
repeat listening.
But then you have to wait until Silence The Voices
for the album to really catch your attention again – another epic slow-builder
that emerges as a potential anthem for fans to embrace.
Cornell says of the album that he wanted to really
stretch himself and experiment – and there’s plenty of evidence of him
doing so.
But while the strength of its ambition is beyond doubt
and it draws on some excellent talent – including jazz bassist Miles Mosley
and legendary guitarists Gary Lucas and Brian Ray – there’s just a nagging
sense that Carry On should have been a great deal better. Perhaps Cornell
is still haunted by his past success…
Download picks: No Such Thing, Poison Eye, Safe And
Sound, Killing Birds, Silence The Voices, She’ll Never Be Your Man
Rating: 2.5 out of 5
- Jack Foley, IndieLondon
Given that he has fought depression and alcoholism,
the former Soundgarden and Audioslave singer could have been expected
to produce a more involved and involving set of songs than the 14 (including
his recent Bond theme and a workaday cover of Billie Jean) that make up
his second solo album.
For all that No Such Thing deals with suicide and
Arms Around Your Love with paranoia and possessiveness, sonically, Cornell’s
new material is frustratingly bland. Too often, it settles back into musical
predictability and relies on his extraordinary, sandpapered singing to
carry the weight. Flitting between songs aimed at fans of his former bands
and those that flirt with a more mainstream appeal, Carry On fails to
convince at either.
2.5 out of 5 stars
-Dan Cairns, The
Sunday Times
Rating: ***
Having written and performed the theme to the latest
Bond film, Casino Royale, the pertinently titled You Know My Name,
it was obvious the time was right for Cornell to resume the solo career
put on hold when he agreed to front Audioslave.
The rest of that band have returned to Rage Against
The Machine, presumably to rake in the revenue that reunions tend to generate.
Now Cornell has finally jettisoned all that Seattle grunge-laden baggage,
he is free to explore exciting new musical territory. At least that’s
the idea.
Then again, if it ain’t broke, why fix it? Rather
than going in for wholesale changes to the riff-driven success Cornell
enjoyed with Temple Of The Dog, Soundgarden and Audioslave, instead there
is a tweak here, a cute key change there, all drifting surreptitiously
towards the mainstream without getting submerged in it.
Arms Around Your Love is the most obvious
example, a well-crafted rock-out pop song that updates the post-Faces
feel of Rod Stewart.
While Cornell probably does not aspire to the faintly
embarrassing karaoke turn that the great ‘Jockney’ has become, he surely
covets the longevity of his career.
There is nothing boasting the rhythmic urgency of
Spoonman (from Cornell’s Soundgarden days) or the dark foreboding
of Black Hole Sun, but the bluesy menace and intriguing role reversal
in the lyric of ‘She'll Never Be Your Man’ is, thankfully, no less compelling.
Download these: Scar On The Sky, She'll Never Be Your
Man
- COLIN SOMERVILLE, Scotland
On Sunday
3 out of 5
Cornell's second solo album is as rugged a record
as you would expect from the former singer of the grunge chestbeaters
Soundgarden and Audioslave.
His hulking voice makes it sound like he is tearing
telephone directories in half while singing, whether on the expansively
cosmic Scar On The Sky, the almost poppy Your Soul Today
or an anguished cover of Billie Jean.
Cornell is clearly a master of his MTV-rock genre
- Silence The Voices and Finally Forever show some emotional
and musical subtleties - but after 16 tracks , all of which could be described
as "impassioned", you could go without hearing another guitar
crash or earnest vocal clench for quite some time.
- Victoria Segal, The Times (print edition)
Chris Cornell has a formidable musical CV, and
after having fronted two huge rock bands, he's now releasing his second
solo album, 'Carry On'. The first track
taken from it, 'Arms Around Your Love' is a refreshing change to the predictable
power-rock of his previous output. However, his gravelly voice wobbles
slightly upon the opening of the song, and this mid-tempo ballad stutters
upon its own lack of passion.
This is inoffensive, part-acoustic soft rock fare.
He may sing with seemingly genuine feeling, but while it's pleasant, it's
not different or diverting enough to be worthy of note.
- Stuart McCaighy, ThisIsFakeDIY
The second solo album from the former Soundgarden
and Audioslave frontman is called "Carry On," and that's exactly what
he does.
The disc covers the different facets of Cornell's
musical personality, ranging from familiar guitar rock-outs ("No Such
Thing") to the widescreen scope of "You Know My Name," the theme to last
year's James Bond revamp "Casino Royale."
Along the way, the greatest living screamer in rock
dials down his leonine roar, letting the honeyed edges of his voice carry
the freight on "Arms Around Your Love," which sounds engineered for mainstream
radio appeal, and lend an air of poignant gravitas to a stripped-down
cover of Michael Jackson's "Billie Jean."
Elsewhere on the disc, he wanders down the back roads
of country for the soulful, slightly bluesy "Safe and Sound" and the steel
guitar-driven "Finally Forever."
- Kevin Forest Moreau, The
Sunday Paper
Underwhelming Solo Shot from Soundgarden Screecher
Cornell has spent a long career searching for material
to do justice to his formidable vocals, with intermittent joy. Soundgarden
and Audioslave both complemented his throaty Gillan-esque roar only occasionally.
The poppy metal of "Carry On" comprises another entry
in Cornell’s catalogue of partial successes. There is one tremendous high
point - his superb Bond theme, “You Know My Name”, co-written with David
Arnold.
There is one jaw-dropping nadir - a baffling reading
of Michael Jackson’s “Billie Jean”. In between, there’s a lot of in-between.
- ANDREW MUELLER, Uncut Magazine
In a nutshell… The name's Cornell, Chris Cornell.
What's it all about? Cornell is famed for his
unique gravelly voice and he is still hitting the right notes on this
album. A few tracks reminiscent of Audioslave's Cochise or Soundgarden's
Spoonman would have been welcomed but the man who lent his voice to the
soundtrack of the latest Bond franchise is getting on a bit now at 42.
No Such Thing begins with a meaty riff that seemingly
announces Cornell's intentions and when Cornell bursts into the chorus,
the hairs stand up on the back of your neck; such is his vocal dexterity.
Poison Eye follows on from the opening track in terms
of offering an infectious hook and this is a typical toe-tapper. Cornell
is at his best on this type of track when he is posturing to high tempo
rock and roll.
Ballads then become flavour of the month as the album's
lead single a distorted, reflective Arms Around Your Love kicks in, followed
by the smooth She'll Never Be Your Man.
A stripped down, basic cover version of Michael Jackson's
Billie Jean is ambitious but just fails to hit the right notes. Top marks
for the attempt though.
Casino Royale track You Know My Name is classic Cornell,
all talk of dying and other morbid masculine angst as is his forte
Who's it by? Soundgarden were one of the pioneers
of grunge and formed back in 1984 in Seattle. They began to see success
in the 90s when Pearl Jam and Nirvana hit the big time.
1994’s Superunknown was the critically acclaimed album
that launched Soundgarden into the big league and spawned such classics
as Black Hole Sun and Spoonman.
When the band parted ways in 1997, Cornell decided
to go it alone and released Euphoria Morning two years later.
The supergroup Audioslave was created in 2001 along
with three of the members of Rage Against the Machine and enjoyed success
with their three albums before calling it a day in February of this year.
Cornell has fought off depression and alcoholism in
the past and his new album probably eclipses his first solo effort but
certainly doesn't match up to previous output with Soundgarden.
As an example… "Arm yourself because no one else here
will save you / The odds will betray you / And I will replace you." -
You Know My Name
Likelihood of a trip to the Grammys Although
there are a few decent tracks here, on a 16-song album that just won't
cut the mustard and so in short, there is no chance of a trip to the Grammys
for this former Grammy winner.
So is it any good? By far the best track on
the album is the Bond theme You Know My Name. It is what the rest of the
album should be but isn't - raw, beguiling and effortlessly cool. Cornell
seems to be enjoying himself on this well-produced track.
The best of the rest on Carry On include No Such Thing,
which is perhaps a little lyrically naive but is a stomping rock song
all the same.
Poison Eye is another high point, as Cornell goes
for an edgy number about redemption, "I saw the light," he croons. Arms
Around Your Love is catchy but unmemorable.
Aside from the She'll Never Be Your Man, Ghosts and
Scar on the Sky, it is all downhill. Safe and Sound could have been penned
by Wet Wet Wet which is not what you want from one of grunge's founding
fathers.
Another sour point is that the self-reflective, personal
tracks that Cornell has previously written for Soundgarden appear to have
been replaced with nothing lyrics that have no great significance - disappointing
considering his voice is still hugely and idiosyncratically powerful.
Cornell should get out his old Soundgarden records
and stick songs like Black Hole Sun and Burden in my Hand on repeat until
he can come away and write some songs with meaning rather than pedestrian
middle-of-the-road album fillers. Cornell's voice works best when there
is an edge to the music and that edge is sadly lacking here.
Rating: 6 out of 10
- Adam Bushby, inthenews.co.uk
This week, two generations of heavy metal figureheads
release solo albums. One is a loveable but emasculated old duffer who's
lucky to have any brain cells left to rub together thanks to voracious
enjoyment of the "rock star lifestyle"; the other is a young(er), buff
rock god archetype who looks like he pumps iron with far greater frequency
than he ingests illegal substances. So, given their present circumstances,
who is the more consummate rocker?
Chris Cornell has recently been introduced to a new
audience as the voice of the latest Bond theme, You Know My Name, a pacey
number which, in the pantheon of Bond themes, can reasonably claim to
be better than Die Another Day but lags some way behind For Your Eyes
Only for sheer inspiration.
He first hit the music scene radar as the extravagantly
hirsute frontman of Seattle grunge rockers Soundgarden, contemporaries
of Nirvana. In recent years, he has joined forces with visionary ex-Rage
Against The Machine guitarist Tom Morello to front Audioslave, a band
who have turned out to be considerably less than the sum of their parts.
Still, Cornell is a formidable rock hollerer. Of the
new rock royalty to emerge in the 1990s, only Pearl Jam's Eddie Vedder
was as much in danger of over-egging his vocal performance, but you might
as well flaunt what you've got, and Cornell has a nicely bluesy tone.
It's the songs he applies his pipes to that are generally the problem.
Fortunately, Carry On has its share of muscular rock
stormers plus some nicely textured rootsier numbers - and lots of stylised
shots of Cornell looking mean and moody in the CD booklet. Never one to
knowingly undersell a vocal, he is as comfortable spouting chest-beating
rock nonsense such as "there's no such thing as nothing" with the conviction
of a zealot as he is putting his all into pleasingly hoary ballads such
as Silence The Voices or Safe And Sound, proving his worth as a soulful
rocker in the Joe Cocker mould.
Poison Eye features a great strutting vocal over a
trim, pugnacious backing, and he just about carries off sub-Free stomper
Your Soul Today, which asks, somewhat dubiously, "can I visit your arms,
can I visit your legs?"
But he stretches our tolerance too far with the constipated,
pompous Scar On The Sky and his atrocious, gurning version of Michael
Jackson's Billie Jean. This is utterly superfluous, from an album which
eventually outstays its welcome.
Ozzy Osbourne has also reached a new audience in recent
times, via the docu-soap The Osbournes, but even prior to his rebirth
as a global TV star he was already an entertainment goliath as the frontman
of seminal heavy metallers Black Sabbath, with an extra-curricular CV
which included urinating on a national monument, onstage livestock mutilation
and trying to kill his wife.
Public affection runs high for the incorrigible old
dodderer, but anyone who has seen recent footage of him being trundled
out on stage to meet fan demand can see how blatantly far past his musical
peak he has wandered.
He is pictured on the front cover of Black Rain getting
soaked with a perplexed do-I-have-to-stand-here? look on his face. So
it is a pleasant surprise to hear him on such combative form on his first
new studio album in six years.
Written with his guitarist Zakk Wylde and performed
by a band which includes ex-Faith No More drummer Mike Bordin, Black Rain
checks off plenty of the stock heavy metal themes - death, destruction,
damnation, desecration - with some fairly perfunctory lyrics. But, for
an old school metaller like Ozzy, it's all in the conviction of his delivery.
On opening track, Not Going Away, he puts so much bile into his performance
it sounds like he's about to throw up. The band leave him to it - Wylde
is too busy mangling his fretboard to notice.
Caveman rocker I Don't Wanna Stop manages to be both
brutal and catchy, while final track Trap Door bristles with a Motörhead-like
nastiness - and I can think of no higher compliment for a rock track.
But it's too much of a task to keep up the momentum, so he takes a breather
on laborious rock ballad Lay Your World On Me, and gets all sentimental
on Here For You as he remembers friends who "bought a one-way ticket"
and pledges to stick around for wife Sharon.
On the title track, he returns to the same territory
as Sabbath standard War Pigs, with suitable references to "Judgement Day",
and a brattish vocal reminding us war is, like, stoopid. He's back on
the same track on Civilize The Universe, but his most amusing political
diatribe is God Bless The Almighty Dollar, on which this Beverley Hills-dwelling,
jet-setting, multi-millionaire recovering alcoholic former hellraiser
rails against the evils of excess and consumption.
Cornell would probably attack such subject matter
with stony-faced gravity, but Ozzy somehow manages to have fun - which
is probably why he's still at it long after he should have retired.
- unnamed reviewer, The
Scotsman
Chris Cornell is an American icon. Through his reign
as Soundgarden’s dark grunge god to his stint at the helm of classic rock
band Audioslave, he’s never failed to push the boundaries of genre, whether
turning base metal into alternative gold or teaching a rap-rock act like
RATM the meaning of modulation.
His ornate 1999 solo album Euphoria Morning failed
to catch on, with its reclusive creator’s deepening substance abuse problems
perhaps contributing to its commercial collapse. Cornell’s certainly not
making the same mistake again - clean, sober and solo, he’s touring the
world for the next eighteen months.
The songs on Carry On are generally more accessible
than those on his former solo effort, but that’s not to say he’s abandoned
his old instinct for experiment. With legendary producer Steve Lillywhite
behind the desk he’s trying on different styles for size, mixing the all-out
attack of opener No Such Thing and the drama of Bond theme You Know My
Name, with the wistful pop of lead-off single Arms Around Your Love and
the romantic, Rufus Wainwright-ish sweep of Disappearing Act. Although
few listeners will take all sixteen tracks to heart, nearly all have something
bold to offer.
Then, there’s the much-referenced cover of Michael
Jackson’s dance classic Billie Jean - chosen, Cornell says, for its sheer
improbability. In his hands it becomes a brooding murder ballad set to
a slow-burning blues: depending on your attitude to the original, you’ll
either love its dark drama or reject its audacity.
The voice that launched a thousand sonic assaults
is as powerful as ever, but Cornell seems eager to use it in new and unexpected
ways - the Princely falsetto of Today is a major surprise, Safe And Sound
sees him toying with blue-eyed soul and it has a deep, bell-like resonance
on anti-war anthem Silence The Voices. Backup comes from a range of musical
stylists, including Paul McCartney sideman Brian Ray, jazz bassist Miles
Mosley and flamboyant New York guitarist Gary Lucas.
Lyrically the album mingles unusual love songs with
meditations on change and loss. One of the most powerful in the latter
category is Ghosts, a backward look at our older selves and those who
need to invest in them, while the tender country ballad Finally Forever
contrasts with a wry look at sexual politics in She’ll Never Be Your Man.
Cornell may not yet have found a defining sound for
his work outside the confines of a band, but maybe that’s not the point.
Far from showing us a legend content to rest on his laurels, the sheer
variation of Carry On is the sound of an artist evolving and exploring.
It’s a road trip into the unknown.
4.5 out of 5
- Clare O'Brien, Subba-Cultcha
Chris Cornell - Arms Around Your Love
With this record Chris Cornell goes truly solo - leaving
Audioslave and James Bond behind to preview his upcoming album Carry On.
Previous Cornell solo productions have hinted
at a sunny, poppier sound that brings out an unexpected soulful quality
in his voice, something Arms Around Your Love taps in to. As ever the
voice is irresistible, flexing in the bridge passage and taking the chorus
in its stride. Occasionally you feel the singer is coasting a little,
taking time out from his rock excesses, but when the songs effortlessly
evoke a summer weekend, you'll be happy to permit him that luxury.
- Ben Hogwood, MusicOMH.com
Chris Cornell - Arms Around Your Love (Polydor)
Chris Cornell has had a varied career to date, from
his life in Soundgarden as the über-cool rock god of the grunge scene
to a slightly less successful foray into bombastic '70s-influenced rock
with Audioslave. And now, following a Bond theme tune of all things, comes
the lead single from the forthcoming Carry On, his second solo
album after 1999’s Euphoria Morning.
Produced by Steve Lillywhite, button-pusher for the
likes of U2, the Rolling Stones and Morrissey, Arms Around Your Love
is a slow-paced rock ballad with a hook. Though not a classic song it
perfectly shows off Cornell’s instantly recognisable vocal ability – think
of his delivery in the classic Temple Of The Dog cut Say Hello 2 Heaven
and you’re pretty close. The song’s nowhere near as good as that marker
but the man’s voice sounds as amazing as it ever has. Here’s hoping the
rest of the album is worthy of that talent.
Rating: 3 out of 5
- Nick Thompson, Manchester
Evening News 18 May 2007
Grunge godfather falls
in love, turns down the volume, does the moonwalk
Though famous for fronting hard-rock institutions
Soundgarden and Audioslave, Chris Cornell has always had a romantic, introspective
side (see Temple of the Dog and the Singles soundtrack). Newly solo and
happily married, Cornell further distances himself from arena bravado
on Carry On, preferring singer-songwriter sensitivity and woodsy love
ballads.
No matter his guise, the constant remains his always-excellent
larynx, which has lost some yelp but gained a rugged vulnerability. His
relationship songs (“Safe and Sound”) benefit from the added delicacy,
but they’re outnumbered by plodding midtempo tunes and pseudo-shamanistic
earsores (“We will rip the night/Out of the arms of the sun”). As demonstrated
by his tortured reading of Michael Jackson’s “Billie Jean,” when Cornell
strains for significance, he squeezes the life out of his music.
-Tim Grierson, Blender, June 2007 issue (thanks
Di)
Carry On (Universal)
There's no denying that Chris Cornell has one of the
great voices in rock. In Soundgarden, he bellowed his way through some
of the greatest songs of the grunge era, and as frontman for the somewhat
contrived supergroup Audioslave, he seemed to regain, at least initially,
some of the exhilaration that was absent from his solo debut, 1999's Euphoria
Morning.
Likewise, Carry On (available June 5) is a lackluster
collection of rock songs that suffers from tired melodies, banal lyrics
and Cornell's distinctly workmanlike performances. The big riffing of
'No Such Thing' opens the album promisingly, as does the follow-up, 'Poison
Eye'. But Carry On soon descends into the mediocrity of 'Arms Around'
and 'She'll Never Be Your Man'. Cornell's cover of Michael Jackson's 'Billie
Jean', slowed down into an acoustic dirge, is a less disastrous concept
than it sounds on paper, but, no, it doesn't work.
At least the album closes on a strong note
with Cornell's recent James Bond theme, 'You Know My Name', although that
opinion may only be because I'm a fan of the movie it came from, Casino
Royale. Time for a Soundgarden reunion, perhaps?
- Sean Plummer, Access Magazine
(thanks Mel)
Soundgarden and Audioslave growler's second solo
album
The finest singer of the grunge generation has never
really had the material to showcase that talent. Now, he and producer
Steve Lillywhite have made the album he should have made post-Soundgarden,
rather than the dreary Euphoria Morning.
Cornell's sometimes astounding vocals sound engaged
for the first time in a decade and he's writing fully formed songs at
last, be it the turbo-charged No Such Thing, the epic Safe And
Sound or You Know My Name, the Casino Royale theme that
forgot to include the words "casino" or "royale".
More rewarding than promised, he even reinvents Michael
Jackson's Billie Jean successfully.
3 out of 5
- John Aizelewood, Q Magazine, June 2007 issue
(thanks Ali)
Change has been a constant in Chris Cornell's life
since Soundgarden split in 1997. Sober and over 40 now, he lives in France
with his wife and daughter. His first solo album (1999's Euphoria Morning)
was lauded in the press, but disregarded by the public. And his supergroup
Audioslave eventually fizzled after a trio of albums.
But on Cornell's long-awaited sophomore solo effort,
it's obvious something hasn't been altered: the voice, a distinguished
instrument still pure and resonant--and authoritative enough to take on
Michael Jackson's "Billie Jean" and turn it from throbbing dancefloor
anthem to portentous ballad. The unforeseen cover is sequenced midway
through 14 tracks that have Cornell softening the edges of his music without
losing the power of the messenger.
No less than a half-dozen songs have hit potential,
including "Arms Around Your Love," with its soaring chorus, the R&B-flecked
"She'll Never Be Your Man," and "No Such Thing," where restrained verses
give way to crunchy-riffed choruses. He uses the bluesy "Safe and Sound"
to call for peace, asking "Why can't we pull it together?"
Ten years after the breakup of his pioneering band,
Chris Cornell has done just that, and it's evident that the change has
done him good.
-Scott Holter, Amazon
Heralding from the delta scored shores of Seattle,
Washington State, Cornell earned his rock wings as the gravelly voiced
front-man of popular grunge band Soundgarden. After several years in the
doldrums, the band shot to fame during the early 90's, riding the crest
of a wave triggered by Nirvana and the emergence of the grunge movement.
Success, however, did nothing to temper the bands exploration of dark
and brooding subject matter. Hits like Black Hole Sun and Fell on Black
Days explored themes of substance abuse, death and existentialism, and
were typical of the bands output at the time. This reflected their troubled
and self-destructive nature, applying particularly to Cornell who, as
a teen, was prone to bouts of depression and latterly, alcoholism.The
band eventually called it quits in 1997, despite continuing ascendancy,
attributed largely to conflict within the band.
After the split, Cornell kept himself busy writing
his first solo album Euphoria Morning which received critical acclaim
but proved a commercial failure. Shortly after, he teamed up with Tom
Morello, Tim Commerford and Brad Wilk of Rage Against the Machine, forming
supergroup Audioslave. Recording their first album, the band almost came
unstuck as Cornell descended into a bout of alcoholism that nearly ended
him. However, back from the brink, he cleaned himself up and there followed
a very productive period in Cornell's career. With a sound more reminiscent
of Soundgarden than Rage..., the group mixed hard rock ballads with cooler,
low tempo tracks and proved a popular draw over the course of three big
selling albums. The band also toured heavily, playing many notable venues,
including a history making first in Cuba (where the gig was free, naturally).
In 2006 Cornell began work on his second solo project, Carry On. Suggesting
to many that his days with Audioslave were numbered, sure enough, he announced
his split from the band in February of this year.
Now in his 40's, sober and free from any group commitments,
the Cornell-of-new turns out to be, well, the Cornell-of-old. Indeed,
his new tracks blend so seamlessly with his earlier work that one can
have trouble differentiating between 'Cornell' eras when heard blind.
Soundgarden blends into Audioslave blends into Cornell solo. Whilst the
music itself feels a little more light weight than his earlier work (smoother
guitar riffs, less prominent drums and higher production values), the
lyrics are reassuringly angsty. No Such Thing deals, in a roundabout way,
with suicide. The fluffily titled Arms Around Your Love whose tune no
doubt intentionally plays reminiscent of a Michael Bolton track (worryingly
so, in fact), fortunately subverts with themes of loss and jealousy and
proves an interesting distraction, if a little middle-of-the-road.
Also included is the recently released You Know My
Name, the theme tune to last year's Bond re-imagining Casino Royale. Cornell,
no stranger to supplying tracks for films, was an astute choice for crooning
duties on this movie, and he and David Arnold have crafted a real toe-tapper.
Given its fullest expression and backed with sweeping orchestral flourishes,
Cornell's voice still has the power to impress. And extra points should
be attributed to the man for securing the ill-chosen Madonna to dankest
corners of Bond history.
Of course, how much you like Cornell's latest work
will depend very much on how receptive you are to having some mildly engorged
disappointment at the world delivered to you in quite a derivative rock-like
fashion. So if all this talk of Soundgarden and Audioslave makes you yearn
for some contemporary rock with an early-Nineties, post-Nirvana feel to
it, then Cornell's new album could be just what you're looking for. On
the other hand, the phrase "Run away" may spring to mind.
6 out of 10
|